- Montreal Deathmatch Champion (pseudo title);
- ICW Quebec Hardcore title;
- IWS World Heavyweight title;
- February 5, 2005 – CZW: Mike Quackenbush defeated Alex Shellley and Sexxxy Eddy and Arsenal to win Junior Heavyweight title!
- February 12, 2005–EWR: Arsenal defeated Dave Silva in Quebec City..
- March 5, 2005–International Wrestling Syndicate: Kurt Lauderdale defeated The Arsenal with the help of the Evil Ninja..
- March 12, 2005 – CZW: Sexxxy Eddy defeated Arsenal..
- March 26, 2005–IWS: Kurt Lauderdale & The Arsenal beat Crazy F’N Manny & Evil Ninja in a Fans Bring the Weapons match..
- April 9, 2005–EWR: Excess won four way over Dave Silva, Arsenal and Jake Matthews..
- April 23, 2005–IWS: Crazy F’N Manny attacked the Arsenal with a broken beer bottle taking him out of the main event.
- May 28, 2005–International Wrestling Syndicate: The Evil Ninja defeated The Arsenal in a No Ropes Barbed Wire Match..
- July 9, 2005–IWS: Sexxxy Eddy defeated Frankie the Mobster and The Arsenal and Evil Ninja in a Cage to capture the IWS title!