- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Southern Tag Team titles w/Scotty Sabre defeating Bull Buchanan & Mr. Black (March 15, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Southern Tag Team titles w/Scotty Sabre defeating Derrick King & Jason Lee (April 4, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Southern Tag Team titles w/Scotty Sabre defeating Slash & Damien (July 19, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Southern Tag Team titles w/Flash Flanagan defeating Slash & Damien (October 17, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Southern Tag Team titles w/Slash defeating Shelton Benjamin & Brock Lesnar (April 22, 2001);
- October 12, 1999– Ohio Valley Wrestling: B.J Payne defeated Vito Andretti..
- October 24, 1999– Ohio Valley Wrestling: B.J Payne defeated Adam Riggs..
- November 7, 1999– OVW: Nick Dinsmore defeated B.J Payne..
- November 30, 1999–OVW: Mr. Black defeated B.J Payne..
- December 26, 1999– OVW: B.J Payne defeated Derrick King..
- 2000: BJ Payne was briefly signed to a developemntal contract with World Wrestling Federation..
- January 15, 2000 – WWF Jakked: Jack Black & Jerry Miller & BJ Payne defeated Pet Gas & Rodney & Joey Abs…
- May 25, 2000– Brian Pillman Memorial Show: B.J Payne defeated Rico Constantino..
- September 9, 2000– WWF Jakked: Chaz & D’Lo Brown defeated B.J Payne & Doug Basham..
- June 27, 2001– Ohio Valley Wrestling: Bobby Eaton & Ron Waterman defeated B.J Payne & Damien..
- August 8, 2001– OVW: B.J Payne & Damien defeated Sean Casey & Chris Michaels..
- August 22, 2001– OVW: Randy Orton & Mark Henry defeated B.J Payne & Damien..
- April 10, 2002– OVW: Flash Flanagan & Trailer Park Trash defeated B.J Payne & Mr. Black..
- October 30, 2002– OVW: Travis Bane & Seven defeated B.J Payne & Damien..
- November 13, 2002– OVW: B.J Payne & Batista defeated Travis Bane & Seven..
- December 4, 2002– OVW: B.J Payne & Matt Morgan defeated Lance Cade & Rene Dupree..
- March 15, 2003– WWE Velosity: Bill Demott defeated B.J Payne..
- March 26, 2003– OVW: Doug Basham defeated B.J Payne..
- April 5, 2003– NWA TNA Xplosion: James Storm defeated B.J Payne..
- April 20, 2003– NWA TNA Xplosion: Chris Harris defeated B.J Payne..
- April 23, 2003– OVW: Rene Dupree & Lance Cade defeated Mark Henry & B.J Payne..
- August 15, 2003– OVW: Prototype, Rico Constantine & Jerome Crony defeated B.J Payne, Connie Swail & Damien..
- May 13, 2005– X3 Wrestling: Billy Gunn & Road Dogg defeated B.J Payne & Scotty Sabre..
- ~~~The promoter, Tim Shady, disappeared at intermission without paying a lot of the guys..
- Later 2005: B.J. Payne retired from wrestling due to a back and neck injury..
- January 2006: Russell Payne Jr. was named head coach for Mansfield High Schools football team..
- ~~~rolf whitney wrote: He is head football coach at Lexington (Ohio) High School, not Mansfield.
Originally from Massilon, Ohio
Billed from Chicago, Illinois