- July 2005: Bobby Jay, a southpaw, shattered the finger in freak accident playing softball..
- November 24, 2005: “Beautiful” Bobby Jay had the middle finger on his left hand amputated..
- ~~~There is nothing left of the shattered part of the finger (and is held together with a screw)..
- ~~~The finger is locked in a 30 degree angle at the middle knuckle and sticks out when a fist is made..
- ~~~The doctors exact words were “You can’t swing a door if it has no hinges”..
- March 29, 2006–Top Rope Championship Wrestling: Zack Mercury & Oz defeated Beautiful Bobby Jay & Bobby Driver..
- April 1, 2006–Independent Wrestling Manitoba: Honky Tonk Man w/Tony Condello beat “Beautiful” Bobby Jay w/Bobby Driver..
- April 21, 2006–NWA ECCW: Kurt Sterling beat Bobby Jay with a rollup after referee Anya slapped Jay after he kissed her..
- June 2, 2006–River City Wrestling: Beautiful Bobby Jay defeated Billy Blaze…
- June 17, 2006–TRCW: Bobby Jay beat T.J. Bratt in a No-DQ match when Honky Tonk Man smashed a guitar over Bratt’s head!
- October 21, 2006–Minnesota Independent Wrestling: Magnus Maximus defeated “Beautiful” Bobby Jay…………..
- October 21, 2006–Minnesota Championship Wrestling: “The Icon” Sean Russell defeated “Beautiful” Bobby Jay…
- June 9, 2007–Top Rope Championship Wrestling: Bobby Jay defeated Rob Stardom to win the TRCW Heavyweight Title