- MEWL (Main Event World League Hardcore) title defeating Christian Faith in a Last Man Standing Match ();
- MCW (Mega Championship Wrestling) Light Heavyweight title defeating Shawn Blaze ();
- MEWL (Main Event World League) North American Heavyweight title defeating Wilbur Whitlock in a Steel Cage ();
- OCW (Ohio Championship Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Ryan Midnite defeating Irish Airborne in a TLC Match ();
- September 17, 2005–Main Event Promotions: Christian Vaughn vs. Justin Diaz (Ivory Guest Referee)..
- February 4, 2006 – M.E.W.L: Justin Diaz defeated Christian Vaughn in a Falls Count Anywhere match by ref stoppage
- Summer 2006–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Christian Vaughn vs Buff Bagwell..
- July 14, 2006: Christian Vaughn made his IWA Mid-South Debut vs Ricochet,
- July 15, 2006–IWA Mid-South: Christian Vaughn vs “Omega” Aaron Draven..
- September 1, 2006–IWA Mid-South: Christian Vaughn vs Ricochet..
- January 27, 2007–IWA Mid South: Jack Thriller beat Tarek the Great and Billy Roc and Christian Vaughn in a 4-WAY
- September 4, 2007–Main Event World League: Christian Vaughn vs. Wilbur Whitlock (Steel Cage Match)..
- September 15, 2007–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Robby Starr defeated “The Natural” Christian Vaughn
- October 6, 2007–M.E.W.L: Johnny Gunn beat Christian Vaughn in a Ladder match to win the MEWL North American title..
- January 13, 2008–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Christian Vaughn & Ryan Midnite vs. Irish Airborne (TLC Match)..
- August 6, 2008–Big Time Wrestling: Christian Vaughn & Robby Starr vs. Jeff Cannon & Bobby Fulton..