- (Illinois) Classic Championship Wrestling Regional title (1st ever);
- (Indiana) Collesium Championship Wreslting Tag Team titles w/Chris Chaos;
- HPW Heavyweight title defeating ????? ();
- NWA Wisconsin X-Division title defeating ????? ();
- CCW Tag Team titles w/???? defeating ??? & ??? ();
- UWC Heavyweight title defeating ????? ();
- CCW Intercontinental title defeating ????? ();
- NWA Wisconsin Heavyweight title defeating Dysfunction (2006);
- 2005–NWA MIDWEST: The Black and the Brave (Tyler Black & Marek Brave) defeated The All-Stars (Bryce Benjamin & Chandler McClure) and The BJ Xpress (Brandon Thomaselli & Josh Abercrombie) and The Usual Suspects (Chris Chaos & Diego Corleone) in a four-way elimination match to become #1 contenders to the NWA Midwest Tag Team Title.
- August 20, 2005–AWA Slam: Diego Corleone defeated Vito “2 Fingers” Fontaine by cheating..
- 2006: Dysfunction defeated Diego Corleone to win the NWA Wisconsin Heavyweight Title in De Pere, Wisconsin..
- November 4, 2006–New Breed Wrestling Alliance: Jon Divosi defeated Diego Corleone to win the NBWA Heavyweight title..
- April 21, 2007–NBWA: “Dangerous” Drew Thomas beat Diego Corleone by Submission to retain the NBWA Heavyweight title..
- June 2, 2007–DXWA/ACPW: Diego Coleone won a Battle Royal in Fox Lake, Illinois..
- June 3, 2007–New Breed Wrestling Alliance: Drew Thomas defeated Deigo Corleone in a 30 Minute Iron Man Match