- National AAU (Amateur Athletic Union) title (3 times);
- World Heavyweight title defeating Joe Stecher (1917);
- Earl Caddock won 3 National AAU (Amateur Athletic Union) titles before turning to professional wrestling..
- April 9, 1917: Earl Caddock defeated Joe Stecher to capture the prestigious World Heavyweight championship in Omaha, NE..
- January 30, 1920: Joe Stecher defeated Earl Caddock to recapture the World Heavyweight title..
- Retired on June 7, 1922.
- Earl Caddock died on August 25, 1950 after major surgery for a heart attack. He was 62.