Title History
- JAPW (Jersey All-Pro Wrestling) Television title defeating Ghost Shadow and Rain Child in a 3-WAY (September 13, 2002);
- JAPW (Jersey All-Pro Wrestling) Cruiserweight title
- UCW World title;
- UCW United States title;
- JCW (Jersey Championship Wrestling) Cruiserweight title;
- JCW (Jersey Championship Wrestling) Television title;
- JCW (Jersey Championship Wrestling) J-Cup title;
- IHPW United States title;
- JAPW Light Heavyweight title defeating Azrael and Insane Dragon and Jack Evans in a 4-WAY (February 28, 2004);
- ROH (Ring of Honor) Pure title defeating John Walters (March 5, 2005);
- JAPW (Jersey All Pro Wrestling) Heavyweight title by winning a four-way (May 21, 2005)
- JAPW (Jersey All-Pro Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Jay Lethal by winning a 3-WAY (October 28, 2006);
- BTW (Big Time Wrestling) Heavyweight title defeating Brother Runt (December 1, 2006);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X-Division title defeating Chris Sabin (June 17, 2007);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X-Division title defeating Kurt Angle (September 9, 2007);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X-Division Wrestler of the Year 2007 (Awarded January 24, 2008);
- ACE (American Championship Entertainment) Tag Team titles w/Mo Sexton defeated Style & Finesse (February 9, 2008);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X Division title defeating Johnny Devine (February 10, 2008);
- MWF (Millenium Wrestling Federation) Television title defeating Tommaso Ciampa (June 21, 2008);
- TNA World Tag Team titles w/Consequences Creed defeating Robert Roode & James Storm (January 8, 2009);
- JAPW (Jersey All Pro Wrestling) Heavyweight title defeating Kenny Omega (February 28, 2009)
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X Division title defeating Douglas Williams (September 16, 2010);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X Division title defeating Amazing Red (September 25, 2010);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X Division title defeating Robbie E (December 16, 2010);
- ROH (Ring of Honor) Television title defeating El Generico (October 1, 2011);
Career Highlights
In The Beginning:
- Jamar Shipman had a 4.0 GPA studying Multi-Media at Union County College..
- Jamar Shipman won a contest put on by Jersey All-Pro Wrestling to win 6-months of free training..
- Jamar Shipman trained under Mikey Whipwreck, but considered himself a protege of Danny Maff (aka Mafia)..
Jersey All-Pro Wrestling & Jersey Championship Wrestling:
- February 2, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Ghost Shadow & Jay Lethal defeated Deranged & Rainchild.
- April 5, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Deranged b Ghost Shadow and Jay Lethal and Rainchild in a 4-WAY..
- April 6, 2003–First JCW/UWA TV Taping: Livewire defeated Jay Lethal..
- May 3, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Rainchild defeated Roderick & Sedrick Strong..
- May 18, 2002–Jersey Championship Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Ray Child defeated Eddie Batten & Eric Baine..
- June 7, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Rainchild beat Wasted Youth and The SAT in a 3-WAY..
- June 22, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Ghost Shadow beat Jay Lethal and Deranged and Azriel in a 4-WAY..
- July 13, 2002–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal b Low Rida..
- August 10, 2002–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Matt Stryker vs Jay Lethal ended in a draw..
- September 13, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal beat Ghost Shadow and Rain in a 3-WAY to win Television title..
- November 8, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal beat Deranged and Tony Lozaro in a 3-WAY to retain the TV Title..
- November 16, 2002–Jersey Championship Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Rob Eckos..
- December 13, 2002–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal beat Rain and Tony Lazaro in a 3-WAY to retain the TV Title..
- January 18, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Tony Lazaro to retain the JAPW Television title..
- January 25, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal (TV Champion) vs Aerial Assassin ended in a No Contest..
- February 22, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Rain defeated Deranged & Dixie..
- April 12, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Dixie to retain the JAPW Television title..
- September 27, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Skinhead Ivan defeated Jay Lethal to win the JAPW Television title..
- September 28, 2003–Jersey Championship Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Simon Diamond..
- November 8, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Skinhead Ivan defeated Jay Lethal to retain the JAPW Television title..
- December 13, 2003–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Derek Wylde..
Jersey All-Pro Wrestling (Light Heavyweight Champion) + Ring of Honor (Special K’s “Hydro”):
- January 9, 2004 – ROH/JAPW: Azriel & Insane Dragon & Jay Lethal defeated Dixie & Deranged & Lit..
- January 10, 2004 – Ring of Honor: Special K (Joey Matthews/Slim J/Deranged/Hydro) defeated Dunn & Marcos/The Carnage Crew..
- February 14, 2004 – ROH 2nd Anniversary: Special K (Dixie/Hydro/Izzy) defeated Carnage Crew (Devito/HC Loc/Credible)..
- February 28, 2004–JAPW: Jay Lethal beat Azrael and Jack Evans and Insane Dragon in a 4-WAY to win Light Heavyweight title..
- March 6, 2004–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal won three-way over Insane Dragon and Azrael..
- March 13, 2004 – ROH Afternoon Show: Hydro (of Special K) defeated Roderick Strong..
- March 13, 2004 – ROH Evening Show: The Carnage Crew defeated Special K in the second ever Scramble Cage Match..
- ~~~~The Carnage Crew (HC Loc//DeVito//Credible/Masada/Dusty Rhodes) ||| Special K (Dixie/Izzy/Slim J/Abyss/Hydro/Angel Dust)
- April 24, 2004–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Azrael to retain the JAPW Light Heavyweight title..
- May 14, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Dan Maff defeated Jay Lethal..
- May 15, 2004 – ROH: John Walters beat Izzy & Roderick Strong & Masada & Hydro & Trent Acid in 6-WAY Mayhem..
- May 16, 2004 – ROH: Alex Shelley defeated Hydro by crossface submission..
- June 5, 2004–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Amazing Red and Sonjay Dutt in a 3-WAY (crowd chanted “F*ck TNA!”)
- June 12, 2004 – ROH: Hydro defeated Chad Collyer and Superstar Steve and Ray Gordy in a 4-Corners Survival..
- June 19, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Amazing Red beat Deranged & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt in a 4-WAY Elimination match..
- June 24, 2004 – ROH: CM Punk defeated Hydro (aka Jay Lethal)..
- July 10, 2004–HIPW: Jay Lethal defeated Josh Daniels in a Best 2/3 Falls match..
- August 7, 2004 – ROH: Alex Shelley defeated Jay Lethal (pinned) and Ace Steel and 2 Cold Scorpio in a 4-WAY..
- August 14, 2004 – CZW: Bobby Quance defeated Jay Lethal and Arik Cannon and Nate Webb (sub for Roderick Strong)..
- August 28, 2004 – ROH: Alex Shelley defeated Jay Lethal..
- September 4, 2004–NWA Wildside 5th Anniversary: Jay Lethal defeated Jerrelle Clark..
- September 11, 2004 – ROH: Jay Lethal (formerly Hydro) defeated Matt Stryker..
- September 17, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Amazing Red..
- September 18, 2004–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Azrael in a “Ladder” match..
- September 25, 2004–NWA Upstate New York: Jay Lethal & Azrael teamed up to win a Tag Team tournament..
- ~~~~Jay Lethal & Azrael beat The Olsen Twins (1st), then The Outkast Killas (2nd), and then Izzy & Dixie (finals)..
- October 2, 2004 – ROH: Low Ki w/Julius Smokes defeated Jay Lethal (Smokes harassed Lethal’s parents in crowd)..
- October 15, 2004 – ROH: Chad Collyer defeated Jay Lethal..
- October 16, 2004 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Delirious..
- October 30, 2004–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Sonjay Dutt to retain the Light Heavyweight title..
Jersey All-Pro Wrestling & Ring of Honor: Jay Lethal & Samoa Joe:
- November 5, 2004 – ROH: John Walters & Nigel McGuinness defeated Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal..
- November 6, 2004 – ROH: Jimmy Rave w/The Embassy defeated Jay Lethal after the Raves Clash finisher..
- November 19, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Mike “The Shooter” Kruel defeated Jay Lethal..
- November 20, 2004–New York Wrestling Connection: Dan Barry defeated Jay Lethal..
- December 4, 2004 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Prince Nana’s Weapon of Masked Destruction (Flash Flanagan under a mask)..
- December 10, 2004–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Azrael beat Jay Lethal to win the LHW title in a “belt vs loser leaves town” match..
- December 17, 2004–Fusion Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Ryan Drago..
- December 26, 2004 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Prince Nana’s Weapon of Mask Destruction #2..
- January 14, 2005–PWF Northeast: Jason Blade defeated Jay Lethal..
- January 15, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal & Josh Daniels defeated The Outkast Killaz..
- January 28, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Dan Maff defeated Jay Lethal to retain the JAPW Heavyweight Title..
- ~~~~Jay Lethal pinned Dan Maff and was awarded the title but the decision was overturned..
- ~~~~Dan Maff tried to hand the belt over to Lethal, who turned his back, then Dan Maff whacked Lethal with the belt!
- ~~~~Referee Sean Hanson took off his shirt, revealing a Dan Maff shirt!!!!!
- February 19, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Jimmy Rave w/Prince Nana to become #1 Contender to the Pure Title..
- ~~~The match happened immediately following that match: John Walters defeated Jay Lethal to retain the Pure Title..
- February 25, 2005–Pro Wrestling Unplugged: “The Technician” Tom Carter defeated Jay Lethal..
- February 26, 2005–Frank Goodman’s UXW: Chris Candido defeated Mike Kruel and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY..
- March 5, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated John Walters w/Prince Nana to win the ROH Pure title!
- March 12, 2005 – ROH: Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal defeated CM Punk & Spanky (sub for Steve Corino) with help from Stevie Richards!!!!
- March 26, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal was awarded the vacant JAPW title, but refused to take it unless he earned it..
- ~~~~This set up a the following match: Homicide defeared Jay Lethal to capture the vacant JAPW Heavyweight title..
- April 1, 2005–Pro Wrestling Unplugged: Jay Lethal & Azrael & Insane Dragon beat Mark’d in a lucha style match..
- April 2, 2005 – ROH: BJ Whitmer & Jimmy Jacobs defeated Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal to win the vacant Tag Team titles..
- April 15, 2005–Frank Goodman’s UXW: Sonny Siaki won six-way over Deranged, Azriel, Dan Barry, Grim Reefer and Jay Lethal..
- April 16, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Spanky to retain the Pure Title..
- April 23, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Ash Samuels | Jay Lethal defeated B-Boy..
- April 30, 2005–Northeast Wrestling: Xavier defeated Jay Lethal (standing ovation)..
- May 7, 2005 – ROH: Samoa Joe defeated Jay Lethal to capture the Pure title (Rottweilers attacked afterwards)..
- ~~~~In the main event: The Rottweilers (Homicide & Low Ki) defeated Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal (Copkilla on Lethal)..
- ~~~~Homicide hit Jay Lethal with the Cop-killa finisher — Lethal was fitted with a neck brace and stretchered out!
- May 21, 2005–JAPW: Jay Lethal won four-way over Kevin Steen and Homicide and Samoa Joe to win the JAPW title!!!
- June 4, 2005–JAPW: Jay Lethal beat Steve Corino (After, Corino handcuffed Lethal to the corner and put his dad in a crossface)..
- June 18, 2005 – ROH: Low Ki vs Jay Lethal ended in a NO CONTEST..
- July 8, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal & Dixie defeated The Heartbreak Express (Sean & Phil Davis)..
- ~~~~In the main event: C.M. Punk (allowed to choose his opponent) defeated Jay Lethal to to retain the Ring of Honor title..
- July 9, 2005 – ROH: Homicide w/Julius Smokes defeated Jay Lethal..
- July 15, 2005–Ballpark Brawl IV: Chris Sabin beat Roderick Strong, Jay Lethal, Petey Williams, Shawn Spears & Mastiff (6-WAY)..
- July 16, 2005–JAPW: Jay Lethal & Jay Lethal’s dad & Charlie Haas defeated Steve Corino & Ricky Landell & Rick Silver..
- ~~~~After the match, Haas turned on the Lethals to set up Lethal vs. Haas for the JAPW title on 9/10..
- July 23, 2005 – ROH: The Rottweilers (Homicide & Low Ki & Ricky Reyes) defeated Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal & James Gibson..
- August 12, 2005 – ROH: Low Ki vs Jay Lethal ended in a NO CONTEST when Homicide interfered and Matt Hardy made the save!
- August 13, 2005 – ROH: Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal defeated Homicide & Low Ki by DQ.
- August 20, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Ricky Reyes (w/Julius Smokes & Grim Reefer)..
- August 21, 2005–NWA Cyberspace: Josh Daniels vs Jay Lethal ended in a NO CONTEST..
- September 2, 2005–Full Impact Pro: Spanky & Sal Rinauro defeated Jimmy Rave & Jay Lethal to retain the Tag Team titles..
- September 3, 2005–Full Impact Pro: Jay Lethal defeated Chasyn Rance..
- September 10, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Charlie Haas to retain the JAPW title..
- September 17, 2005 – ROH: Low Ki w/Julius Smokes defeated Jay Lethal in a Fight Without Honor to lift his suspension..
- ~~~~Later on in an official sanctioned match: Jay Lethal defeated Low Ki with an amazing top rope Dragon Suplex..
- September 24, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Sal Rinauro to advance to the Survival of the Fittest main event..
- ~~~~Roderick Strong defeated Austin Aries and Colt Cabana and Jay Lethal and Chris Daniels and Samoa Joe in the Finals!
- September 25, 2005–NWA Cyberspace: Jay Lethal & Josh Daniels defeated Matt Bentley & Mike Kruel..
- October 1, 2005 – ROH: Nigel McGuinnesss defeated Jay Lethal to retain the Pure title..
- October 2, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Nigel McGuinness and Davey Andrews and Claudio Castagnoli in a 4-Corner Survival..
- October 8, 2005–Defiant Pro Wrestling: “Sudden Impact” Dylan Kage defeated Jay Lethal..
- October 14, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal & Samoa Joe defeated The Embassy (Alex Shelley & Jimmy Rave)..
- October 15, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Jimmy Jacobs w/Lacey..
- October 22, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Steve Corino to keep JAPW title in a Dog Collar match..
- October 29, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Curry Man (aka Christopher Daniels) w/Allison Danger..
- November 12, 2005–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated B-Boy to retain the JAPW title..
- November 19, 2005 – ROH: Austin Aries & Roderick Strong defeated Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal..
Jersey All-Pro Wrestling & Ring of Honor: Jay Lethal (Heel):
- December 3, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Samoa Joe (Lethal turned heel and attacked his mentor after the match!)..
- December 17, 2005 – TNA Impact: Samoa Joe defeated Jay Lethal by Submission..
- December 17, 2005 – ROH: Jay Lethal defeated Samoa Joe and Christopher Daniels and BJ Whitmer in a 4-Corner Survival..
- January 7, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Rhino beat Jay Lethal to win the JAPW title after a top rope piledriver through a table..
- January 14, 2006 – ROH: Christopher Daniels defeated Jay Lethal..
- January 15, 2006 – Final Resolution Pre-show: Petey Williams & Eric Young & A-1 defeated Lance Hoyt & Jay Lethal & Kenny King..
- January 20, 2006–Full Impact Pro: Roderick Strong defeated Jay Lethal..
- January 21, 2006–NWA Cyberspace: Frankie Kazarian defeated Jay Lethal..
- January 27, 2006 – ROH: Austin Aries & Roderick Strong defeated American Dragon & Jay Lethal to retain the Tag Team titles…
- January 28, 2006 – ROH: Jimmy Yang defeated Jay Lethal..
- January 28, 2006 – TNA Impact: World Champion Jeff Jarrett defeated Jay Lethal in a Non-title match..
- February 4, 2006 – TNA Impact: A.J. Styles defeated Jay Lethal (Samoa Joe watched from the stage with the bloody towel)..
- February 11, 2006 – TNA Impact: Samoa Joe (X-Division Champion) defeated Jay Lethal and Chasyn Rance in a 3-WAY..
- February 12, 2006 – Against All Odds: Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley and Alex Shelley and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- February 25, 2006 – ROH: Samoa Joe defeated Jay Lethal in a grudge match..
- February 18, 2006 – TNA Impact: Jay Lethal defeated Shannon Moore and Roderick Strong in a 3-WAY to Qualify for Team USA..
- February 18, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Rhino beat Jay Lethal and Teddy Hart in a 3-WAY to retain the JAPW title..
- March 4, 2006 – TNA Impact: Elix Skipper & David Young & Simon Diamond beat Jay Lethal & Shark Boy & Lance Hoyt (Xplosion)
- ~~~ON TV: Petey Williams & Bobby Roode & Eric Young w/Scott D’Amore defeated Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal..
- March 12, 2006 – Destination-X: Alex Shelley defeated Jay Lethal..
- March 24, 2006–Pro Wrestling Elite: Milano Collection A.T. defeated Jay Lethal..
Total Nonstop Action + Ring of Honor + Other Indies:
- March 25, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal beat Simon Diamond & Elix Skipper & David Young..
- March 25, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: A.J. Styles defeated Jay Lethal in an excellent match..
- April 1, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams & Bobby Roode defeated Jay Lethal & Cassidy Riley in a dark match..
- April 8, 2006–Liberty States Wrestling: Christian Cage defeated Jay Lethal to retain the NWA World Heavyweight title..
- April 15, 2006–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Xavier and Antonio Thomas and EC Negro in a 4-WAY…
- April 20, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Team Canada (Williams/Roode/Young/A-1) defeated Team USA (Dutt/Sabin/Lethal/Shelley)..
- April 23, 2006 – TNA Lockdown: Japan (Minoru Tanaka/Hirooki Goto/Black Tiger) beat USA (Sonjay Dutt/Alex Shelley/Jay Lethal)..
- April 27, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Samoa Joe defeated Jay Lethal to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- April 29, 2006–TNT Pro Wrestling – HOG-A-MANIA: Jay Lethal defeated Chris Hero..
- May 13, 2006 – CZW Best of the Best: Roderick Strong defeated Claudio Castagnoli and Jay Lethal (Lethal eliminated)..
- May 13, 2006 – Ring of Honor: Nigel McGuiness defeated Jay Lethal (sub for Alex Shelley) to retain the Pure title..
- May 14, 2006 – TNA Sacrifice: Jay Lethal represented Team USA in the World X-Cup Gauntlet Match (won by Petey Williams)..
- May 20, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Rhino defeated Jay Lethal to retain the JAPW Heavyweight title..
- May 25, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Senshi defeated Jay Lethal and Alex Shelley and Shark Boy in a 4-WAY..
- ~~~~ Kevin Nash showed up after the match and beat up Jay Lethal and called himself the Cruiserweight Bully..
- May 26, 2006–Full Impact Pro: Jay Lethal & Davey Richards defeated American Dragon & Jimmy Rave (Lethal pinned Dragon)..
- May 27, 2006–Full Impact Pro: American Dragon defeated Jay Lethal in 25:00 to retain the FIP title..
- June 1, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Alex Shelley in an X-Division match when Kevin Nash’s interference backfired..
- ~~~~Kevin Nash & Alex Shelley attacked Lethal after the match until Chris Sabin made the save and challenged Nash for Slammiversary!
- June 2, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Xavier defeated Jay Lethal..
- June 9, 2006–TNA Hardcore War: Jay Lethal defeated Sonjay Dutt with a release Dragon Suplex..
- June 10, 2006–TNA House Show (LSW): Jeff Jarrett w/Simon Diamond defeated Jay Lethal w/Mrs. Lethal in an Open Challenge..
- June 17, 2006–JAPW: Frankie Kazarian defeated Jay Lethal and A.J. Styles in a 3-WAY to retain the Light Heavyweight title..
Total Nonstop Action + Ring of Honor + Other Indies:
- June 18, 2006 – TNA Slammiversary: Senshi beat Alex Shelley & Petey Williams & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt & Shark Boy in a 6-WAY..
- June 22, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Alex Shelley w/Johnny Devine in a match taped for Xplosion..
- July 6, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Kevin Nash (w/Shelley & Devine) brought Chris Sabin to the ring in a body bag and Jay Lethal made the save..
- July 15, 2006 – ROH: Jimmy Rave & Sal Rinauro w/Prince Nana defeated Colt Cabana & Jay Lethal..
- July 13, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D & Rhino & Jay Lethal defeated Team Canada (Lethal got the pin, thus gets match of choice)..
- July 14, 2006–Big Time Wrestling: Xavier defeated Jay Lethal and E.C. Negro and Antonio Thomas in a 4-WAY..
- July 16, 2006 – TNA Victory Road: Jay Lethal & Chris Sabin defeated Kevin Nash & Alex Shelley w/Johnny Devine..
- July 20, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jeff Jarrett defeated Jay Lethal (Sting convinced him to go for the BIG ONE) to retain the NWA World title..
- July 21, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Abyss defeated Jay Lethal..
- July 22, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Alex Shelley defeated Jay Lethal..
- July 29, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Teddy Hart defeated Jay Lethal in a #1 Contenders match..
- August 3, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams beat Jay Lethal and Alex Shelley and Sonjay Dutt and Frankie Kazarian in a 5-WAY..
- August 5, 2006 – Ring of Honor: Nigel McGuiness defeated Jay Lethal and Claudio Castagnoli and Chris Daniels in a 4-WAY..
- August 10, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal beat Kevin Nash & Alex Shelley & Johnny Devine..
- August 10, 2006–TNA House Show: The Naturals (Andy Douglas & Chase Stevens) defeated Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal..
- August 11, 2006–TNA House Show: Chris Daniels & AJ Styles beat Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal to retain the Tag Team titles..
- August 12, 2006–TNA House Show: Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal defeated The Diamonds In The Rough (Elix Skipper & David Young)..
- August 13, 2006 – TNA Hard Justice: Senshi beat Petey Williams and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY to retain the X-Division title..
- August 17, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal beat Alex Shelley & Johnny Devine & Petey Williams..
- August 19, 2006: AWA Anarchy: Jay Lethal defeated Archadia and Mo Sexton in a 3-WAY in Union City, New Jersey..
- August 31, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams & Senshi..
- September 13, 2006–Pro Wrestling Xplosion (debut): Christopher Daniels defeated Jay Lethal..
- September 14, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal pushed Johnny Devine in a cart and crashed it into the ring post!
- September 15, 2006–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Acradia defeated Jay Lethal by DQ..
- September 21, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams in an X-Division match..
- September 28, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal beat Senshi & Alex Shelley & Johnny Devine..
- October 12, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sabin & Lethal & Dutt & Shark defeated Senshi & Shelley & Devine & Petey Williams..
- October 14, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Josh Daniels in Milford, Pennsylvania..
- October 19, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: X-Division Champion Senshi defeated Jay Lethal in a Non-title match..
- October 22, 2006 – TNA Bound For Glory: Jay Lethal was in the Kevin Nash Open Invitational X-Division Gauntlet Battle Royal!
- October 26, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal failed to advance in the reverse Battle Royal “Fight foe the Right” Tournament..
- October 28, 2006–JAPW: Jay Lethal & Azrieal beat The Outkast Killaz and The SAT in a 3-WAY to win the Tag Team titles!
- November 3, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Josh Daniels..
- November 5, 2006–Pro Wrestling Xplosion: A.J. Styles defeated Jay Lethal in Long Island, New York..
- November 10, 2006–TNA House Show: Senshi defeated Jay Lethal…..
- November 16, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: “The Samoan Submission Machine” defeated Jay Lethal by Submission..
- November 19, 2006 – TNA Genesis: The Naturals w/Shane Douglas defeated Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal w/Jerry Lynn..
- November 24, 2006–IWA Mid South: Chuck Taylor defeated Jay Lethal to retain the IWA-MS World title..
- November 30, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin defeated Sonjay Dutt and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders match..
- December 1, 2006–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Brother Runt to win the BTW Heavyweight Title.
- December 9, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Xavier beat AJ Styles and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY to win the vacant NW Title.
- December 11, 2006 – TNA Turning Point: Senshi beat Austin Starr and Alex Shelley and Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt in a 5-WAY..
- December 15, 2006–TNA House Show: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders match.
- December 16, 2006–TNA House Show: A.J. Styles defeated Jay Lethal in South Hill, Virginia..
- January 19, 2007–International Wrestling Cartel: Jay Lethal defeated Jason Cage in Elizabeth, Pennsylvania..
- January 20, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Azrieal defeated The Outcast Killaz to retain the Tag Team titles.
- January 27, 2007—Powerhouse Wrestling of New England: Jimmy Jact Cash beat Jay Lethal in Worcester, Massachusetts..
- February 1, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Austin Starr defeated Alex Shelley and Sonjay Dutt and Jay Lethal and Jerry Lynn in a 5-WAY..
- February 12, 2007 – TNA Against All Odds: Frankie Kazarian & Johnny Devine defeated Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal in a Pre-show match.
- February 22, 2007 – TNA Xplosion: Petey Williams & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt defeated Serotonin (Bentley & Kazarian & Devine)..
- February 22, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jerry Lynn beat Austin Starr & Senshi & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt in a 5-WAY Ladder Match..
- February 25, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Mr. T.A. in a Dog Collar match.
- March 1, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jerry Lynn & Senshi & Jay Lethal defeated Chris Sabin & Austin Starr & Alex Shelley.
- March 2, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Antonio Thomas to retain the BTW Heavyweight title..
- March 3, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Malice to retain the BTW Heavyweight title..
- March 8, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: James Storm & Robert Roode & Eric Young defeated Petey Williams & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal..
- March 10, 2007–Northeast Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Josh Daniels in Torrington, Connecticut..
- March 15, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Jerry Lynn and Kaz (Frankie Kazarian) in a triple threat match..
- March 17, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Azrieal defeated Homicide & B-Boy to retain the Tag Team titles.
- March 24, 2007–NWA Midwest: Jason Dukes defeated Jay Lethal..
Total Nonstop Action (The Black Machismo) + Independent Wrestling:
- April 5, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Kevin Nash gave Jay Lethal a “Macho Man” costume and called him The Black Machismo..
- April 12, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: The Black Machismo (Jay Lethal) defeated X-Division Champion Chris Sabin in a Non-title match..
- April 15, 2007 – TNA Lockdown: Chris Sabin beat Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt and Alex Shelley and Shark Boy in an Xscape Match..
- April 21, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Christopher Daniels to retain the BTW Heavyweight title..
- April 21, 2007–Northeast Wrestling: Xavier defeated Jay Lethal in Bristol, Connecticut..
- April 26, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt won a 4-WAY Tag match and will face Chris Sabin in a 3-WAY at Sacrifice..
- ~~~~Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal defeated Alex Shelley & Kaz and Shark Boy & Senshi and Jerry Lynn & Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- April 30, 2007–TNA TV Tapings: “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated LAX’s Homicide in a match taped for Xplosion..
- May 5, 2007–NWA Midwest: Jason Dukes defeated Jaysin Strife and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY in Streamwood, Illinois..
- May 10, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley defeated The Black Machismo (Jay Lethal) & Sonjay Dutt..
- May 11, 2007–IWC Super Indy VI: Larry Sweeney defeated Jay Lethal in the 1st Round of the Super Indy VI Tournament..
- May 12, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: John Walters w/Talia Madison defeated Jay Lethal to win the BTW Heavyweight title..
- May 13, 2007 – TNA Sacrifice: Chris Sabin defeated Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt in a 3-WAY to retain the X-Division title..
- May 19, 2007–JAPW: Jay Lethal & Azrieal defeated The Outcast Killaz by DQ to retain the JAPW Tag Team titles.
- June 9, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: LAX (Homicide & Hernandez) defeated Jay Lethal & Azrieal to win the Tag Team titles.
- June 17, 2007 – TNA Slammiversary: “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Chris Sabin to capture the X-Division title!
- June 2007: Kevin Nash dumped Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal and will now begin to manage Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley..
- June 21, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Samoa Joe defeated The Black Machismo (c) and Chris Sabin to win the X-Division title!
- June 30, 2007–IWA Mid South Wrestling: Jay Lethal defeated Tracy Smothers and Z-Barr in a 3-WAY.
- July 2, 2007–TNA TV TAPINGS: ” The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams in a dark match..
- July 8, 2007–Maryland Championship Wrestling: Christopher Daniels defeated Jay Lethal in the 1st Round of the Shamrock Cup..
- July 16, 2007–TNA TV Tapings: Black Machismo & Eric Young defeated Serotonin (Havok & Martyr) — (taped for Xplosion)..
- July 17, 2007 – TNA Victory Road: The Black Machismo participated in a 10-Man X-Division Gauntlet Ultimate-X Match!
- August 2, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Triple X (Christopher Daniels & Senshi w/Elix Skipper) defeated Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt..
- August 12, 2007 – TNA Hard Justice: Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt defeated Chris Daniels & Senshi and Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley..
- August 16, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal w/Sonjay Dutt defeated Christopher Daniels w/XXX in a #1 Contenders match..
- August 31, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Mister T.A. w/Johnny Fabulous beat Jay Lethal to become the 1st ever Dog Collar Champion.
- September 6, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Abyss & Jay Lethal defeated Kurt Angle & Sting (Abyss pinned Kurt Angle to win!)..
- September 7, 2007–Pro Wrestling Syndicate: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Lanny Poffo w/Chrissy Rivera..
- September 8, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Grim Reefer defeated Deranged and Azrieal and Jay Lethal in a 4-WAY.
Total Nonstop Action (The Black Machismo) + Independent Wrestling:
- September 9, 2007 – TNA No Surrender: Jay Lethal defeated Kurt Angle (in his second match) to win the TNA X-Division title!
- September 13, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Christopher Daniels defeated X-Division Champion Jay Lethal in a Non-title match..
- September 22, 2007–Powerhouse Wrestling of New England: Jay Lethal beat Paul E Normous by DQ in Worcester, Massachusetts..
- September 29, 2007–MWF: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated “Canadian Superstar” J-Busta by DQ in Somerville, Ohio..
- ~~~~Jay Lethal & Slyck Wagner Brown & Beau Douglas beat The Canadian Superstars (J-Busta & Dave Cole) & Jason Rumble.
- October 11, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal (with taped ribs) defeated Havok (aka Johnny Devine)..
- October 14, 2007 – TNA Bound For Glory: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Christopher Daniels to retain the X-Division title..
- October 27, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Azrieal beat Blackout (Ruckus & Sabian) in Rahway, New Jersey.
- November 1, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal started a storyline with So-Cal Val becoming his “Elizabeth”..
- November 8, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D (Brothers Ray & Devon) defeated Abyss & “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal..
- ~~~~After the match: Team 3-D continued to assault Jay Lethal until the Motor City Machine Guns made the save!
- November 10, 2007–ACE: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Alex Shelley to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- November 11, 2007 – TNA Genesis: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val defeated Sonjay Dutt to retain the X-Division title..
- ~~~~After the match: Team 3-D attacked Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt and cornered So-Cal Val before stealing the X-Division belt..
- November 15, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D took a mystery member of the X-Division hostage and made a list of demands..
- ~~~~The entire X-Division came to his rescue – but the hostage (Havok) was a traitor and helped Team 3-D destroy everyone!
- November 22, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: A.J. Styles defeated Jay Lethal and Christian Cage in a 3-WAY Turkey Bowl Qualifier..
- November 24, 2007–Millennium Wrestling Federation: Jay Lethal beat Tommaso Ciampa by DQ in Somerville, Massachusetts..
- November 29, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D defeated Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal in a Street FIght with help from Johnny Devine..
- December 1, 2007–ACE Action Zone: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal beat Light Heavyweight Champion Giovanni Marranca by DQ
- ~~~~”Black Machismo” Jay Lethal & Azrieal defeated Style & Finesse (Mike Donovan & Rob Vegas) in a tag team match..
- December 2, 2007 – TNA Turning Point: Team 3-D & Johnny Devine defeated C.Sabin & A.Shelley & J.Lethal in a Tables Match..
- December 6, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D & Johnny Devine defeated Jay Lethal & Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley in a Ladder Match..
- ~~~~This match was for “possession” of the X-Division belt, not to become X-Division champion (Jay Lethal is still the Champion)..
- December 8, 2007–Jersey All Pro Wrestling : “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Kenny Omega..
- December 9, 2007–Pro Wrestling Syndicate: Teddy Hart & Ruckus defeated Jay Lethal & Human Tornado in New Jersey..
- December 13, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Johnny Devine in a Lumberjack Strap match..
- December 15, 2007–ACE Action Zone: Jay Lethal & Killa S defeated The BS Express (Ed & Tom)..
- December 20, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D brought out midgets dressed as Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley & Jay Lethal..
- ~~~~Brother Ray pretended to be Santa and let each midget sit on his lap and tell him what they want for Christmas..
- ~~~~Team 3-D started to beat up the three midgets until Jay Lethal, Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley ran down for the save!
- ~~~~ Jay Lethal & Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin defeated Team 3-D & Johnny Devine in a Double North Pole Match..
- ~~~~Christmas Party: So-Cal Val had Mistletoe and wanted to kiss Black Machismo but Sonjay Dutt stole the kiss!
Total Nonstop Action (The Black Machismo) + Independent Wrestling:
- January 6, 2008 – TNA Final Resolution: Team 3-D & Johnny Devine defeated Shelley & Sabin & Lethal in an Ultimate-X Match..
- ~~~~3-D used a Ladder to get the X-Division belt – there was an “unwritten” rule that you couldn’t use a Ladder in U-X matches..
- January 19, 2008–Jersey All Pro Wrestling : Jay Lethal defeated Chris Hero in Jersey City, New Jersey
- January 24, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jeremy Borash & So Cal Val announced Jay Lethal as the TNA X-Division Wrestler of the Year!
- ~~~~Jay Lethal said he has lost his smile and he is made as hell and he will start by taking it out on Johnny Devine!
- ~~~~Johnny Devine defeated Jay Lethal in a Street Fight with help from Team 3-D to capture the TNA X-Division title!!
- January 31, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D & J.Devine destroyed Shelley & Sabin & Lethal with kendo sticks, chairs, and tables!
- February 7, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Robert Roode vs. Jay Lethal (not there) didn’t get started because Booker T attacked Roode..
- February 9, 2008–ACE Action Zone: Jay Lethal & Mo Sexton defeated Style & Finesse to win the ACE Tag Team titles..
- February 10, 2008 – TNA Against All Odds: Jay Lethal & Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley defeated Team 3-D & Johnny Devine..
- ~~~~This was a Hardcore Street Fight – which ended with Jay Lethal pinned Johnny Devine to recapture the TNA X-Division title!
- ~~~~As a result, both members of Team 3-D will be forced to wrestle under a strict 270 lbs weight restriction in TNA competion..
- February 16, 2008–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Archadia defeated Jay Lethal in Rahway, New Jersey..
- February 21, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jim Cornette and some X-Division wrestlers honored Jay Lethal with a Thank You ceremony..
- ~~~”The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal got down on one knee and nervously asked So-Cal Val if she would go out on a date with him…
- ~~~So-Cal Val hesitated and said “Ohhhh yeah!” (Carbon copy of when Randy “Macho Man” Savage asked Elizabeth to marry him).
- February 28, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams & Scott Steiner w/Rhaka Khan defeated Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt…
- March 6, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: The Black Machismo Jay Lethal participated in a Destination-X Battle Royal (Won by Curry Man)..
- ~~~”The GURU” Sonjay Dutt (Lethal’s best friend) was lurking around ringside flirting with So-Cal Val during the Battle Royal..
- March 8, 2008–ACW: Jay Lethal vs. Mo Sexton ended in a No Contest when Joe Hardway & William Wyeth interfered..
- ~~~”Hollywood” Joe Hardway & William Wyeth defeated Mo Sexton & Jay Lethal to win the AWE Tag Team titles..
- March 9, 2008 – TNA Destination-X: “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal beat Petey Williams to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~Scott Steiner interfered and Petey Williams nailed the Canadian Destroyer on Lethal but So-Cal Val pulled the referee out..
- ~~~Rhaka Khan went after So-Cal Val but “The GURU” Sonjay Dutt got between them while Jay Lethal scored the pinfall..
Total Nonstop Action (The Love Triangle) + Independent Wrestling:
- March 13, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal & So-Cal Val on their date at Universal Studios..
- ~~~The bumped into “The GURU” Sonjay Dutt to became a third wheel offering to show So-Cal Val the “secret spots”..
- March 20, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal was at a restaurant with So-Cal Val when Sonjay Dutt showed up acting as a waiter..
- March 27, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal was at the gym with So-Cal Val and Sonjay Dutt once again showed up out of nowhere..
- April 3, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal was in a hot tub with So-Cal Val until Sonjay Dutt popped up from under the water!
- April 13, 2008 – TNA Lockdown: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal won a 6-WAY X-Scape Match to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~~”The Black Machismo” defeated Sonjay Dutt and Shark Boy and Curry Man and Johnny Devine and Consequences Creed..
- ~~~~Jay Lethal defeated Johnny Devine in the Finals with help from both his best friend Sonjay Dutt & his girlfriend So-Cal Val..
- April 17, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val defeated Johnny Devine to retain the X-Division title..
- ~~~~After the match; “Little Petey Pump” Petey Williams whacked Jay Lethal with his briefcase and cashed in his title shot!
- ~~~~Petey Williams w/Rhaka Kahn defeated “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val to capture the TNA X-Division title!
- May 11, 2008 – TNA Sacrifice: Kaz won the first ever 10-Man Terror Dome match to earn a future TNA X-Division title shot..
- ~~~~Kaz beat Lethal and Dutt and Sabin and Shelley and Devine and Curry Man and Shark Boy and Rave and Creed in a 6-WAY..
- May 15, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Kaz & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt defeated The Rock & Rave Infection & Johnny Devine…
- ~~~After the match; Jay Lethal asked So-Cal Val to marry him at Slammiversary – and she responded “Ohhhhh yeeaaahh!!!”
- May 29, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt (w/So-Cal Val) defeated The Rock & Rave Infection w/Christy Hemme..
- May 31, 2008–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Booker T w/Sharmell defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal.
- June 5, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt threw a bachelor party for his best friend, “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal at the Pink Taco..
- June 8, 2008 – TNA Slammiversary: Jay Lethal and So-Cal Val’s wedding was interrupted and ruined by the “Best Man” Sonjay Dutt..
- ~~~George “The Animal” Steel, Kamala, “Birdman” Koko B. Ware and Jake “The Snake” Roberts attended the wedding ceremony..
Total Nonstop Action (Victory Road: Black Machismo vs. Sonjay Dutt) + Independent Wrestling:
- June 12, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt defeated Consequences Creed (Jay Lethal attacked Sonjay Dutt as So-Cal Val cheered)…
- June 19, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal invited Sonjay Dutt to the Pink Taco (night club) where they had a huge intense brawl..
- June 21, 2008–Millenium Wrestling Federation: Jay Lethal beat Tommaso Ciampa in a Lumberjack match to win the TV title
- June 26, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: So-Cal Val started to sympathize with Sonjay Dutt and decided to postpone her wedding to Lethal..
- ~~~Sonjay Dutt showed up at ringside soliciting donations for the “Save Val Fund” getting his little GURU’s to chant “Set Val Free!”
- ~~~So-Cal Val scolded Sonjay Dutt publically for his actions; Jay Lethal ran down, but Dutt quickly hid behind his little GURU’s..
- July 13, 2008 – TNA Victory Road: Sonjay Dutt defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val in a Grudge match..
Total Nonstop Action (Hard Justice: Black Machismo vs. Sonjay Dutt) + Independent Wrestling:
- July 17, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: So-Cal Val mysteriously stuck up for Sonjay Dutt and said Lethal was being way too hard on him..
- ~~~Sonjay Dutt beat Eric Young and Johnny Devine in a 3-WAY (After the match, Jay Lethal attacked Sonjay Dutt with a chair)..
- ~~~So-Cal Val convinced Lethal to stop the assault. Dutt whacked the chair against the post and pretended that Lethal hit him!
- July 24, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: So-Cal Val visited Sonjay Dutt in the hospital recovering from his “head injury” suffered last week.
- ~~~So-Cal Val left the room, and Sonjay Dutt held up Val’s wedding ring (from Jay Lethal) – which he stole right off of Val’s finger!
- July 31, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Curry Man & Shark Boy defeated Lance Rock & Jimmy Rave & Johnny Devine..
- ~~~After the match; Jay Lethal noticed that Val had lost his wedding ring and concluded that she never wanted to marry him..
- August 7, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt gave Val her stolen wedding ring and a bogus story and she foolishly forgave him!
- ~~~”Black Machismo” Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed defeated The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin)..
- August 10, 2008 – TNA Hard Justice: Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val defeated Sonjay Dutt in a Black Tie Brawl & Chain Grudge Match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal was just brutal with Sonjay Dutt. So-Cal Val begged him to ease up, and she walked out when Jay refused to let up..
Total Nonstop Action (Black Machismo vs. Sonjay Dutt) + Independent Wrestling:
- August 14, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sheik Abdul Bashir defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal in an X-Division match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal was freaked out over what happened at Hard Justice and said that Val has to choose between him and Sonjay Dutt..
- August 21, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: So-Cal Val was a guest on Karen’s Angle, but Sonjay Dutt and Jay Lethal also showed up on set..
- ~~~Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt started brawling until Lethal went to throw a punch and accidentally hit Val in the face with his elbow!
- August 28, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed defeated Petey Williams (w/Rhaka Khan) & Sheik Abdul Bashir..
- August 30, 2008–A.W.E.S.O.M.E: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Colin Delaney in Toms River, New Jersey..
- September 14, 2008 – TNA No Surrender: Sonjay Dutt beat Jay Lethal in a Ladder of Love match when So-Cal Val turned on Lethal!
Total Nonstop Action (Bound For Glory) + Independent Wrestling:
- September 18, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Booker T w/Sharmell defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal..
- September 20, 2008–Jersey All Pro Wrestling: Danny Demanto beat Dan Maff and Eddie Kingston and Jay Lethal in a 4-WAY..
- September 27, 2008–ACE: Joe Harway beat Jay Lethal and Mo Sexton and Vince Steele in a 4-WAY to retain the ACE Title..
- October 2, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Booker T & Team 3-D defeated Christian Cage & A.J. Styles & “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal..
- October 9, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Consequences Creed defeated Petey Williams and Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt in a 4-WAY..
- ~~~This was the first time that Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt were in the ring together since Val betrayed Lethal and sided with Dutt..
- October 12, 2008 – TNA Bound For Glory: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal won an X-Division Steel Asylum #1 Contenders match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal-Sonjay Dutt-Chris Sabin-Alex Shelley-Shark Boy-Curry Man-Super Eric-Petey Williams-Jimmy Rave-Johnny Devine.
Total Nonstop Action (Feast of Fired) + Independent Wrestling:
- October 23, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sheik Abdul Bashir defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- October 24, 2008–Big Time Wrestling: Jason Styles defeated Jay Lethal to retain the BTW Title with the help from Shannon Ballard.
- November 6, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sting & Kurt Angle & Kevin Nash defeated Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed & Eric Young..
- November 9, 2008 – TNA Turning Point: Eric Young won the X-Division Rankings Elimination Match against nine other wrestlers..
- ~~~Consequences Creed-Jay Lethal-Sonjay Dutt-Homicide-Petey Williams-Jimmy Rave-Doug Williams-Volador-Hiroshi Tanahashi
- November 13, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Sting defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal to retain the TNA World Heavyweight title.
- November 20, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed defeated Hiroshi Tanahashi & Sonjay Dutt w/So-Cal Val..
- November 29, 2008–ACE Action Zone (1 Year Anniversary): Mo Sexton defeated Jay Lethal in a Lumberjack match..
- December 4, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed & Eric Young beat The Sheik & Sonjay Dutt & Jimmy Rave..
- December 7, 2008 – TNA Final Resolution: Jay Lethal, Homicide, Hernandez, & Curry Man earned cases in a Feast of Fired match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal’s briefcase was immediately opened, and he found out that he won a shot at the TNA World Tag Team Titles..
Total Nonstop Action (The Consequences Are Lethal) + Independent Wrestling:
- December 11, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Alex Shelley defeated Jay Lethal in the 1st Round of the X-Division title Tournament..
- December 13, 2008–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Don Juan defeated Kevin Steen & El Generico..
Jay Lethal won for “Best X-Division Wrestler” in the 2008 Online World of Wrestling Awards..
- January 8, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed defeated Beer Money Inc. to win the TNA Tag Team titles!!!
- January 11, 2009 – TNA Genesis: Beer Money beat Creed/Lethal and Morgan/Abyss in a 3-WAY to win the TNA Tag Team titles
- ~~~Robert Roode & James Storm w/Jackie Moore beat Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal (champs) and Matt Morgan & Abyss..
Total Nonstop Action (Lethal Consequences) + Independent Wrestling:
- January 15, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Lethal Consequences (Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed) defeated Matt Morgan & Abyss..
- February 5, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Eric Young (sub for Consequences Creed) defeated The Motor City Machine Guns..
- ~~~Before the match; Beer Money Inc. attacked Consequences Creed while the Machine Guns just stood there watching it happen..
- February 8, 2009 – TNA Against All Odds: Beer Money defeated Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed to retain the Tag Team titles..
- ~~~~Jackie Moore passed a chain into James Storm and he used to knock out Jay Lethal! Roode pinned Lethal to win the match..
Total Nonstop Action (Ultimate X) + Independent Wrestling:
- February 12, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Lethal Consequences defeated The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin)..
- ~~~After the match; the Guns offered a handshake and it was accepted – but then turned and kicked them straight in the crotch!
- February 19, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: The Motor City Machine Guns defeated Lethal Consequences in a Tag Team Street Fight..
- February 26, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Alex Shelley beat Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed in a 4-WAY Ladder match..
- ~~~After the match; SUICIDE flew in on a zip-line, picked up the X-Division title and dropped it on Shelley, and then disappeared..
- February 28, 2009–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Jay Lethal won a #1 Contenders Rumble Match..
- ~~~~MAIN EVENT: Jay Lethal defeated Kenny Omega to win the JAPW World Heavyweight title.
- March 12, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Creed & Homicide & Hernandez beat Booker T & Scott Steiner & Shelley & Sabin..
- March 15, 2009 – TNA Destination X: SUICIDE (Christopher Daniels) won an Ultimate X match to win the TNA X-Division title!
- ~~~SUICIDE defeated Alex Shelley (c) and Chris Sabin and Jay Lethal and Consequences Creed to WIN the TNA X-Division title.
- Total Nonstop Action (X-Scape) + Independent Wrestling:
- March 28, 2009–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: JAPW World Champion Jay Lethal defeated Dan Maff..
- March 26, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Participated in a Gauntlet Match where the co-winners get to be captains for Lethal Lockdown..
- April 2, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: The Sheik & Kiyoshi & NO LIMIT defeated Jay Lethal & Creed & Homicide & Hernandez..
- April 11, 2009–WSU/NWS: Jay Lethal & real life girlfriend Miss April participated in the King & Queen of the Ring Tournament..
- ~~~~”Black Machismo” Jay Lethal & Miss April defeated Helter Skelter & Trixie Lynn in a 1st Round match..
- ~~~~”Black Machismo” Jay Lethal & Miss April defeated Bison Bravado & Annie Social in a 2nd Round match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal & Miss April defeated Damian Demanto & Jana in the Finals to win the King & Queen of the Ring Tournament..
- April 18, 2009–JAPW: JAPW World Champion Jay Lethal defeated Dan Maff after new D Factor member Trent Acid interfered..
- April 19, 2009 – TNA Lockdown: SUICIDE (Christopher Daniels) won the annual X-Scape match to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~SUICIDE defeated Jay Lethal and Consequences Creed and Sheik Abdul Bashir and Kiyoshi to retain the TNA X-Division title..
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling:
- April 23, 2009 – iMPACT: Beer Money Inc. defeated Lethal Consequences in the Team 3-D Invitational Tournament..
- May 7, 2009 – iMPACT: TNA X-Division champion SUICIDE defeated Consequences Creed w/Jay Lethal in a Non-title match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed accused Christopher Daniels of being SUICIDE and demanded that he confess immediately..
- May 9, 2009–JAPW: Jay Lethal defeated Azrael and Teddy Hart and Homicide in a 4-WAY to retain the JAPW Heavyweight title..
- May 14, 2009 – iMPACT: Christopher Daniels defeated Chris Sabin w/Alex Shelley with Lethal Consequences watching from stage..
- ~~~Later That Night: Shelley & Sabin & Lethal & Creed tried to unmasked SUICIDE but Christopher Daniels came to his rescue!
- May 21, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: SUICIDE & Daniels beat The Motor City Machine Guns and Lethal Consequences in a 3-WAY..
- May 24, 2009 – TNA Sacrifice: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed & Eric Young beat The Motor City Machine Guns & The Sheik..
Total Nonstop Action – vs. SUICIDE:
- June 4, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Beer Money Inc. (Robert Roode & James Storm) defeated Consequences Creed & Chris Sabin..
- ~~~Before the match; The Motor City Machine Guns & Lethal Consequences talked about their goal of unmasking SUICIDE..
- June 11, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Alex Shelley (w/Chris Sabin) & Jay Lethal (w/Consequences Creed) defeated Team 3-D..
- June 18, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Beer Money Inc. & Team 3-D defeated Lethal Consequences & The Motor City Machine Guns..
- June 21, 2009 – TNA Slammiversary: SUICIDE won a King of the Mountain Match to retain the TNA X-Division championship..
- ~~~SUICIDE defeated Jay Lethal and Consequences Creed and Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin to retain the TNA X-Division title..
Total Nonstop Action – Steel Asylum:
- June 27, 2009–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Dan Maff defeated Jay Lethal in a Steel Cage match to win JAPW Heavyweight title.
- July 2, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jethro Holiday vs. Jay Lethal didn’t happen because Abyss destroyed both men..
- August 6, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Lethal Consequences tried but failed to cash in on the $50,000 Bounty on the head of Abyss..
- August 16, 2009 – TNA Hard Justice: Christopher Daniels won a Steel Asylum match to earn a shot at the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~Daniels beat SUICIDE & Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed & Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley & Amazing Red & D’Angelo Dinero..
Total Nonstop Action – The Black Machismo:
- August 20, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Pope D’Angelo Dinero defeated Consequences Creed – (Jay Lethal was banned from ringside)..
- September 10, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Pope D’Angelo Dinero defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal in a singles match..
- October 1, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Amazing Red defeated Lethal and Creed and Sheik and Kiyoshi in a 5-WAY Ladder match..
- October 10, 2009–ACE Pro Wrestling: Mike Donovan defeated Jay Lethal in Union City, New Jersey..
- October 18 , 2009 – TNA Bound For Glory: The Motor City Machine Guns defeated Lethal Consequences in a dark match..
- October 22, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: The Motor City Machine Guns defeated Lethal Consequences in an Ultimate-X match..
Total Nonstop Action – The Black Machismo Invitational:
- November 5, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal announced the beginning of the Black Machismo Invitational next week!
- November 12, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Jim “The Anvil” Neidhart defeated Jay Lethal in a Black Machismo Invitational Match..
- December 17, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: “Native American” Tatanka defeated Jay Lethal in a Black Machismo Invitational Match..
- December 20, 2009 – TNA Final Resolution: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal participated in the 4th Annual Feast or Fired match..
- ~~~The Sheik & Kevin Nash & Rob Terry & Samoa Joe walked away with briefcases containing title shots or a pink slip..
- January 4, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: A special Steel Asylum match ended in a No Contest when Homicide hit everyone with a weapon!
- ~~~~Alex Shelley vs. Chris Sabin vs. Homicide vs. Kiyoshi vs. Jay Lethal vs. Consequences Creed vs. SUICIDE vs. Amazing Red..
- January 9, 2010 – Xplosion: X-Division Champion Douglas Williams defeated The Amazing Red, Jay Lethal & Brian Kendrick in a 4-way non-title match.
- January 14, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D defeated Lethal Consequences after Bobby Lashley attacked Lethal & Creed..
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal:
- March 15, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Kazuchika Okada with an Elbow Drop in a dark match..
- March 29, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Beer Money Inc. (Robert Roode & James Storm)..
- April 5, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Hulk Hogan formed an alliance with “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal giving some MegaPowers nostalgia..
- April 24, 2010–Millenium Wrestling Federation: The Iron Sheik & Jay Lethal defeated “Stalker” Dylan Kage w/Paul Bearer..
- ~~~~No DQ/Countout Match ending when Sheik made Kage submit to the camel clutch on the floor in the Sheik’s retirement match..
- ~~~~There was a huge celebration with the locker room hitting the ring after the bout to honor the Sheik! [www.bostonwrestling.com]
- April 12, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: The Black Machismo wanted to reform the MegaPowers and Hulk Hogan said he would think about it..
- April 26, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Desmond Wolfe w/Chelsea defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal in a match taped for Xplosion..
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal vs. “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair:
- May 3, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Hulk Hogan gave Ric Flair’s HOF ring to Jay Lethal, who suddenly began impersonating the Nature Boy..
- ~~~Ric Flair confronted Jay Lethal saying he felt disrespected, so Lethal showed respect by giving Flair his Hall of Fame ring back..
- ~~Ric Flair slapped Jay Lethal accross the face and a fight broke out until Flair’s troop interfered – Team 3-D & RVD made the save!
- May 20, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Rob Van Dam & Jay Lethal defeated Beer Money Inc (Robert Roode & James Storm)..
- ~~~After the match; Ric Flair attacked Jay Lethal and Sting (who was disguised a fan in the front row) attacked Rob Van Dam..
- May 27, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Frankie Kazarian defeated “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal after distraction from Ric Flair..
- ~~~After the match, Ric Flair attacked Jay Lethal, soon joined by A.J. Styles, but Kazarian got up and began argueing with Styles!
- ~~~Jay Lethal drop-kicked both Kazarian & Styles out of the ring – and the Nature Boy was livid about his two protege’s screwing up..
- June 3, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated A.J. Styles and Frankie Kazarian in a 3-WAY with Ric Flair watching from ringside..
- ~~~A.J. Styles & Frankie Kazarian bickered like two brothers trying to get the attention of their father (Ric Flair) – Lethal pinned Styles..
- June 10, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: AJ Styles & Desmond Wolfe & Beer Money beat Jay Lethal & Abyss & Mr. Anderson & Jeff Hardy
- June 12, 2010–Traditional Championship Wrestling: Jay Lethal & Matt Riviera defeated The Dark Circle by DQ..
- June 13, 2010 – TNA Slammiversary: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated “The Phenomenal” A.J. Styles w/Nature Boy Ric Flair..
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal vs. “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair:
- June 17, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Desmond Wolfe w/Chelsea in a singles match..
- ~~~After the match, Ric Flair & Desmond Wolfe double-teamed Jay Lethal until Hogan Hogan made the save (Hogan praised Lethal!)
- June 24, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated (Frankie) Kazarian (Ric Flair & A.J. Styles attacked Lethal’s brother backstage)..
- July 1, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal called out Flair/Styles, but got Matt Morgan instead…. Jay Lethal defeated Matt Morgan..
- July 8, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal had an intense in-ring confrontation with Ric Flair to hype their big match at Victory Road..
- July 11, 2010 – TNA Victory Road: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair with a figure-four-leg-lock!
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal vs. “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair:
- July 15, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: #2 ranked Jeff Hardy defeated #5 ranked Jay Lethal…
- August 5, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Ric Flair (wearing a suit) defeated Jay Lethal in a Street Fight with help from Douglas Williams..
- August 19, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Mr. Anderson defeated Jay Lethal in the first round of a tournament for the vacant TNA title..
- August 21, 2010–ICW Super Brawl 1: Jay Lethal defeated Eric Young in Sierra Vista, Arizona..
- August 26, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Douglas Williams defeated Brian Kendrick and Amazing Red and Jay Lethal in a 4-WAY (Xplosion).
- September 16, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Douglas Williams to win the TNA X-Division title..
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal (X Division Champion):
- September 23, 2010 – TNA Live Event: Amazing Red defeated Jay Lethal to win the TNA X-Division title in New York City..
- September 25, 2010 – TNA Live Event: Jay Lethal defeated Amazing Red to recapture the TNA X-Division title in New Jersey..
- October 7, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal participated in a $100,000 Invitational Gauntlet-style Battle Royal (won by Kurt Angle)..
- October 10, 2010 – TNA Bound For Glory: Jay Lethal defeated Douglas Williams to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~~After the match; The Shore (Robbie E & Cookie) attacked Jay Lethal and set their sights on the TNA X-Division title..
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal vs. TNA X-Division champion Robbie E w/Cookie:
- October 28, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Robbie E w/Cookie defeated TNA X-Division champion Jay Lethal in a Non-title match..
- November 7, 2010 – TNA Turning Point: Robbie E w/Cookie defeated Jay Lethal to win the TNA X-Division title..
- November 11, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Robbie E & Cookie defeated Jay Lethal & Taylor Wilde in a mixed tag team match..
- November 18, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Generation Me & Robbie E & Cookie beat Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal & Velvet Sky..
- December 2, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal vs. Robbie E w/Cookie competed in a New Jersey Fist Pump Showdown (Dancing)..
- ~~~~It ended in a brawl that went backstage, and it also involved backstage reporter Christy Hemme getting into a catfight with Cookie..
- December 5, 2010 – TNA Final Resolution: Robbie E defeated Jay Lethal by DQ to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~~Cookie was suspended above the ring in a shark cage and threw a can of hair spray into the ring which Lethal used for the DQ..
Total Nonstop Action – X Division champion Jay Lethal vs. Kazarian:
- December 11, 2010–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Kenny Omega defeated Jay Lethal.
- December 16, 2010 – TNA IMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Robbie E w/Cookie to recapture the TNA X Division title..
- ~~~~Christy Hemme ran down and hand-cuffed herself to Cookie so she would prevent her from interfering in the match!
- December 30, 2010 – TNA iMPACT: Kazarian lured Jay Lethal to the ring with insults only to bash him on the head with a weapon!
- January 6, 2011 – TNA IMPACT: TNA X Division champion Jay Lethal defeated The Monster Abyss by disqualification for unnecessary aggression..
- ~~~~After, Kazarian sarcastically begged Abyss to stop. Abyss picked up the unconcious Lethal and made him shake hands with Kaz..
- January 9, 2011 – Genesis: Frankie Kazarian defeated TNA X Division champion Jay Lethal to win the title.
Total Nonstop Action – Jay Lethal:
- January 20, 2011 – TNA IMPACT: Kazarian defeated Jay Lethal to retain the title.
- February 3, 2011 – TNA IMPACT: Jeremy Buck w/ Max Buck defeated Douglas Williams and Jay Lethal in a triple threat #1 contenders series match.
- March 5, 2011 – ASW Best of the Best: Jay Lethal and Simon Sez defeated The Uprising (Eric Cooper and Eddie Taurus).
- April 17, 2011 – Lockdown: Max Buck defeated Brian Kendrick, Jay Lethal, Amazing Red, Chris Sabin, Jeremy Buck, Suicide, and Robbie E (w/ Cookie) in an Ultimate Xscape steel cage match to become the #1 contender match for the TNA X Division title.
- April 21 2011 – TNA Xplosion: Sangriento (Amazing Red) defeated Chris Sabin and Jay Lethal in a triple threat match.
- Summer 2011: Jay Lethal was released from his Total Nonstop Action contract..
Jay Lethal:
- May 28, 2011 – Lucha Libre USA: The Right (Jon Rekon & Petey Williams) defeated Black Machismo Jay Lethal & Magno.
- June 25, 2011 – Best in the World: Jay Lethal defeated Mike Bennett w/Bob Evans.
- September 17, 2011 – Death before Dishonor IV: Tommaso Ciampa and Rhino with the Embassy defeated Homicide and Jay Lethal.
- October 1, 2011 – ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated El Generico to become the 4th TV Champion.
- October 22, 2011 – ROH TV: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal vs Mike Bennett ended in a time limit draw.
- November 17, 2011 – Survival of the Fittest: ROH World Tag Team Champions Charlie Haas and Shelton Benjamin defeated ROH World Champion Davey Richards and ROH World TV Champion Jay Lethal.
- November 18, 2011 – Glory by Honor X: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal defeated Roderick Strong.
- November 26, 2011 – ROH TV: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal vs El Generico ended in a time limit draw.
- December 3, 2011 – Southern Defiance: Jay Lethal won the 20 man Honor Rumble.
- Jay Lethal defeated TJ Perkins.
- December 4, 2011 – Northern Aggression: Jay Lethal defeated Adam Cole.
- December 23, 2011 – Final Battle: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal defeated El Generico and “The Prodigy” Mike Bennett w/ Brutal Bob & Maria Kanellis to retain.
- January 20, 2012 – Homecoming: ROH Champion Davey Richards defeated Jay Lethal to retain the title.
- February 4, 2012–ROH TV: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal defeated Mike Bennett to retain.
- February 25, 2012–ROH TV: ROH Champion Davey Richards defeated Jay Lethal to retain.
- March 4, 2012–10th Anniversary: World TV Champion Jay Lethal defeated Tommaso Ciampa with The Embassy Ltd.
- March 10, 2012–ROH TV: World TV Champion Jay Lethal beat Kenny King.
- March 17, 2012–ROH TV: World Television Champion Jay Lethal beat Roderick Strong March Mayhem” Qualifier.
- March 29, 2012–Showdown in the Sun night 1: ROH TV Champion Jay Lethal defeated Kyle O’Reilly to retain the title.
- March 30, 2012–Showdown in the Sun night 2: ROH TV Champion Roderick Strong w/ Truth Martini defeated Jay Lethal to retain the title.
- April 7, 2012–ROH TV: Tommaso Ciampa beat Adam Cole, “The Prodigy” Mike Bennett, & Jay Lethal to win the $24,000 March Mayhem 4 Way Elimination Finals.
- April 27, 2012–Unity: The Colony defeated TJ Perkins, Adam Cole & Jay Lethal.
- May 11, 2012–Bordar Wars: Jay Lethal def. Tommaso Ciampa w/ The Embassy, Ltd.
- May 12, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Ricky Reyes.
- May 19, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal & Grizzly Redwood defeated Michael Elgin by DQ.
- June 23, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Chris Silvio.
- June 24, 2012–Best in the World: ROH TV Champion Roderick Strong defeated Jay Lethal & Tommaso Ciampa in a 3-way match to retain.
- August 11, 2012–Boiling Point: Jay Lethal defeated Tommaso Ciampa in a 2out3 falls count match.
- August 11, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal & The All Night Express (Rhett Titus & Kenny King) defeated World Champion Kevin Steen, Steve Corino, & Jimmy Jacobs.
- August 18, 2012 – Warriors of Wrestling: Matt Hardy defeated Jay Lethal.
- August 25, 2012–ROH TV: Mike Mondo beat TJ Perkins, Tommaso Ciampa, Roderick Strong, Jay Lethal, and Mike Bennett to earn the “DBD X” TV Title match.
- September 1, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal vs Matt Taven never started.
- September 8, 2012–Cage Hostily: Jay Lethal defeated Adam Page.
- September 15, 2012–Death before Dishonor: Jay Lethal defeated Homicide.
- October 6, 2012–ROH Live Event: ROH Heavyweight Champion Kevin Steen vs Jay Lethal ended in a No Contest.
- October 13, 2012–Glory by Honor: Jay Lethal defeated Davey Richards.
- October 13, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated QT Marshall.
- October 20, 2012 – NYWC Wrestling: Tony Nese defeated Jay Lethal.
- October 27, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal beat World TV Champion Adam Cole, Davey Richards, Michael Elgin, Mike Mondo, and Roderick Strong to earn a future World Title shot.
- December 8, 2012–ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Chris Silvio.
- December 16, 2012–Final Battle: Jay Lethal defeated Rhino.
- January 18, 2013 – ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Steve Corino.
- January 19, 2013 – ROH Live Event: S.C.U.M. (Jimmy Jacobs, Rhino & Steve Corino) defeated Jay Lethal & The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe).
- February 2, 2013 – ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Jimmy Jacobs.
- February 16, 2013–ROH TV: Jay Lethal defeated Jimmy Jacobs.
- February 16, 2013–ROH Live Event: Jay Lethal defeated Tadarius Thomas.
- March 2, 2013 – 11th Anniversary: ROH Heavyweight Champion Kevin Steen defeated Jay Lethal to retain the title.
- March 30, 2013 – War: ACH defeated Matt Taven, Roderick Strong & Jay Lethal in the Proving Ground Match.
- April 5, 2013 – Super Card of Honor: Michael Elgin defeated Jay Lethal in a #1 contenders match.
