
Title History
- RWF (Renegade Wrestling Federation) Heavyweight title defeating Bob Evans (September 24, 1993);
- ECW World Tag Team titles w/Lance Storm defeating Raven & Tommmy Dreamer (January 9, 2000);
- ECW World Tag Team titles w/Lance Storm defeating Raven & Mike Awesome (March 12, 2000);
- ECW World Heavyweight title defeating Tommy Dreamer (April 21, 2000);
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Shawn Stasiak (May 2, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Crash Holly.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Raven (May 6, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Crash Holly.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Bradshaw (July 12, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Spike Dudley.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Bradshaw (July 13, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Shawn Stasiak.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Bradshaw (July 14, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Shawn Stasiak.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Raven (July 26, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Shawn Stasiak.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Raven (July 27, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Shawn Stasiak.
- WWF Hardcore title defeating Steven Richards (July 28, 2002); – Lost it in the same match to Shawn Stasiak.
- PWF Universal Heavyweight title defeating Steve Corino (February 9, 2003);
- ICW (Impact Championship Wrestling) Heavyweight title defeating Jerry Lynn (April 13, 2003);
- TWA (Texas Wrestling Academy) Heavyweight title;
- NEWA (New Bedford) Tag Team titles;
- PWF (Pennsylvania) Universal Heavyweight title (2);
- 3PW (Pro Pain Pro) Heavyweight title defeating Terry Funk (August 16, 2003);
- TRP (Top Rope Promotions) Heavyweight title defeating Big Rick Fuller (July 27, 2007);
Career Highlights
In The Beginning:
- Peter Polaco trained in Calgary with Stu Hart and the Hart Brothers along with future tag team partner, Lance Storm..
- Peter Polaco had the chance to have such opponents as Lance Storm and Chris Jericho early in his career..
- September 24, 1993: P.J. Walker defeated Bob Evans for the RWF Heavyweight title.
World Wrestling Federation – Jobber to the Stars:
- Peter Polaco went to the World Wrestling Federation where he jobbed as PJ Walker..
- March 1, 1993 – WWF RAW: Lex Luger defeated P.J. Walker (Walker’s WWF debut)..
- March 22, 1993 – WWF RAW: Lex Luger defeated P.J. Walker..
- May 10, 1993 – WWF RAW: Yokozuna defeated P.J. Walker..
- June 28, 1993 – WWF RAW: Adam Bomb defeated P.J. Walker..
- July 12, 1993 – WWF RAW: The Headshrinkers defeated P.J. Walker & Aaron Ferguson..
- September 20, 1993 – WWF RAW: P.J. Walker defeated Irwin R. Schyster in an upset victory!
- October 18, 1993 – WWF RAW: The Steiner Brothers defeated P.J. Walker & Tony DeVito..
- December 20, 1993 – WWF RAW: Jeff Jarrett defeated P.J. Walker..
- April 18, 1994 – WWF RAW: Jeff Jarrett defeated P.J. Walker.
World Championship Wrestling:
- March 12, 1994–WCW WorldWide: Big Van Vader defeated P.J. Walker ..
- April 9, 1994–WCW Worldwide: The Nasty Boys defeated Randy Hogan & P.J. Walker.
World Wrestling Federation – Aldo Mantoya:
- PJ Walker was transformed into the masked Aldo Montoya (aka Portugese Man-o-War)..
- November 14, 1994 – WWF RAW: Aldo Montoya defeated The Brooklyn Brawler..
- December 12, 1994 – WWF RAW: Aldo Montoya defeated Nick Barbarry..
- January 30, 1995 – WWF RAW: Aldo Montoya defeated David Sierra…
- April 24, 1995 – WWF RAW: Aldo Montoya defeated The Black Phantom..
- October 23, 1995 – WWF RAW: Aldo Montoya was a participant in a battle royal won by Owen Hart..
- January 8, 1996 – WWF RAW: Goldust defeated Aldo Montoya..
- February 19, 1996 – WWF RAW: The BodyDonnas defeated Barry Horowitz & Aldo Montoya…
- March 25, 1996 – WWF RAW: Hunter Hearst Helmsley defeated Aldo Montoya…
- April 1, 1996 – WWF RAW: The BodyDonnas (Skip & Zip) defeated Barry Horowitz & Aldo Montoya…
- April 22, 1996 – WWF RAW: Mankind defeated Aldo Montoya by Submission..
- May 13, 1996 – WWF RAW: Justin Bradshaw defeated Aldo Montoya… .
- June 17, 1996 – WWF RAW: Hunter Hearst Helmsley vs Aldo Montoya fought ended in a No Contest…
- June 24, 1996 – WWF RAW: Vader & Owen Hart & The Bulldog defeated Aldo Montoya & Savio Vega & Barry Horowitz…
- August 05, 1996 – WWF RAW: Jerry Lawler defeated Aldo Montoya…
- October 07, 1996 – WWF RAW: The Sultan defeated Aldo Montoya by Submission…
- October 28, 1996 – WWF RAW: Crush defeated Aldo Montoya…
- March 10, 1997 – WWF RAW: Billy Gunn defeated Aldo Montoya.
United States Wrestling Association:
- Peter Polaco was sent to USWA as “PG-187″ as a member of an early version of the Nation of Domination..
- ~~~PG-187 was suppose to be WWF’s version of Konnan, but failed to realize the difference between being Portuguese & Mexican..
- Peter Polaco wasn’t making enough for living expenses from his USWA work, so asked for his release from the WWF..
- ~~~The WWF feared that he’d go to WCW and instead decided to send him to Extreme Championship Wrestling.
Extreme Championship Wrestling – Justin Credible is Born:
- Peter Polaco was sent to Extreme Championship Wrestling as part of a talent exchange and had a short stint as PG-187..
- Peter Polaco was granted his release from the WWF, and went full time with ECW and developed a new gimmick, Justin Credible..
- Justin Credible had Jason Knight as his manager, Nicole Bass as his bodyguard, and Chastity as his valet..
- September 20, 1997–As Good As It Gets: Justin Credible defeated Jerry Lynn..
- November 8, 1997–Ultimate Jeopardy: Justin Credible defeated Chris Chetti..
- November 30, 1997 – November to Remember: Mikey Whipwreck defeated Justin Credible..
- December 6, 1997–Better Than Ever: Mikey Whipwreck defeated Justin Credible..
- December 1997: Justin Credible defeated Mikey Whipwreck..
- December 26, 1997: Justin Credible beat Tommy Dreamer…
- January 10, 1998–House Party: Justin Credible and Jason attacked the Great Sasuke at the ECW Arena..
- January 31, 1998–Hostile City Showdown: Justin Credible (wearing Sasuke’s mask) defeated Gran Hamada..
- February 1998: After the death of Tommy Dreamer’s grandfather, Justin Credible took advantage of Dreamer and told him:
- ~~~”I’m sorry your grandfather died. I wish it was you instead of your worthless grandfather!”
- February 21, 1998–CyberSlam: Justin Credible defeated Tommy Dreamer in a “First Blood” match..
- March 1, 1998–Living Dangerously: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible..
- May 3, 1998–Wrestlepalooza: Justin Credible defeated Mikey Whipwreck..
- May 15, 1998–A Matter of Respect: Justin Credible defeated Jerry Lynn in a Best 2/3 Falls match..
- July 10, 1998–ECW: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible..
- July 18, 1998–ECW: Masato Tanaka & Jerry Lynn defeated Mike Awesome & Justin Credible..
- July 24, 1998–ECW: Masato Tanaka & Jerry Lynn defeated Mike Awesome & Justin Credible..
- August 2, 1998–Heat Wave: Justin Credible defeated Jerry Lynn..
- August 8, 1998–ECW: Justin Credible defeated The Sandman..
- August 28, 1998–ECW: Justin Credible defeated The Sandman..
- August 29, 1998–ECW: The Sandman defeated Justin Credible & Jason in a handicap match..
- November 1, 1998–November to Remember: Jake Roberts & Tommy Dreamer beat Justin Credible & Jack Victory..
- January 10, 1999–Guilty as Charged: Justin Credible defeated Dreamer in a Stairway to Hell match..
- January 16, 1999–House Party: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible and Lance Storm in a THREE WAY DANCE..
- March 21, 1999–Living Dangerously: Tommy Dreamer & Shane Douglas defeated Justin Credible & Lance Storm..
- April 3, 1999–CyberSlam: Shane Douglas defeated Justin Credible..
- May 16, 1999–Hardcore Heaven: Sid Vicious vs Justin Credible ended in a NO CONTEST.
Extreme Championship Wrestling – The Impact Players:
- Justin Credible teamed with Lance Storm as the Impact Players managed by Dawn Marie and Jason..
- Catch Phrase: That’s Not Just the Coolest, That’s Not Just the Best, That My Friends, is Justin Credible!
- August 2, 1999–Heat Wave: Rob Van Dam & Jerry Lynn defeated The Impact Players (Justin Credible & Lance Storm)..
- September 19, 1999–Anarchy Rulz: Justin Credible defeated Sabu..
- October 23, 1999–Re-enter the Sandman: Raven & Tommy Dreamer vs Justin Credible & Lance Storm ended in a NO CONTEST..
- November 7, 1999–November to Remember: Rhino & Justin Credible & Lance Storm beat Raven & Tommy Dreamer & Sandman..
- January 9, 2000–Guilty as Charged: Lance Storm & Justin Credible beat Tommy Dreamer & Raven to win the Tag Team titles!
- March 3, 2000: Masato Tanaka & Tommy Dreamer defeated The Impact Players for the Tag Team titles..
- March 12, 2000–Living Dangerously: The Players beat Raven/Awesome and Dreamer/Tanaka to recapture the Tag Team titles!
- When Lance Storm left ECW for WCW, Justin forfieted the Tag Team titles and went after the Heavyweight title!
Extreme Championship Wrestling – Justin Credible:
- April 22, 2000–CyberSlam: Justin Credible defeated Tommy Dreamer to win the ECW Heavyweight title in a surprise match on PPV..
- May 14, 2000–Hardcore Heaven: Justin Credible defeated Lance Storm and Tommy Dreamer in a 3-WAY to retain the ECW title..
- June 23, 2000–Midwest Massacre Tour: Tommy Dreamer & Jazz defeated Francine & Justin Credible..
- June 24, 2000–Midwest Massacre Tour: Justin Credible defeated The Sandman to retain the Heavyweight title..
- July 16, 2000–Heat Wave: Justin Credible defeated Tommy Dreamer in a “Stairway to Hell” match to retain the Heavyweight title..
- August 19, 2000–A New Era Begins: Rob Van Dam & Kid Kash defeated Justin Credible & Rhino..
- August 25, 2000–Mid-Town Massacre Tour: Justin Credible & Rhino defeated The Sandman & Chilly Willy (1st Round)..
- ~~~Tommy Dreamer & Jerry Lynn b Rhino & Justin Credible in the 2nd Round of the Tag Team Title Tournament..
- August 25, 2000–Mid-Town Massacre Tour: Justin Credible defeated Steve Corino to retain the Heavyweight title..
- October 1, 2000–Anarchy Rulz: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible to win the ECW World Heavyweight title..
- October 7, 2000–Beer, Blood, Babes, and Barbed Wire: New Jack defeated Justin Credible..
- November 5, 2000–November to Remember: Steve Corino defeated Justin Credible to win the vacant Heavyweight title..
- December 3, 2000–Massacre on 34th Street: Steve Corino defeated Jerry Lynn and Justin Credible in a 3-WAY to retain the ECW title..
- December 23, 2000–Holiday Hell: Steve Corino defeated Justin Credible and The Sandman in a 3-WAY to retain the ECW title..
- January 7, 2001–Guilty as Charged: The Sandman defeated Steve Corino and Justin Credible in a 3-WAY to win the ECW World Title..
- January 13, 2001–Extreme Championship Wrestling: Justin credible w/Francine defeated The Sandman……
- ~~~Justin Credible challenged Sandman to a regular wrestling match to which Sandman agreed, but Credible would owe him one..
- ~~~After the match, Sandman called in his favor for an ECW Style match | Sandman defeated Justin Credible w/Francine…
- When ECW went out of business, Justin Credible showed up in the World Wrestling Federation again.
World Wrestling Federation – X-Factor:
- January 2001: Justin Credible resigned with the World Wrestling Federation..
- February 12, 2001 – RAW: Justin Credible formed an alliance with XPac & Albert calling themselves X-Factor..
- February 26, 2001 – RAW: X-Pac & Justin Credible defeated Eddie Guerrero & Chris Benoit..
- February 25, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible defeated Matt Murphy..
- March 4, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible defeated Grandmaster Sexay..
- March 10, 2001 – Jakked: X-Pac & Justin Credible defeated Kaientai..
- March 12, 2001 – RAW: The Hardy Boyz defeated X-Pac & Justin Credible by DQ..
- March 15, 2001 – Smackdown!: The Hardy Boyz & Billy Gunn vs. X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert ended in a No Contest..
- March 19, 2001- RAW: Justin Credible & X-Pac defeated Steve Blackman & Grandmaster Sexay..
- March 22, 2001 – Smackdown!: X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert defeated Grandmaster Sexay & Steve Blackman & K-Kwik..
- March 29, 2001 – Smackdown!: X-Factor (X-Pac & Justin Credible) defeated The APW (Bradshaw & Farooq)..
- April 29, 2001 – Backlash: X-Factor (X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert) beat The Dudley Boyz & Spike Dudley.
- April 5, 2001 – Smackdown!: X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert defeated Billy Gunn & Steve Blackman & Grandmaster Sexay..
- April 9, 2001 – RAW: The Dudley Boyz & Spike Dudley defeated X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert..
- April 15, 2001 – HEAT: The Dudley Boyz defeated Justin Credible & X-Pac..
- April 16, 2001 – RAW: Bubba Dudley defeated Justin Credible..
- April 22, 2001 – HEAT: Hardcore Holly & Crash Holly defeated Justin Credible & X-Pac..
- April 29, 2001 – HEAT: Raven defeated Justin Credible..
- April 29, 2001 – Backlash: Justin Credible & X-Pac & Albert defeated Bubba Dudley & D-Von Dudley & Spike Dudley..
- May 5, 2001 – Insurrextion: Edge & Christian defeated The Hardy Boyz & The Dudley Boyz & Justin Credible & X-Pac..
- May 6, 2001 – HEAT: The APA (Bradshaw & Farooq) defeated Justin Credible & Albert..
- May 7, 2001 – RAW: The Dudley Boyz & Spike Dudley defeated Justin Credible & X-Pac & Albert in a Tables match..
- May 13, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible & X-Pac defeated Kaientai..
- May 19, 2001 – Jakked: X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert defeated Doug Basham & Chris Williams & Rob Harris..
- May 20, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible & X-Pac defeated Kaientai..
- May 27, 2001 – HEAT: The APA (Bradshaw & Farooq) defeated Justin Credible & Albert..
- May 28, 2001 – RAW: The Hardy Boyz defeated X-Pac & Justin Credible..
- May 31, 2001 – Smackdown!: X-Pac & Justin Credible & Albert defeated The Hardy Boyz & Eddie Guerrero..
- June 9, 2001 – Jakked: Justin Credible & X-Pac defeated Billy Gunn & Raven..
- June 10, 2001 – HEAT: Steve Blackman defeated Justin Credible..
- June 17, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible & X-Pac defeated The Acolytes..
- June 21, 2001 – Smackdown!: Kane & The Hardy Boyz defeated Albert & X-Pac & Justin Credible..
- June 24, 2001 – HEAT: European Champion Matt Hardy defeated Justin Credible in a dark match..
- The team started to crumble when Albert won the IC title & XPac won the Light Heavyweight title..
- Justin Credible was soon struck with jealousy for his partners and looked for something new..
- July 1, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible defeated K-Kwik..
- July 8, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible defeated Sho Funaki.
World Wrestling Federation – The Alliance:
- July 9, 2001 – RAW: Paul Heyman reunited a group of ECW Alumni to mix things up in the WCW Invasaion situation..
- ~~~Tommy Dreamer, Rob Van Dam, Lance Storm, Mike Awesome, Tazz, Raven, Rhyno, Justin Credible, & the Dudley Boyz..
- ~~~Paul Heyman says that the InVasion just got “Extreme”, and that ECW will take on both WCW and the WWF..
- ~~~By the end of the night it was all a set up and Paul Heyman was actually in cahoots with Shane McMahon’s WCW..
- ~~~Extreme Championship Wrestling & World Championship Wrestling merged into “The Alliance“!
- July 15, 2001 – HEAT: WWF Intercontinental Champion Albert defeated Justin Credible..
- July 21, 2001 – Jakked: Justin Credible defeated K-Kwik..
- July 22, 2001 – HEAT: Perry Saturn defeated Justin Credible..
- July 28, 2001 – Jakked: Justin Credible defeated Crash Holly..
- July 29, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible & Raven defeated Taka Michinoku & Sho Funaki..
- August 4, 2001 – Jakked: Justin Credible defeated Scotty Too Hotty.
World Wrestling Federation – Justin Credible & Raven:
- Mid 2001: Raven & Justin Credible started teaming up regularly….
- August 5, 2001 – HEAT: The Big Show & Billy Gunn defeated Raven & Justin Credible..
- August 11, 2001 – Jakked: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible..
- August 19, 2001 – HEAT: Raven & Justin Credible defeated Kaientai..
- August 26, 2001 – HEAT: Justin Credible defeated Tommy Dreamer..
- September 4, 2001 – Smackdown!: The Hardy Boyz defeated Justin Credible & Raven…
- September 7, 2001 – IWA Puerto Rico: Super Crazy defeated Justin Credible…
- September 8, 2001 – Jakked: Billy Gunn defeated Justin Credible..
- September 15, 2001 – Jakked: X-Pac & Albert defeated Justin Credible & Mike Awesome..
- September 22, 2001 – Jakked: Crash Holly defeated Justin Credible..
- October 6, 2001 – Jakked: Scotty 2 Hotty defeated Justin Credible..
- October 14, 2001 – HEAT: The Hardy Boyz defeated Justin Credible & Raven..
- October 18, 2001 – Smackdown!: The Rock & Chris Jericho vs. Raven & Justin Credible ended in a No contest..
- October 20, 2001 – Jakked: Kaientai defeated Justin Credible & Raven..
- October 27, 2001 – Jakked: The Hardy Boyz defeated Justin Credible & Hugh Morris..
- October 28, 2001 – Heat: X-Factor (Albert & X-Pac) defeated Justin Credible & Raven..
- November 3, 2001 – Jakked: Justin Credible & Chavo Guerrero defeated Crash Holly & Spike Dudley..
- November 10, 2001 – Jakked: Spike Dudley defeated Justin Credible..
- November 11, 2001 – HEAT: Chuck Palumbo & Billy Gunn defeated Justin Credible & Raven..
- November 17, 2001 – Jakked: Perry Saturn defeated Justin Credible..
- November 18, 2001 – HEAT: Raven & Lance Storm & Justin Credible defeated Albert & Scotty 2 Hotty & Spike Dudley..
- Late 2001: Justin Credible, Mike Awesome, Scotty Too Hotty, & Tommy Dreamer were sent to Puerto Rico to tour with IWA.
World Wrestling Federation – Justin Credible:
- April 14, 2002 – HEAT: The Hardy Boyz defeated Steven Richards & Justin Credible..
- April 28, 2002 – HEAT: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible..
- May 5, 2002 – HEAT: Rob Van Dam defeated Justin Credible..
- May 19, 2002 – HEAT: D-Lo Brown defeated Justin Credible..
- May 26, 2002 – HEAT: D-Lo Brown defeated Justin Credible..
- June 2, 2002 – HEAT: Matt Hardy defeated Justin Credible..
- June 23, 2002 – HEAT: Hardcore Champion Bradshaw defeated Justin Credible..
- June 30, 2002 – HEAT: Sean O’Haire defeated Justin Credible..
- July 28, 2002 – HEAT: Goldust defeated Justin Credible..
- August 4, 2002 – HEAT: Shelton Benjamin defeated Justin Credible..
- August 11, 2002 – HEAT: Sean O’Haire defeated Justin Credible..
- August 18, 2002 – HEAT: D-Lo Brown defeated Justin Credible..
- August 25, 2002 – HEAT: Sean O’Haire defeated Justin Credible..
- September 1, 2002 – HEAT: Bradshaw defeated Justin Credible..
- September 15, 2002 – HEAT: Shelton Benjamin defeated Justin Credible..
- September 29, 2002 – HEAT: Johnny Stamboli defeated Justin Credible..
- October 13, 2002 – HEAT: Mark Jindrak defeated Justin Credible..
- November 3, 2002 – HEAT: Mark Jindrak defeated Justin Credible..
- November 17, 2002 – HEAT: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible..
- November 24, 2002 – HEAT: The Hurricane defeated Justin Credible..
- December 1, 2002 – HEAT: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible..
- December 8, 2002 – HEAT: Test defeated Justin Credible..
- January 20, 2003: Justin Credible was officially released from his World Wrestling Entertainment contract..
- Justin Credible is good friends with “The Kliq“, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Shawn Michaels, Sean Waltman, & Paul Levesque.
Independent Circuit:
- February 9, 2003–PWF: Steve Corino defeated Mikey Whipwreck to win vacant Universal Heavyweight title..
- ~~~However, after the match, Justin Credible showed up and defeated Steve Corino to claim the Universal title..
- February 14, 2003 – Xtreme Pro Wrestling: Justin Credible debuted confronting XPW Champion Shane Douglas..
- March 8, 2003 – XPW: Shane Douglas defeated Justin Crdible to retain the XPW title..
- March 16, 2003: Steve Corino defeated Justin Credible for the PWF Universal Heavyweight title..
- April 13, 2003–Impact Championship Wrestling: Justin Credible beat Jerry Lynn to win vacant ICW title.
NWA: Total Nonstop Action:
- April 16, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Justin Credible debuts aligning himself with Perry Saturn, New Jack & Sandman..
- April 23, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Justin Credible vs Slash went to a NO CONTEST after the New Church & Team Extreme both intefered..
- May 21, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Amazing Red & Slash & Justin Credible defeats Elix Skipper & Christopher Daniels..
- May 28, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Chris Harris & Chris Sabin defeated Justin Credible & Jerry Lynn in an Anarchy Alliance match..
- June 18, 2003 – NWA^TNA ANNIVERSARY: Justin Credible defeated Jerry Lynn and then continued to brawl!
- June 21, 2003 – 3PW: Justin Credible defeated Homicide in a match where Justin did a horrible blade job in plain view of the fans..
- June 25, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Jerry Lynn pinned Justin Credible in a “Lights Out” match..
- July 2, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Jerry Lynn beat Justin Credible in a “Chain” match, but afterwards, Justin tombstoned Jerry on the chain!
- July 16, 2003 – NWA^TNA: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible in a “Last Man Standing” match.
Ring of Honor / Combat Zone / 3PW / W1 / USA Pro Etc:
- August 16, 2003 – 3PW: Justin Credible defeated Terry Funk to win the 3PW Heavyweight title!
- September 27, 2003 – Lucha Xtreme Wrestling: Justin Credible w/Jason Knight & Veronica Caine defeated La Parka..
- October 16, 2003 – Ring of Honor: Raven defeated Justin Credible in a “Special Challenge” match..
- November 1, 2003 – Ring of Honor: Matt Stryker defeated Justin Credible by submission..
- Late 2003: Justin Credible with partner Ekmo Faru worked All Japan’s Real World Tag League
- December 27, 2003 – ROH Afternoon Showcase: The Carnage Crew & Justin Credible vs Special K went to a NO CONTEST..
- January 9, 2004 – ROH/JAPW: Shane Douglas defeated Justin Credible..
- January 17, 2004 – CZW: Rebel’s Army (Rebel/Greg Matthews/Derek Frazier) defeated The Backseat Boyz & Justin Credible..
- February 6, 2004 – PWWorld-1: Jerry Lynn & Justin Credible defeated Low Ki & Spanky..
- February 7, 2004 – PWWorld-1: C.W. Anderson & Simon Diamond defeated Steve Corino & Justin Credible..
- February 8, 2004 – PWWorld-1: Low Ki defeated Justin Credible to capture the PWF Heavyweight title!
- February 14, 2004 – ROH 2nd Anniversary: Special K (Dixie/Hydro/Izzy) defeated Carnage Crew (Devito/HC Loc/Credible)..
- March 7, 2004 – Z1 Hustle-2: Masato Tanaka & Kintaro Kanemura & Tetsuhiro Kuroda defeated Gladiator & Sabu & Justin Credible..
- March 13, 2004 – ROH: The Carnage Crew defeated Special K in the second ever Scramble Cage Match..
- ~~~The Carnage Crew (HC Loc//DeVito//Credible/Masada/Dusty Rhodes) ||| Special K (Dixie/Izzy/Slim J/Abyss/Hydro/Angel Dust)
- April 8, 2004 – PWWorld-1: Dusty Rhodes Jr defeated Justin Credible..
- April 9, 2004 – PWWorld-1: Simon Diamond & Justin Credible defeated Christopher Street Connection..
- April 10, 2004 – PWWorld-1: CW Anderson/Justin Credible/Simon Diamond defeated Ricky Landell/Alex Law/Greg Spitz..
- April 23, 2004 – ROH: John Walters beat Justin Credible..
- April 24, 2004 – ROH: The Carnage Crew (Justin Credible & Masada) defeated Delirious & Shawn Daivari..
- June 19, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Balls Mahoney defeated Justin Credible..
- September 17, 2004–USA Pro Wrestling: Slyk Wagner Brown defeated Justin Credible..
- September 24, 2004–FIP: C.M. Punk defeated Justin Credible in St. Petersburg, Florida..
- December 17, 2004–Fusion Wrestling: Justin Credible defeated Frankie Kazarian..
- February 26, 2005–Frank Goodman’s UXW: Mick Foley came out saying that there is no point waiting for June for an ECW reunion..
- ~~~Mick Foley called out Axl Rotten, Chris Candido, Tammy Sytch, Balls Mahoney, Raven, Al Snow, Sandman & Justin Credible..
- ~~~Later on that night, Sandman defeated Justin Credible in an ECW-style match..
- April 15, 2005–Frank Goodman’s UXW: Justin Credible defeated Sandman in a Singapore Cane match..
- May 21, 2005–UXW Chris Candido Memorial: Billy Gunn defeated Justin Credible..
- June 4, 2005–NWS (ECW Style Show): Sandman & Justin Credible defeated Danny Doring & Roadkill (All four shook hands after)..
- June 10, 2005 – Hardcore Homecoming: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible w/Jason (Jazz stopped Jason from interfering)..
- June 12, 2005 – ECW One Night Stand: Lance Storm w/Dawn Marie defeated Chris Jericho with help from Justin Credible & Jason!
- ~~~The Impact Players (Storm & Credible) showed up during the Dudleyz vs Sandman/Dreamer main event to interfere..
- ~~~Justin Credible gave Sandman the That’s Incredible Piledriver onto a roll of barbed wire!
- June 18, 2005 – 3PW: Roadkill defeated Justin Credible to retain the 3PW Heavyweight title..
- September 16, 2005–Hardcore Homecoming: Sandman defeated Justin Credible in a Cane match..
- September 17, 2005–Hardcore Homecoming: Jerry Lynn defeated Justin Credible..
- September 24, 2004–Full Impact Pro: Justin Credible defeated Ralph Mosca in the 1st Round of the FIP Title Tournament..
- September 25, 2004–Full Impact Pro: C.M. Punk defeated Justin Credible in the 2nd Round of the FIP Title Tournament..
- October 14, 2005–IWA Mid South: Justin Credible & Ian Rotten defeated Iron Saints (Vito & Sal Thomaselli)..
- October 15, 2005–IWA Mid South: Vito & Sal Thomaselli vs Justin Credible & Ian Rotten ended in a No COntest..
- November 4, 2005 – Hardcore Homecoming: Justin Credible defeated Jerry Lynn in a Cage with help from Lance Storm!
- November 13, 2005 – TNA Genesis: Raven defeated PJ Palaco (formerly known as Justin Credible) – match set up by Larry Zbyszko..
- December 10, 2005–Queen City Clash: Sandman defeated Justin Credible in a Street Fight in Charlotte, NC..
- February 9, 2006–MTV’s Wrestling Society X: Justin Credible participated in a special Royal Rumble Death match…
- May 13, 2006–Powerhouse Wrestling: Gino Martino & Ron Zombie beat Justin Credible & Sandman in Beds of Nails Death Match!
- May 20, 2006–Connecticut Championship Wrestling: Justin Credible defeated Christian Frost….
- June 2, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Ron Zombie defeated Justin Credible and Tony DeVito in a 3-WAY with Tommy Dreamer as referee.
World Wrestling Entertainment – ECW Resurrection!:
- June 7, 2006 – WWE vs ECW: Justin Credible was in a WWE vs ECW Battle Royal, won by The Big Show (who defected to ECW)..
- June 12, 2006 – RAW: Balls Mahoney, Justin Credible & Stevie Richards mysteriously scored front row seats & interfered in the main event..
- June 13, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: Kurt Angle defeated Justin Credible by Submission within seconds…
- June 24, 2006–ECW House Show: The Sandman defeated Justin Credible..
- June 17, 2006–Connecticut Championship Wrestling: Ron Zombie defeated Justin Credible….
- July 1 & 2, 2006–ECW House Shows: Sandman defeated Justin Credible in a Singapore Cane Challenge..
- July 4, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: Tommy Dreamer defeated Justin Credible in a dark match..
- July 8 & 9, 2006–ECW House Shows: Sandman defeated Justin Credible in a Dueling Canes match…
- July 11, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: Justin Credible defeated Sabu by DQ when Sabu put Credible through a Table at ringside..
- July 25, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: Justin Credible defeated Balls Mahoney by DQ (Balls was DQ’d for using a chair)..
- July 29 & 30, 2006–WWE/ECW House Shows: Sandman defeated Justin Credible by DQ in a Dueling Canes match..
- August 1, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: C.M. Punk (ECW TV debut) defeated Justin Credible..
- August 15, 2006–ECW on Sci Fi: C.M. Punk defeated Justin Credible by Submission in a rematch…
- September 28, 2006: Justin Credible was released by World Wrestling Entertainment.
Independents:
- February 10, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: Justin Credible w/Jason Knight defeated “Latin Fury” Luis Ortiz..
- ~~~Justin Credible had a “worked” confrontation with the promoter and eventually walked out of the building..
- March 17, 2007–JCW: NOSAWA vs. Ron Zombie ended in a No Contest when Justin Credible interfered……….
- April 14, 2007–Powerhouse Wrestling of New England: Men of Business retained their Powerhouse Tag Team titles..
- ~~~Men of Business (Paul E Normous & Jimmy Jact Cash) defeated Justin Credible & Jason Knight in a Cage match..
- April 29, 2007–DPW: Justin Credible & Jason Knight w/Mike E. Milano beat Avil Graves & Del Tsunami w/Paulie J by DQ
- May 5, 2007–Tri-State Wrestling: Justin Credible & Tony DeVito defeated The Outkast Killaz in Rutland, Vermont ..
- May 12, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Brother Runt defeated Justin Credible in a T.L.C. match in Massachusetts..
- May 20, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: Justin Credible w/Mike E. Milano beat The Canadian Superstars in a Handicap match
- May 26, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: John Walters defeated Justin Credible to retain the BTW Heavyweight title.
- June 23, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: Justin Credible & Tony DeVito beat Sudden Death (Dylan Kage & Ron Zombie)..
- June 24, 2007–Pro Wrestling Syndicate: Justin Credible defeated Reckless Youth in Garfield, New Jersey
- June 29, 2007–Top Rope Promotions: Justin Credible defeated Vain in Fall River, Massachusetts ..
- July 8, 2007–DPW: Ron Zombie beat Justin Credible w/DPW Owner Mike E. Milano in a Fans Bring Weapons Hardcore match..
- July 15, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: Dylan Kage defeated Justin Credible in Waterbury, Connecticut …
- July 27, 2007–Top Rope Promotions: Justin Credible beat Big Rick Fuller due to interference to win the TRP Title..
- August 31, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: Justin Credible defeated Antonio Thomas in a Last Man Standing Match
- September 7, 2007–Pro Wrestling Syndicate: Julio Dinero’s “Naked Truth” interview segment with Justin Credible..
- ~~~Sabu defeated Trent Acid and Danny Doring and Justin Credible in a 4-WAY in Garfield, New Jersey..
- September 28, 2007–Top Rope Promotions: Justin Credible vs. New Jack in a Hardcore Match ended in a No Contest..
- October 5, 2007–Full Throttle Wrestling: Justin Credible defeated Spike Dudley in Amherst, Massachusetts..
- October 7, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: DPW Television Champion Chris Mooch w/Paulie J. defeated Justin Credible
- November 10, 2007–Big Time Wrestling: The Sandman defeated Justin Credible in a Singapore Cane match..
- November 24, 2007–Defiant Pro Wrestling: Justin Credible (w/J.J. Alexander) defeated Tony DeVito
- December 2, 2007–DPW: Justin Credible w/JJ Alexander defeated Chris Mooch w/Mike E. Milano..
- December 9, 2007–Pro Wrestling Syndicate: Trent Acid defeated Justin Credible in Lake Hiawatha, New Jersey..
- December 15, 2007–DPW: Jason Knight (w/Mike E. Milano) defeated Justin Credible (w/J.J. Alexander)..
- December 15, 2007–DPW: Ron Zombie beat Slyck Wagner Brown and Justin Credible in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders Match..
- January 6, 2008–DPW: Jose Perez defeated Justin Credible and Lenn Oddity in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders Hardcore match
- October 4, 2008–National Wrestling Superstars: Raven defeated Justin Credible in a Hardcore Brawl.
- November 8, 2008–Big Time Wrestling: BTW Champion “Hurricane” John Walters (w/ Ox Baker) defeated Justin Credible..
- December 6, 2008–Big Time Wrestling: BTW Champion John Walters defeated Justin Credible in an Extreme Rules match..
- June 29, 2009–Legends of The Arena: Sandman & Sabu w/Bill Alfonso defeated Raven (w/Chastity) & Justin Credible (w/Jason)..
- ~~~The special guest referee was Terry Funk and Sandman’s two son’s interfered and got “revenge” for the old ECW storyline..
- August 7, 2010 – TNA Hardcore Justice: Stevie Richards (w/Blue Tilly & Hollywood Nova) defeated P.J. Polaco (Justin Credible)..