- NWL/HoPWF (House of Pain Wrestling Federation) Women’s title defeating Amy Lee (November 19, 2005/Pennsylvania);
- UCW Women’s title defeating Lexie Fyfe (August 10, 2006 in Front Royal, Virginia);
- WXW (World Xtreme Wrestling) Ladies title after declaring she beat Mercedes Martines in an Empty Arena Match (March 7, 2007);
- DCW (Dynamite Championship Wrestling) Women’s title defeating Trixie Lynn (October 10, 2009);
- November 19, 2005: Kacee Carlisle defeated Primetime Amy Lee to win the NWL/HoPWF Title in Newville, Pennsylvania..
- August 10, 2006: Kacee Carlisle defeated Lexie Fyfe to win the UCW Women’s Title in Front Royal, Virginia..
- March 7, 2007: Awarded the WXW Ladies title after declaring she beat Mercedes Martinez in an “Empty Arena Match”.
- June 21, 2008–Women Superstars Uncensored: Mercedes Martinez defeated Kacee Carlisle..
- June 21, 2008–Women Superstars Uncensored: Missy Sampson & Alere Little Feather defeated Kacee Carlisle & Kylie Pierce..
- ~~~After the match, Carlisle & Pierce handcuffed Missy Sampson to the rope and destroyed Little Feather, injuring her neck..
- June 6, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Jana won an 8-Man Tag to earn the #20 spot in the Uncensored Rumble..
- ~~~Jana & Kacee Carlisle & Trixxie Lynn & Lea Morrison beat Latasha & Amy Lee & Missy Sampson & Lady Dyvyne..
- June 6, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Participated in the 2009 WSU Uncensored Rumble (which was won by Nikki Roxx)..
- October 10, 2009–Dynamite Championship Wrestling: Kacee Carlisle beat Trixie Lynn to win the DCW Women’s title in Delaware..
- August 14, 2010–Mid Atlanticpro: Brittany Force defeated Kacee Carlisle in Millcreek, West Virginia..
- August 29, 2010–All Star South: Angeldust & Mia Yim defeated Brittany Force & Kacee Carlisle in Morgantown, West Virginia..
- October 2, 2010–WCW-C4: Niya beat Brittany Force and Kacee Carlisle in a 3-WAY in Allentown, Pennsylvania