Title History
- IWA Mid South Heavyweight title defeating BJ Whitmer (May 29, 2004);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X-Division title by winning a Gauntlet match (August 11, 2004);
- Border City Wrestling Tag Team titles w/Bobby Rude defeating Eddie Venom & N8 Mattson (September 19, 2004);
- EWR Heavyweight title defeating Excess and Hell Storm and Crazy Crusher (February 12, 2005)..
- Border City Wrestling Television title defeating Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley (April 17, 2005);
- WAJ Junior Heavyweight title ();
- NWA Upstate No Limits title defeating Dunn (May 14, 2005);
- TNA (Total Nonstop Action) X-Division title defeating The Black Machismo Jay Lethal (April 17, 2008);
Career Highlights
Border City Wrestling:
- January 23, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Bret Nikita & Chris Valentino defeated A1 & Petey Wlliams..
- May 2, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Eric Young defeated Petey Williams..
- May 10, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Hacker & Gutter defeated Petey Williams & Rob Romulus..
- June 13, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Mike Legacy & Petey Williams defeated Trent Steele & Chad Logan..
- September 6, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Hacker in a TLC match..
- October 10, 2002–BCW: Petey Williams beat Derek Wylde | Mike Legacy & A-1 & Petey b Wylde & Eric Young & Larry Destiny..
- November 28, 2002–Border City Wrestling: Tornado & Tyson Dux defeated Petey Williams & Mike Legacy..
- January 15, 2003–BCW: Eric Young/Derek Wylde/Larry Destiny/Tornado/Dix b Mike Legacy/A-1/Petey/El Fuego/John E. Bravo..
- March 6, 2003–Border City Wrestling: Tornado & Tyson Dux defeated Petey Williams & Mike Legacy..
- July 24, 2003–Border City Wrestling: Alex Shelley defeated Petey Williams..
- September 14, 2003–Border City Wrestling: Gutter & Chuck Wagon defeated Dyson Pryce & Petey Williams..
- November 19, 2003–Border City Wrestling: Jerry Lynn won three-way over Petey Williams and Johnny Devine..
- February 8, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Trent Steele..
Border City Wrestling + Total Nonstop Action (America’s Cup) + Combat Zone + IWA: Mid South + Others…:
- February 25 2004 – TNA: Petey Williams (Team Canada) defeated Juvi Guerrera (Team AAA) & Jerry Lynn (Team NWA)..
- March 5, 2004 – CZW: B-Boy defeated Petey Williams — then Jack Evans & Petey Williams defeated Grunger & Derek Frazier..
- March 6, 2004 – CZW: Jack Evans & Petey Williams defeated Teddy Hart in an ARIAL ASSAULT MATCH..
- March 10, 2004 – TNA: Team Mexico (AAA) successfully defended the America’s X-Cup against Team Canada..
- ~~~Juvi Guerrera & Mr. Aguila & Hector Garza & Abismo Negro beat Teddy Hart & Jack Evans & Petey Williams & Johnny Devine..
- March 24, 2004 – TNA: Amazing Red defeated Nosawa, Petey Williams, Elix Skipper, Jerry Lynn & Kazarian in a 6-WAY..
- April 2, 2004 – CZW: Sabian & Petey Williams defeated Jimmy Jacobs & Sonjay Dutt..
- April 3, 2004 – CZW: Sonjay Dutt defeated Petey Williams and Roderick Strong to retain the CZW Jr Heavyweight title..
- April 10, 2004 IWA Mid-South: “The Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams was victorious in a 6-WAY Match..
- ~~~~Petey Williams defeated Jimmy Jacobs and Arik Cannon and Roderick Strong and Emil Sitochi and Nate Webb.
- April 25, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Jimmy Jacobs..
- May 1, 2004–Michigan Marquee Wrestling: A.J. Styles defeated Petey Williams..
- May 5, 2004 – TNA: Team Canada (Williams/Devine/Rude/Young) beat Team USA (Skipper/Lynn/Sabin/Daniels)-tune-up match..
- May 12, 2004 – TNA: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude w/Scott D’Amore defeated Hector Garza and Abismo Negro..
- May 21, 2004–Metro Pro Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Truth Martini..
- May 22, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated A.J. Styles in a tournament match for NWA Indiana State title..
- May 26, 2004 – TNA: Team USA defeated Team Mexico, Team Canada & Team Japan to win the World’s X-Cup!
- ~~~Chris Sabin (USA) defeated Petey Williams (CAN) and Hector Garza (MEX) in an Ultimate-X Match!
- May 29, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams participated in a 7-man elimination style match for #1 Contendership..
- ~~~Petey Williams beat Jimmy Jacobs & Alex Shelley & Roderick Strong & Nate Webb & Austin Aries & Delirious..
- ~~~Petey Williams won a Title shot and defeated B.J. Whitmer to win IWA Mid South Heavyweight title..
- May 30, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Roderick Strong.
Border City Wrestling + Total Nonstop Action (Team Canada) + IWA: Mid South + Others…:
- June 2, 2004 – TNA: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude defeated Jerry Lynn & Heavy Metal when Eric Young interfered..
- June 4, 2004 – TNA Impact: Sonjay Dutt & Amazing Red & Hector Garza defeated Petey Williams & Bobby Rude & Eric Young..
- June 5, 2004–Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup: Alex Shelley & Petey Williams defeated Mikey Tenderfoot & Black Tigers (Jeremy Lopez)..
- June 9, 2004 – TNA: Bobby Rude & Eric Young & Petey Williams defeated Heavy Metal & Hector Garza & Jerry Lynn..
- June 11, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude & Eric Young defeated Abismo Negro & Heavy Metal & Mr Aguila..
- June 16, 2004 – TNA: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude & Eric Young beat Jerry Lynn & Elix Skipper & Chris Sabin (Flag Match)..
- June 18, 2004 – TNA Impact: 3-Live Krew (BG James & Konnan) beat Petey Williams & Bobby Rude in a match taped for Xplosion..
- June 25, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude defeated America’s Most Wanted in a NON TITLE match..
- June 19, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley..
- June 27, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Alex Shelley/Ruffy Silverstein/Conrad Kennedy III b Zach Gowen/Petey Williams/Chris Sabin..
- June 30, 2004 – TNA: Sabu & Sonjay Dutt defeated Bobby Rude & Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore..
- July 2, 2004 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Petey Williams & Bobby Rude & Eric Young) defeated 3-Live Krew w/Dennis Rodman..
- July 7, 2004 – TNA: Chris Daniels & Primetime beat Chris Sabin & Red and Petey Williams & Bobby Rude in a 3-WAY..
- July 9, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin and AJ Styles in a 3-WAY (Non title match)..
- July 10, 2004 – CZW BotB 4: Sonjay Dutt defeated Petey Williams in the quarter-finals of the Tournament..
- July 14, 2004 – TNA: Primetime & C.Daniels & Red & C.Sabin beat P.Williams & B.Rude & Eric Young & Johnny Devine..
- July 17, 2004–Buffalo Brawl: Julio Dinero defeated Petey Williams in the first round of the Natural tournament..
- July 23, 2004 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Williams/Rude/Devine/Young) beat Chris Sabin & Mikey Batts & Sonjay Dutt & Red..
- July 28, 2004 – TNA PPV: America’s Most Wanted (Chris Harris & James Storm) beat Bobby Rude & Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore..
- July 30, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude w/Scott D’Amore defeated Jerrelle Clark & Mark Laurnoff..
- July 31, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley to retain IWA title in a Best 2/3 falls match..
- August 4, 2004 – TNA PPV: America’s Most Wanted defeated Petey Williams & Bobby Rude in a “Country Whippin” match..
- August 6, 2004 – TNA Impact: Kid Kash & Kazarian & Shane & Petey Williams beat Chris Daniels & Primetime & Dutt & Sabin..
Border City Wrestling + Total Nonstop Action (X-Division Champion) + IWA: Mid South + Others…:
- August 11, 2004 – TNA PPV: Petey Williams won a 20-Man Gauntlet Match to win the X-Division title!
- August 13, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated The Amazing Red to retain the X-Division title..
- August 18, 2004 – TNA PPV: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin to retain the X-Division title..
- August 27, 2004 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Williams,Rude,Young,Devine) beat Rod & Bruce Steele & Mikey Batts & Jerrelle Clark..
- September 1, 2004 – TNA PPV: Petey Williams defeated Sonjay Dutt to retain the X-Division championship..
- September 15, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated C.M. Punk to retain the IWA Heavyweight title..
- September 16, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated B-Boy to retain the IWA Heavywieght title..
- September 17, 2004–IWA MS TPI Round #1: Petey Williams defeated B.J. Whitmer to retain the IWA Heavyweight title..
- September 18, 2004–IWA MS Ted Petty Invitational Round #2: Arik Cannon defeated Petey Williams (wins IWA title)..
- September 19, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams & Bobby Roode beat Eddie Venom & N8 Mattson to win the Tag titles..
- September 24, 2004 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Jerrelle Clark..
- September 25, 2004–International Wrestling Cartel: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley..
- October 8, 2004 – TNA Xplosion: America’s Most Wanted & Triple X defeated Team Canada (Williams/Rude/Young/Silverstein)..
- October 20, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- October 21, 2004–IWA Mid South: AJ Styles beat Petey Williams and Chris Daniels and Chris Sabin to win the vacant IWA title..
- October 22, 2004 – TNA Xplosion: Alex Shelley & Petey Williams defeated Shark Boy & D-Ray 3000..
- October 29, 2004 – TNA Impact: Jeff Hardy defeated Petey William (X-Division Champion) w/Scott D’Amore..
- November 5, 2004 – TNA Impact: AJ Styles & Ron Killings (sub for Jeff Hardy) defeated Petey Williams & Jeff Jarrett..
- November 7, 2004 – TNA Victory Road: Petey Williams defeated AJ Styles with help from Scott D’Amore to retain the X-title..
- November 11, 2004 – Best Damn Wrestling Show Period: Petey Williams b Sonjay Dutt, Jerrelle Clark, Shark Boy & Michael Shane..
- November 13, 2004–Universal Wrestling Alliance: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude beat Alex Shelley & Gutter to retain the Tag titles..
- November 19, 2004 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Petey Williams & Bobby Rude) defeated Jerrelle Clark & Mikey Batts..
- November 19, 2004–IWA Mid South: Nate Webb & Matt Sydal defeated Petey Williams & Delirious..
- November 20, 2004–IWA Mid South: Ryan Boz & Brad Bradley defeated Alex Shelley & Petey Williams..
- November 21, 2004–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude defeated Ruffy Silverstein & Conrad Kennedy III..
- November 26, 2004 – TNA Impact: Chris Sabin defeated Michael Shane and Petey Williams in a 3-WAY (NON TITLE)..
- November 28, 2004–Border City/Prime Time: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude beat Gutter & Chris Sabin to retain the Tag titles..
- December 5, 2004 – Turning Point: Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore defeated Chris Sabin to retain the X-Division championship..
- December 13, 2004 – Night of Appreciation for Sabu: Petey Williams & Johnny Devine defeated James Storm & Gutter..
- December 17, 2004–IWA Mid South: Trik Davis won four-way over Petey Williams and Josh Abercrombie and Matt Turner..
- December 18, 2004–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated Spyder Nate Webb to retain the TNA X title..
- December 19, 2004–Border City: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude beat Ruffy Silverstein & Conrad Kennedy III to retain the Tag titles..
- January 7, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore defeated Andy Douglas w/Chase Stevens..
- January 15, 2005–IWA Mid South: Petey Williams defeated Chad Collyer..
- January 16, 2005 – Final Resolution: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams and Chris Sabin in an Ultimate X match to capture the X-title!
Border City Wrestling + Total Nonstop Action (Team Canada) + IWA: Mid South + Others…:
- January 21, 2005–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams & Bobby Rude beat Chris Harris & Tritan to retain Tag Team titles..
- February 4, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Shark Boy..
- February 4, 2005–IWA Mid South: Alex Shelley defeated Petey Williams..
- February 12, 2005–EWR: Petey Williams won four-way over Excess and Hell Storm and Crazy Crusher to win EWR title..
- February 13, 2005 – TNA Against All Odds: Elix Skipper defeated Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore..
- February 25, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Eric Young & Bobby Rude defeated Dustin Rhodes & America’s Most Wanted..
- March 4, 2005 – TNA Impact: Chris Candido & Chase Stevens & Andy Douglas beat Elix Skipper & Petey Williams & Mikey Batts..
- March 13, 2005 – TNA Destination X: Team Canada (Williams/Young/Rude/A-1) defeated America’s Most Wanted & 3 Live Krew..
- March 19, 2005–TWC International Showdown: Petey Williams beat Spud and Chris Sabin and Jonny Storm in a 4-WAY..
- April 1, 2005 – TNA Impact: Elix Skipper defeated Chris Sabin and Michael Shane and Petey Williams in a #1 Contenders 4-WAY..
- April 1, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Jonny Storm defeated Petey Williams..
- April 2, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Petey Williams defeated Joey Ryan..
- April 9, 2005–ECWA Super 8: Petey Willaims beat Rory Fox, then Alex Shelley, then Puma to win the Super 8 Tournament!
- April 15, 2005 – TNA Impact: BG James & Ron Killings defeated Petey Williams & Alistair Ralph w/Scott D’amore
- April 15, 2005–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams won four-way over El Reverso and Derek Wylde and [Insert].
- April 17, 2005–Prime Time/Border City: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley in a 3-WAY to win the TV Title..
- April 23, 2005–BWCW: Chris Sabin beat Truth Martini and Zach Gowen and Petey Williams to win the Cruiserweight title..
- April 24, 2005 – TNA Lockdown: America’s Most Wanted beat Petey Williams & Eric Young in a Cage Strap Match to retain..
- April 29, 2005 – TNA Impact: Shocker defeated Petey Williams..
- May 15, 2005 – TNA Hard Justice: Team Canada (Eric Young & Petey Williams) defeated Sonny Siaki & Gran Apollo..
- ~~~Later on that night: Petey Williams participated in the #1 Contenders 20-Man Gauntlet Match (won by Abyss)..
- June 4, 2005: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams in a Best 2/3 Falls match to retain the NWA title in ROME, Italy!
- May 13, 2005–X3 Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin..
- ~~~The promoter, Tim Shady, disappeared at intermission without paying a lot of the guys..
- May 14, 2005–NWA Upstate: Petey Williams defeated Dunn to win No Limits title..
- May 21, 2005–NWA Cyberspace: Petey Williams defeated Shark Boy..
- June 10-11, 2005–NWA Florida: Petey Williams participated in the 2-night 2005 Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup Tournament..
- ~~~Petey Williams defeated Jerrelle Clark (1st round match) | Jimmy Rave defeated Petey Williams (2nd round match)..
- June 18, 2005 – ROH: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams w/Prince Nana & The Embassy..
- June 19, 2005 – Slammiversary: The Naturals w/Jimmy Hart defeated Team Canada (Williams/Young) to retain the Tag Team titles..
- June 26, 2005–Warrior 1 Wrestling: Sinn & Slash defeated Bobby Rude & Petey Williams…
- July 1, 2005–International Wrestling Cartel: Shiima Xion & Petey Williams defeated Jason Gary & Chris Sabin..
- July 8, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Amazing Red while Chris Daniels did commentary..
- July 9, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Ricky Reyes defeated Petey Williams..
- July 10, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Petey Williams & Chris Sabin defeated Scott Lost & Joey Ryan..
- July 15, 2005 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Petey Williams & Eric Young) defeated Samoa Joe & Christopher Daniels..
- ~~~Chris Sabin brawled with Samoa Joe to the back leaving Chris Daniels to get hit with a Canadian Destroyer and pinned!
- July 15, 2005–Ballpark Brawl IV: Chris Sabin beat Roderick Strong, Jay Lethal, Petey Williams, Shawn Spears & Mastiff (6-WAY)..
- July 17, 2005 – No Surrender: Christopher Daniels defeated Petey Williams w/Scott D’Amore to retain the X-Division title..
- July 22, 2005–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams beat AJ Styles and Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley to retain the TV title..
- July 29, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin in the first round of the Super X Tournament..
- August 12, 2005 – TNA Impact: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams to advance to the Super X Tournament finals..
- August 13, 2005–Ballpark Brawl: Petey Williams & Eric Young defeated Shawn Spears & Derek Wylde..
- August 14, 2005 – TNA Sacrifice: Team Canada defeated America’s Most Wanted & The Naturals w/Jimmy Hart..
- ~~~Team Canada = Petey Williams, Bobby Rude, Eric Young and Alistair Ralph w/Scott D’Amore..
- August 19, 2005–PWG: Human Tornado & El Generico beat Petey Williams & Frankie Kazarian to retain the Tag Team titles..
- August 20, 2005–NWA Legends Convention: Petey Williams defeated “Primetime” Elix Skipper..
- August 21, 2005–NWA Cyberspace: Chris Harris beat James Storm, Petey Williams, Bobby Rude, Shark Boy & ?? Maximo (6-WAY)..
- August 25, 2005–UWA: Bobby Roode & Petey Williams defeated Shawn McMillan & Virus by DQ..
- August 26, 2005 – TNA Impact: Lance Hoyt & Konnan beat Kip James & Petey Williams in the Chris Candido Cup Tournament..
- August 28, 2005–Blood, Sweat & Ears: Christopher Daniels won three-way over Chris Sabin and Petey Williams..
- September 11, 2005 – TNA Unbreakable: Chris Sabin defeated Petey Williams (Matt Bentley returned to TNA and superkicked Sabin!)
- October 14, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerilla: Super Dragon & Davey Richards defeated Chris Sabin & Petey Williams..
- October 15, 2005–Christian Wrestling Entertainment: A.J. Styles defeated Petey Williams and Jimmy Yang to win the CWE Title..
- September 15, 2005–Border City Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Jerry Lynn to retain the Television title (Can Am Cup)..
- September 25, 2005–NWA Cyberspace: Elix Skipper defeated Petey Williams to keep the Cyberspace X-Division title..
- October 1, 2005 – TNA Impact: Chris Sabin defeated Alex Shelley and Petey Williams in a Triple Threat match..
- October 2, 2005–Prime Time Wrestling (Tournament): Petey Williams beat Amazing Red | Monty Brown beat Petey Williams..
- October 23, 2005 – TNA Bound For Glory: Petey Williams defeated Matt Bentley and Chris Sabin in an Ultimate X match..
- October 30, 2005–Blood, Sweat and Ears: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin.
Total Nonstop Action (Team Canada) + Border City Wrestling…:
- November 3, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated Matt Bentley and Chris Sabin in an Ultimate-X rematch..
- November 5, 2005–EWR Elite 8: Petey Williams defeated Excess in the first round of the EWR Elite 8 Tournament!
- ~~~Petey Williams defeated El Generico in the 2nd Round | Kevin Steen defeated Petey Williams to win Elite 8 Tournament!
- November 12, 2005 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams defeated AJ Styles in a “Finishers” match by hitting the Canadian Destroyer!
- November 13, 2005 – TNA Genesis: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams w/A-1 to retain the X-Division title (as Samoa Joe watched)..
- November 18, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin..
- November 19, 2005–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Chris Sabin & Frankie Kazarian defeated Petey Williams & Aaron Aguilera..
- November 27, 2005–International Wrestling Cartel: John McChesney defeated Petey Williams to retain the Super Indy title..
- December 3, 2005 – TNA Impact: Chris Sabin defeated Petey Williams and Alex Shelley and Austin Aries in a 4-WAY..
- December 11, 2005 – TNA Turning Point: Team Canada w/Scott D’Amore defeated 4-live Krew when Konnan turned on Kip James!
- ~~~Team Canada: Petey Williams, Bobby Rude, Eric Young & A-1 | 4-Live Krew: BG James, Kip James, Konnan & Ron Killings..
- December 16, 2005–PWG: Frankie Kazarian/Chris Sabin/TJ Perkins/Rocky Romero beat Williams/Chris Daniels/Alex Koslov/B-Boy..
- December 17, 2005 – TNA Impact: Team Canada (Williams/Roode/A-1) defeated Chase Stevens & Andy Douglas & Shark Boy..
- ~~~Jeff Jarrett formed an alliance with AMW, Abyss & James Mitchell, Team Canada & Scott D’Amore… and Monty Brown!
2006: Total Nonstop Action (Team Canada) + Border City Wrestling…:
- January 6, 2006–1PW – No Turning Back 1: Jerry Lynn defeated Petey Williams in Doncaster, England …
- January 7, 2006–1PW – No Turning Back 2: Joey Fleisch beat Jerry Lynn and Jonny Storm and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- January 14, 2006 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Eric Young & A-1 beat Chris Sabin & Sonjay Dutt & Matt Bentley w/Tracy Brooks..
- January 15, 2006 – Final Resolution Pre-show: Petey Williams & Eric Young & A-1 defeated Lance Hoyt & Jay Lethal & Kenny King..
- January 21, 2006 – TNA Impact: Petey Williams & Eric Young & A-1 defeated Ron Killings & Lance Hoyt & Shark Boy..
- January 22, 2006–Prime Time Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Phil Atlas in a Semi-Final Tournament match…
- ~~~Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin in a Ladder match to win the Cruiserweight Tournament (tore the house down)..
- January 28, 2006 – TNA Impact: Team Canada beat Ron Killings & The Naturals & Cassidy Riley in a match taped for Xplosion..
- January 28, 2006–PW Elite: Brandon Thomaselli defeated Petey Williams and Azrieal in a 3-WAY..
- February 4, 2006 – TNA Impact: Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin beat Team Canada (Petey Williams & A-1) in a #1 Contenders Tournament..
- February 12, 2006 – Against All Odds: Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley and Alex Shelley and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- February 18, 2006 – TNA Impact: Ron Killings & Team 3-D defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode & Petey Williams & A-1)..
- February 26, 2006–Blood, Sweat, & Ears: Petey Williams defeated “Fallen Angel” Christopher Daniels..
- March 3, 2006–UWF: Petey Williams defeated Matt Bentley….
- March 4, 2006 – TNA Impact: The Naturals & Ron Killings beat Team Canada (Petey Williams/Bobby Roode/A-1) for Xplosion..
- ~~~ON TV: Petey Williams & Bobby Roode & Eric Young w/Scott D’Amore defeated Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal..
- March 12, 2006 – Destination-X: Chris Sabin (USA) beat Puma (Japan) and Petey Williams (Canada) and Sonjay Dutt (India)..
- March 17, 2006–TNA 1st-Ever House Show: Insane Clown Posse (Shaggy 2 Dope & Violent J) beat Petey Williams & Eric Young..
- March 31, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Jerry Lynn & Sonjay Dutt defeated Team Canada (Petey Williams & Eric Young)..
- April 1, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Sonjay Dutt defeated Petey Williams and Jerry Lynn in a 3-WAY……
- April 15, 2006–International Wrestling Cartel: Matt Sydal defeated Petey Williams in the 1st Round of the Super Indy Tournament..
- April 20, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Team Canada (Williams/Roode/Young/A-1) defeated Team USA (Dutt/Sabin/Lethal/Shelley)..
- April 23, 2006 – TNA Lockdown: Chris Sabin beat Elix Skipper, Petey Williams, Shark Boy, Chase Stevens & Puma (Escape the Cage)..
- April 28, 2006–UWA Hardcore: Josh Prohibition defeated Petey Williams (playing a fan in the crowd)..
- May 20, 2006–Windy City Wrestling: Isasis Velazquez beat Marche Rockett and Petey Williams to win the Lightweight title..
- May 14, 2006 – TNA Sacrifice: Jushin Thunder Liger w/Team Japan defeated Petey Williams w/Team Canada..
- ~~~Later on: Petey Williams (Team Canada) defeated Puma (Team Mexico) in the Finals of a 16-Man World X-Cup Gauntlet Match..
- May 18, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin defeated Petey Williams in a TIE-breaker to win the World X-Cup for Team USA…
- May 26, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Petey Williams defeated Chris Sabin…
- May 27, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Monty Brown & Petey Williams defeated Rhino & Kip James..
- June 1, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin defeated Petey Williams & Eric Young in a match taped for Xplosion..
- June 3, 2006–Children’s Benefit Show: Petey Williams defeated Josh Daniels….
- June 9, 2006–TNA Hardcore War: Petey Williams defeated Jerry Lynn after a Canadian Destroyer….
- June 10, 2006–TNA House Show (LSW): Petey Williams defeated Shark Boy….
- June 11, 2006–Action Packed Wrestling: Petey Williams & A-1 beat Jeff Brooks & Jason Harris in Pontiac, Michigan..
- June 18, 2006 – TNA Slammiversary: Senshi beat Alex Shelley & Petey Williams & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt & Shark Boy in a 6-WAY..
- June 22, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Ron Killings & Sonjay Dutt defeated Petey Williams & Bobby Roode in a match taped for Xplosion..
- June 23, 2006–UWA Hardcore Wrestling: Puma defeated Petey Williams to retain the Canadian title..
- July 1, 2006–Fourth Coast Championship Wrestling: Petey Williams & Hybrid Rain defeated The Hellraizers. …
- July 9, 2006–Maryland Championship Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Josh Daniels in the 1st Round of the Shane Shamrock Cup..
- ~~~Ruckus beat Derek Frazier and Jerry Lynn and Chris Sabin and Steve Anthony and Petey Williams in a 6-WAY to win the Cup!
- July 13, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Team 3-D & Rhino & Jay Lethal defeated Team Canada (as a result, Team Canada forced to dispand)..
- July 15, 2006–Border City Wrestling: N8 Mattson defeated Petey Williams to win the BCW Television title..
- July 16, 2006 – TNA Victory Road: Scott D’Amore wished each member of Team Canada well — but ignoring and picked on Eric Young..
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams on his own:
- July 20, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sonjay Dutt & Chris Sabin defeated Senshi & Petey Williams in a dark match..
- July 21, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF): Christopher Daniels defeated Petey Williams…
- July 22, 2006–TNA House Show (UWF: “Showtime” Eric Young defeated “Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams…
- July 27, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams defeated Sonjay Dutt and Johnny Devine and Shark Boy in a 4-WAY X-Division match..
- August 3, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams beat Jay Lethal and Alex Shelley and Sonjay Dutt and Frankie Kazarian in a 5-WAY..
- August 10, 2006–TNA House Show: Chris Daniels & AJ Styles beat Samoa Joe & Petey Williams to retain the Tag Team titles..
- August 11, 2006–TNA House Show: Ron “The Truth” Killings defeated Petey Williams..
- August 12, 2006–TNA House Show: Brother Runt defeated Petey Williams…
- August 13, 2006 – TNA Hard Justice: Senshi beat Petey Williams and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY to retain the X-Division title..
- August 17, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal beat Alex Shelley & Johnny Devine & Petey Williams ..
- August 31, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams & Senshi..
- September 1, 2006–PWG: Human Tornado/Excalibur/B-Boy/Homicide beat Joey Ryan/Scott Lost/Chris Bosh/Petey Williams
- September 2, 2006–PWG: Human Tornado beat Joey Ryan and Excalibur and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY to win the PWG Title!
- September 21, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams in an X-Division match..
- September 22, 2006–NWA Wisconsin: Petey Williams defeated Dysfunction in Del Perre, Wisconsin..
- September 29, 2006–TNA House Show: Petey Williams defeated Shark Boy and Eric Young and Chris Sabin in a 4-WAY..
- September 30, 2006–TNA House Show: America’s Most Wanted & Petey Williams beat The James Gang & Hermie Sadler..
- October 7, 2006–AWA When Worlds Collide: Envy defeated Petey Williams to retain the AWA Anarchy Heavyweight title..
- October 12, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Sabin & Lethal & Dutt & Shark defeated Senshi & Shelley & Devine & Petey Williams..
- October 14, 2006–All Pro Wrestling: Mr. Prime Time defeated Petey Williams in Bakersfield, California..
- October 14, 2006–GZW: Petey Williams defeated Joey Ryan in a qualifying match to advance to a 3-WAY for the GZW Title..
- ~~~MAIN EVENT: Hijo del Chupacabra defeated Dana Lee and Petey Williams in a 3-WAY to win the GZW Heavyweight title….
- October 22, 2006 – TNA Bound For Glory: Petey Williams was in the Kevin Nash Open Invitational X-Division Gauntlet Battle Royal!
- November 9, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Austin Starr (w/Kevin Nash & Alex Shelley) beat Petey Williams and Johnny Devine in a 3-WAY..
- November 10, 2006–TNA House Show: Petey Williams defeated Sonjay Dutt.
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams:
- November 16, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Konnan, Homicide & Hernandez tried to burn the American flah but Petey Williams saved the day!
- November 17, 2006–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: “Classic” Colt Cabana defeated “Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams..
- November 18, 2006–Pro Wrestling Guerrilla: Human Tornado defeated “Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams..
- November 23, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: LAX attacked Petey Williams until America’s Most Wanted & Kurt Angle made the save!
- November 25, 2006–TNA House Show: AJ Styles defeated Petey Williams and Eric Young in a 3-WAY in Monterrey, Mexico..
- December 7, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams beat Homicide (w/Konnan & Hernandez)- America’s Most Wanted made the save!..
- December 11, 2006 – TNA Turning Point: Petey Williams interfered in the LAX vs AMW “Flag” match which was won by LAX..
- December 13, 2006–Prime Time Wrestling: Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley defeated Petey Williams & Phil Atlas……
- December 14, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams defeated X-Division Champion Christopher Daniels in a Non-title match..
- December 15, 2006–TNA House Show: Petey Williams defeated Alex Shelley and Jay Lethal in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders match
- December 16, 2006–TNA House Show: Christopher Daniels defeated Petey Williams to retain the X Division title…..
- December 28, 2006 – TNA iMPACT: Chris Sabin & James Storm defeated Christopher Daniels & Petey Williams in a Tag Team match..
- ~~~In the ring, James Storm avoided the Canadian Destroyer from Petey Williams and scored the pin to win the match!
- December 2006: Petey Williams Canadian Destroyer was voted the “Finisher of the Year” on the TNA.com Year End Awards..
- January 11, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: A.J. Styles & Chris Sabin & James Storm beat Christopher Daniels & Petey Williams & Rhino..
- January 14, 2007 – TNA Final Resolution: “Tennessee Cowboy” James Storm w/Gail Kim defeated “Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams..
- ~~~After the match: Gail Kim stood up to James Storm and they got into a fight until Jacqueline showed up and attacked Gail Kim!
- January 20, 2007–TNA House Show: Petey Williams defeated Sonjay Dutt in Birmingham, Alabama …
- January 2?, 2007–German Stampede Wrestling: X-Dream defeated Petey Williams with a Shooting Star Press
- February 1, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Robert Roode w/Tracy Brooks defeated Petey Williams w/Gail Kim..
- February 12, 2007 – TNA Against All Odds: James Storm & Jacqueline Moore defeated Petey Williams & Gail Kim..
- February 22, 2007 – TNA Xplosion: Petey Williams & Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt defeated Serotonin (Bentley & Kazarian & Devine)..
- March 2, 2007–Hermie Sadler’s UWF: “Tennessee Cowboy” James Storm defeated “Canadian Destroyer” Petey Williams
- March 8, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: James Storm & Robert Roode & Eric Young defeated Petey Williams & Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal..
- March 11, 2007 – TNA Destination-X: James Storm & Jacqueline defeated Petey Williams & Gail Kim in a Double Bullrope match..
- March 22, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Austin Starr defeated Eric Young after interference from Robert Roode & Tracy Brooks..
- ~~~After the match: Robert Roode & Tracy Brooks berated Eric Young until Petey Williams ran out to save him!
- March 29, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jerry Lynn beat Petey Williams & Sonjay Dutt & Austin Starr & Alex Shelley & Shark Boy in a Cage..
- April 12, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Robert Roode & Jackie Moore w/Tracy Brooks defeated Petey Williams & Gail Kim..
- April 15, 2007 – TNA Lockdown: Robert Roode (w/Tracy Brooks & Eric Young) defeating Petey Williams in Six Sides of Steel..
- April 20, 2007–RGW: Petey Williams beat T.L. Money | Petey Williams & Steve Boz beat Milo Cash & T.L. Money…
- April 26, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt won a 4-WAY Tag match and will face Chris Sabin in a 3-WAY at Sacrifice..
- ~~~Sonjay Dutt & Jay Lethal defeated Alex Shelley & Kaz and Shark Boy & Senshi and Jerry Lynn & Petey Williams in a 4-WAY ..
- April 28, 2007–CWR: Don Paysan defeated Petey Williams to retain the CWR Canadian Junior Heavyweight title.. ..
- May 14, 2007–TNA Tapings: Petey Williams & Eric Young beat Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley in a match taped for Xplosion..
- June 7, 2007–Premier Championship Wrestling: Petey Williams defeated Don Douglas in the 1st Round of a Tournament..
- ~~~Petey Williams received a bye (2nd Round) | Kenny Omega defeated Petey Williams in the Finals to win the Premier Cup!
- July 2, 2007–TNA TV TAPINGS: ” The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal defeated Petey Williams in a dark match..
- July 13, 2007–CWA: Josh Magnum defeated Petey Williams by DQ in Columbia, South Carolina ..
- July 16, 2007–TNA TV Tapings: Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin defeated Sonjay Dutt & Petey Williams (taped for Xplosion)..
- July 15, 2007 – TNA Victory Road: Petey Williams participated in a 10-Man X-Division Gauntlet Ultimate-X Match!
- September 9, 2007 – TNA No Surrender: Petey & Sonjay Dutt participated in a Tag Team Gauntlet Match (won by Styles/Tomko)..
- October 4, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams participated in a 10-Man Gauntlet Match (Won by “Showtime” Eric Young)..
- October 11, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Robert Roode w/Tracy Brooks defeated Petey Williams..
- October 14, 2007 – TNA Bound For Glory: Petey Williams participated in the Fight For the Right Series (Won by Eric Young)..
- October 20, 2007–Pro Wrestling Xtreme: Petey Williams defeated Asylum in Milton, Ontario …
- October 25, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Shark Boy vs. Havok – No Contest when Team 3-D interfered..
Total Nonstop Action – “Maple Leaf Muscle” Petey Williams:
- December 2, 2007 – TNA Turning Point: Petey Williams earned one-of-four special briefcases in a “Feast or Fired” match..
- ~~~The cases contained 1) World title shot, 2) World Tag Team title shot, 3) X-Division title shot, or 4) A TNA Pink Slip!
- December 9, 2007–Prime Time Wrestling: Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin beat Petey Williams & Tyson Dux in Belleville, Michigan..
- December 13, 2007 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner defeated BG James and Christopher Daniels and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- ~~~As a result, Scott Steiner had a choice between $50,000 or he could trade briefcases with any of the three participants…
- ~~~Scott Steiner chose to trade cases with Petey Williams, who was previously bragging that he had the World title shot!
- ~~~They opened Petey Williams’ briefcase (which WAS Scott Steiner’s case) – a TNA World Heavyweight title shot!
- January 3, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams defeated Senshi in the Finals of the TNA X-Division Gauntlet Match!
- January 10, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams & Sonjay Dutt defeated Voodoo Kin Mafia (BG & Kip James w/Roxxi Leveaux)..
- ~~~Scott Steiner snuck down to ringside during the match and stole Petey Williams’ “Feast of Fired” case (World title shot)….
- January 18, 2008–UWA: Petey Williams defeated Josh Prohibition by DQ after Lionel Knight & Johnny Gargano interfered
- January 31, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: The Rock & Rave Infection w/Christy Hemme defeated Scott Steiner & Petey Williams..
- ~~~Midway though the match: Scott Steiner cracked Petey Williams with a briefcase and took BOTH briefcases backstage..
- February 10, 2008 – TNA Against All Odds: Scott Steiner defeated Petey Williams with the help of a mystery large black woman!
- ~~~Scott Steiner now wins both the TNA X-Division title shot (briefcase) AND the TNA World Heavyweight title shot (briefcase)..
- February 14, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner w/Rhaka Khan defeated Petey Williams (Scott showed respect to Petey afterwards!)
Total Nonstop Action – Scott Steiner & Petey Williams (The Initiation Phase):
- February 21, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams defeated Johnny Devine and Sonjay Dutt in a 3-WAY #1 Contenders match..
- ~~~”Big Poppa Pump” Scott Steiner (with Rhaka Khan) came out and helped Petey Williams win and then showed his support..
- February 28, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams & Scott Steiner w/Rhaka Khan defeated Jay Lethal & Sonjay Dutt…
- March 1, 2008–Combined Wrestling Federation: Shawn Daivari vs. Petey Williams ended in a No Contest in San Antonio, Texas ..
- March 6, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams participated in a Destination-X Battle Royal (Won by Curry Man)..
- March 9, 2008 – TNA Destination-X: “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal beat Petey Williams to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~Scott Steiner interfered and Petey Williams nailed the Canadian Destroyer on Lethal but So-Cal Val pulled the referee out..
- ~~~Rhaka Khan went after So-Cal Val but “The GURU” Sonjay Dutt got between them while Jay Lethal scored the pinfall..
- March 13, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Curry Man defeated Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan to qualify for the X-Scape match at Lockdown..
- ~~~After the match: Scott Steiner & Rhaka Khan came down and put handcuffs on Petey Williams as well as a blindfold..
- March 20, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner & Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan defeated Eric Young & Kaz in a tag team match..
- ~~~After the match; Scott Steiner handcuffed Petey Williams again and placed a black bag over his head as part of his initiation….
- March 27, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: LAX (Homicide & Hernandez & Salinas) defeated Scott Steiner & Petey Williams & Rhaka Khan..
- ~~~After the match: Scott Steiner & Rhaka Khan blindfolded Petey Williams to give him some more of their special “initiation”..
- April 10, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner & Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan defeated The Motor City Machine Guns..
- ~~~After the match; Scott Steiner & Rhaka Khan put Petey Williams through his final initiation – SHAVING HIM BALD!
Total Nonstop Action – Scott Steiner & Petey Williams (“Little Petey Pump”):
- April 13, 2008 – TNA Lockdown: Steiner & Williams participated the first ever Cuffed in the Cage match (won by SUPER ERIC!)
- April 17, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val defeated Johnny Devine to retain the X-Division title..
- ~~~After the match; “Little Petey Pump” Petey Williams whacked Jay Lethal with his briefcase and cashed in his title shot!
- ~~~Petey Williams w/Rhaka Kahn defeated “The Black Machismo” Jay Lethal w/So-Cal Val to capture the TNA X-Division title!
- April 20, 2008–XICW: TNA’s Petey Williams defeated “Amazing” N8 Mattson in Warren, Michigan..
- May 1, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Samoa Joe & Kurt Angle defeated Scott Steiner & Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan in the main event..
- May 8, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jimmy Rave beat Petey Williams & Johnny Devine & Shark Boy & Curry Man & Consequences Creed..
- June 8, 2008 – TNA Slammiversary: Petey Williams (w/Scott Steiner & Rhaka Khan) defeated Kaz to retain the TNA X-Division title.
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams (w/Rhaka Khan) vs. Consequences Creed:
- July 10, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams & Tomko & Kip James defeated BG James & Eric Young & Matt Morgan..
- July 17, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan defeated Kaz to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- July 31, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Consequences Creed defeated TNA X-Division champion Petey Williams in a Non-title match..
- August 10, 2008 – TNA Hard Justice: Petey Williams defeated Consequences Creed to retain the TNA X-Division title..
- ~~~Sheik Abdul Bashir cracked Consequences Creed with a chair and said he was representative of the entire USA.
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams (w/Rhaka Khan) vs. Consequences Creed vs. Sheik Abdul Bashir:
- August 21, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Consequences Creed defeated TNA X-Division Champion Petey Williams w/Rhaka Khan by DQ..
- August 28, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Jay Lethal & Consequences Creed defeated Petey Williams (w/Rhaka Khan) & Sheik Abdul Bashir..
- September 14, 2008 – TNA No Surrender: Sheik Abdul Bashir defeated Petey Williams and Creed to capture the TNA X-Division title!
- September 18, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Super Eric & Shark Boy & Curry Man beat Petey Williams & Johnny Devine & Jimmy Rave..
- October 9, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Consequences Creed defeated Petey Williams and Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt in a 4-WAY..
- October 12, 2008 – TNA Bound For Glory: “Black Machismo” Jay Lethal won an X-Division Steel Asylum #1 Contenders match..
- ~~~Jay Lethal-Sonjay Dutt-Chris Sabin-Alex Shelley-Shark Boy-Curry Man-Super Eric-Petey Williams-Jimmy Rave-Johnny Devine
- November 9, 2008 – TNA Turning Point: Eric Young won the X-Division Rankings Elimination Match against nine other wrestlers..
- ~~~Consequences Creed-Jay Lethal-Sonjay Dutt-Homicide-Petey Williams-Jimmy Rave-Doug Williams-Volador-Hiroshi Tanahashi
- November 13, 2008 – TNA iMPACT: Petey Williams reached out to Scott Steiner, but was destroyed by the Main Event Mafia..
- December 7, 2008 – TNA Final Resolution: Petey Williams participated in the annual Feast or Fired match but did not get a briefcase.
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams vs. Scott Steiner (Against All Odds):
- January 15, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: A.J. Styles defeated Scott Steiner after interference from Petey Williams..
- January 22, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner & Booker T defeated Petey Williams & Eric Young in an Elimination Match..
- January 29, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Matt Morgan defeated Petey Williams in a match where Petey’s arm was tied behind his back..
- ~~~Scott Steiner was at ringside giving Matt Morgan advice and locked Petey Williams in the Steiner Recliner after the match..
- February 8, 2009 – TNA Against All Odds: “Big Poppa Pump” Scott Steiner defeated “Maple Leaf Muscle” Petey Williams..
- ~~~After the match; Scott Steiner continued the assault on Petey Williams until the NEW Samoa Joe ran out to make the save!
Total Nonstop Action – Petey Williams jobs out.:
- February 10, 2009: Petey Williams left Total Nonstop Action after his contract expired without him resigning…
- February 12, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Scott Steiner defeated Petey Williams in a Headdress on a Poll match..
- February 19, 2009 – TNA iMPACT: Beer Money Inc. defeated Petey Williams & Eric Young to retain the TNA Tag Team titles..
- ~~~This was a BMI “Off the Wagon” Challenge, and Petey Williams was pinned, therefore he must leave TNA forever…
- ~~~Petey Williams showed real emotions after the match as the appreciative TNA fanbase gave him a warm standing ovation!
Petey Williams:
- June 26, 2009 – ROH: Austin Aries beat Delirious & Joey Ryan & Petey Williams & Sami Callihan & Rasche Brown in a 6-WAY..
- June 27, 2009 – Ring of Honor: Kenny King w/Rhett Titus defeated Petey Williams in a singles match..
- ~~~King & Titus attacked Petey Williams after the match, but Petey fought back and hit King with the Canadian Destroyer!
- September 18, 2009–Ring of Honor: Colt Cabana & Petey Williams defeated Austin Aries & Rhett Titus…
- September 19, 2009–Ring of Honor: Petey Williams defeated “Addicted to Love” Rhett Titus..
- September 25, 2009–Ring of Honor: Claudio Castagnoli defeated Chris Hero and El Generico and Petey Williams in a 4-WAY..
- September 26, 2009–Ring of Honor: Austin Aries defeated “Maple Leaf Muscle” Petey Williams to retain the ROH World title..
- October 9, 2009–Ring of Honor: Claudio Castagnoli defeated Colt Cabana and Ace Steel and Petey Williams om a 4-WAY..
- October 10, 2009–Ring of Honor: Claudio Castagnoli defeated Petey Williams in a Survival of the Fittest Qualifying match..
- November 13, 2009 Border City Wrestling: Scott D’Amore & Petey Williams defeated Joe Doering & Tyson Dux..
- ~~~with spcial guest referee Kurt Angle (Jake O’Reilly & Jon Bolen interfered until Rhino came out and took care of them).
- March 19, 2010–Ring of Honor: Austin Aries defeated Petey Williams with a roll up while holding the ropes!
- ~~~After the match, Petey Williams hit Austin Aries with the Canadian Destroyer!
- March 20, 2010–Ring of Honor: Eddie Edwards defeated Petey Williams to retain the ROH Television title..
- April 23, 2010–Ring of Honor: Chris Hero defeated Petey Williams to retain his #3 “Pick 6″ ranking..
- April 24, 2010–Ring of Honor: “Addicted to Love” Rhett Titus defeated Petey Williams…
- February 26, 2011–Clash Wrestling: Gavin Quinn defeated Petey Williams in Taylor, Michigan.
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling:
- April 4, 2013 – TNA IMPACT: Petey Williams defeated Sonjay Dutt and Mason Andrews in a triple threat #1 contenders match for the X Division championship.
- April 18, 2013 – TNA IMPACT: TNA X Division champion Kenny King defeated Petey Williams and Zema Ion in a triple threat match to retain the title.
- May 16, 2013 – TNA IMPACT: TNA X Division champion Kenny King defeated Petey Williams and Chris Sabin in a triple threat match to retain the title.
- May 23, 2013 – TNA IMPACT Suicide (T.J. Perkins under a mask) defeated Joey Ryan and Petey Williams in a triple threat match.
