WSU Tag Team titles w/Roxie Cotton & Annie Social defeating Amy Lee & Taylor Wilde (January 10, 2009);
NYWC Starlet title defeating Marti Belle (September 27, 2012);
March 8, 2008–Wrestling Superstars Unleashed: Roxie Cotton & Rick Cataldo were destroyed by Awesome Kong..
March 8, 2008–WSU: The Soul Sisters & Alere Little Feather defeated Roxie Cotton & Rick Cataldo & Annie Social Summer 2008: Rick Cataldo formed the “Beatdown Betties” with female wrestlers
Roxie Cotton & Annie Social..
June 21, 2008–Women Superstars Uncensored: The Beatdown Betties won a 3-WAY Tag Team Match.. ~~~Roxie Cotton & Rick Cataldo defeated The Soul Sisters and Missy Sampson & Alere Little Feather..
~~~After the match; Awesome Kong destroyed Roxie Cotton while Rick Cataldo sprinted to the locker room..
June 21, 2008–Women Superstars Uncensored: Roxie Cotton & Rick Cataldo beat The Soul Sisters (Jana & Latasha)..
October 10, 2008–WSU: Melissa Coates & Trixxie Lynn w/Sunny beat Annie Social & Rick Cataldo (w/Sean Hanson & R.Cotton)..
January 10, 2009–WSU: The Betties (Roxie Cotton & Annie Social & Rick Cataldo) won a 4-WAY for the WSU Tag team titles.. ~~~The Beatdown Betties beat Amy Lee & Taylor Wilde and Little Feather & Missy Sampson and Kylie Pierce & Lea Morrison..
April 11, 2009–WSU/NWS: Ref Hansen & Rick Cataldo participated in the King & Queen of the Ring Tournament.. ~~~Bison Bravado & Annie Social defeated J.D. Smoothie & Roxxie Cotton and Ref Hansen & Rick Cataldo in a 3-WAY..
June 6, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Annie Social & Roxie Cotton defeated Sean “Ref” Hanson & Rick Cataldo.. ~~~As a result of the stipulation, Annie Social & Roxxie Cotton won full possession of “The Beatdown Betties” Name..
June 6, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Participated in the 2009 WSU Uncensored Rumble (which was won by Nikki Roxx)..
August 22, 2009–WSU: Rick Cataldo attacked Roxie Cotton until fellow Beatdown Bettie, Annie Social, made the save! Missy Hyatt’s “MISSY’S MANOR” segment featured the Wedding Shower of Rick Cataldo & Sean “Ref” Hanson..
August 22, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Rick Cataldo defeated Roxie Cotton in a Loser Leaves WSU match..
WSU – Rick Cataldo & Brittney Savage:
October 3, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Becky Bayless w/Missy Hyatt defeated Rick Cataldo! ~~~~~~~~Later that Night; Brittney Savage attacked Alicia and revealed that she was aligned with “manager” Rick Cataldo..
~~~~~Brooke changed her name to “Brittney Savage,” and began curb stomping Alicia until Becky Bayless made the save!..
October 3, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored: Alicia & Becky Bayless w/Missy Hyatt beat Rick Cataldo & Brittney Savage..
December 12, 2009–Women Superstars Uncensored/NWS: Jennifer Cruz & Angelina Love defeated Rick Cataldo & Jana..
June 19, 2010–New York Wrestling Connection: Mercedes Martinez defeated Jana | Mercedes Martinez defeated Rick Cataldo.. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Mercedes Martinez defeated Brittney Savage in a Bull Rope match to retain the WSU Championship!
August 6, 2010–WSU: Niya defeated Rick Cataldo.
September 24, 2010–NYWC: Francis Kipland Stevens and Wendell Oliver Wentworth defeated Dickie Rodz and Rick Cataldo.
November 5, 2010–NYWC: Rick Cataldo and Dickie Rodz defeated Francis Kipland Stevens and Wendell Oliver Wentworth.
November 6, 2010–WSU: WSU All Guts No Glory champion Angel Orsini defeated Rick Cataldo, Brittney Savage, Cindy Rogers, Jana and Melissa Coates in a gauntlet match to retain the title.
November 27, 2010–New York Wrestling Connection: Brittney Savage w/Rick Cataldo defeated former Cosmo Club member Jana..
December 11, 2010–WSU: WSU All Guts No Glory champion Angel Orsini defeated Rick Cataldo to retain the title.
January 15, 2011–ACE Pro Wrestling: The Belle Saints defeated Brittney Savage and Rick Cataldo to retain the WSU Tag Team titles.
January 22, 2011–WSU: Alicia and Sassy Stephie defeated Rick Cataldo and Brittney Savage.
January 29, 2011–NYWC: Team Frewaks And Geeks (Alex Moore, Francis Kipland Stevens, JT Kasin, Mikey Whipwreck and Syther) defeated Apollyon, Dickie Rodz, Rex Lawless, Rick Cataldo and Stockade.
April 2, 2011–WSU: WSU tag team champions Marti Belle and Tina San Antonio defeated Rick Cataldo and Monique to retain the titles.
June 11, 2011–NYWC: Dickie Rodz and Nikki Syxx defeated Francis Kipland Stevens and Violet Stevens & John Silver and Rick Cataldo in a 3-way tag team match.
June 25, 2011–WSU: Amy Lee, Jamilia Craft, Jana and Nikki Syxx defeated Allysin Kay, Jennifer Cruz, Monique and Rick Cataldo. Rick Cataldo was in the Uncensored Rumble won by Lexxus.
July 28, 2011–NYWC: Rick Cataldo defeated Francis Kipland Stevens.
August 6, 2011–WSU: Gabby Gilbert defeated Rick Cataldo.
August 18, 2011–NYWC: Rick Cataldo and Nikki Syxx defeated Francis Kipland Stevens and Violet Stevens.
August 25, 2011–NYWC: NYWC Starlet champion Nikki Syxx defeated Rick Cataldo, Marti Belle and Violet Stevens in a 4-way match to retain the title.
November 12, 2011–NYWC: Francis Kipland Stevens defeated Rick Cataldo.
November 19, 2011–WSU: Becky Bayless defeated Rick Cataldo.
March 3, 2012–WSU: Jenny Rose and Jessie Brooks defeated Rick Cataldo and Ezavel Suena.
April 14, 2012–WSU: Jack Spades and Tina San Antonio defeated Rick Cataldo and JD Smoothie in the 1st round.
April 21, 2012–NYWC: Marti Belle defeated Rick Cataldo.
April 28, 2012–WSU: Rick Cataldo and Ezavel Suena defeated Annie Social and Kimber Lee.
May 5, 2012–EVOLVE: Marti Belle and Braydon Knight defeated Rick Cataldo and Nikki Syxx.
August 16, 2012–NYWC: Rick Cataldo defeated Brittney Savage.
August 23, 2012–NYWC: Rick Cataldo and Marti Belle defeated Brittney Savage and Nikki Addams.
September 15, 2012–NYWC: Nikki Adams and Ryan Rush defeated Rick Cataldo and J-Redd, Marti Belle and Matthew Justice & Brittney Savage and Justin Corino in a 4-way tag team match.
September 27, 2012–NYWC: Rick Cataldo defeated Marti Belle to win the NYWC Starlet title. Alicia was the special referee.
September 29, 2012–ACE: Nikki Addams defeated Rick Cataldo.
October 20, 2012–NYWC: NYWC Starlet champion Rick Cataldo defeated Nikki Addams to retain the title.
November 17, 2012–NYWC: Rick Cataldo and Brittney Savage defeated Alicia and Nikki Addams.
December 8, 2012–NYWC: Alicia, Nikki Addams and Steve Forge defeated Brittney Savage, Marti Belle and Rick Cataldo.
February 23, 2013–NYWC: NYWC Starlet champion Rick Cataldo defeated Marti Belle and Nikki Addams in a 3-way match to retain the title.
May 18, 2013–NYWC: Marti Belle defeated Rick Cataldo to win the NYWC Starlet title.
June 15, 2013–NYWC: NYWC Starlet champion Marti Belle defeated Rick Cataldo to retain the title.
July 13, 2013–NYWC: Matthew Justice defeated Rick Cataldo.
August 10, 2013–WSU: Rick Cataldo was in the Uncensored Rumble won by Ezavel Suena.
May 10, 2014–WSU: Drew Gulak and Kimber Lee defeated Rick Cataldo and Niya in the 1st round.