- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/BJ Payne defeating Mr. Black & Bull Buchanan (March 15, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/BJ Payne defeating Jason Lee & Derrick King (April 4, 2000);
- OVW (Ohio Valley Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/BJ Payne defeating Slash & Damian (July 19, 2000);
- 2000: Scotty Sabre formed a tag team with B.J. Payne known as the Paynethrillers..
- May 25, 2000–3rd Annual Pillman Memorial: Scotty Sabre defeated Reckless Youth..
- March 8, 2003–Carolina Wrestling Federation: Scotty Sabre defeated Kid Justice..
- March 22, 2003–Carolina Wrestling Federation: Scotty Sabre defeated Chris Collins..
- March 26, 2003 – NWA:TNA: Glen Gilbertti defeated Scotty Sabre in a match taped for Xplosion..
- April 30, 2004–Main Event Promotions: B.J. Payne defeated Scotty Sabre…
- August 14, 2004–Comnav Marianas Naval Base: Black Dragon defeated Scotty Sabre..
- February 5, 2005–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Matt Mason defeated Scotty Sabre to retain the OCW title..
- February 26, 2005–World Wrestling Council: Scotty Sabre defeated Stevie Lee..
- March 22, 2005–Heartland Wrestling Association: Matt Stryker defeated Scotty Sabre..
- April 9, 2005–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Al Snow defeated Scotty Sabre..
- May 13, 2005–X3 Wrestling: Road Dogg & Billy Gunn defeated B.J. Payne & Scotty Sabre..
- July 10, 2005–Border City Wrestling: Bobby Rude defeated Scotty Sabre..
- July 16, 2005–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Scotty Sabre defeated Carlton Kaz..
- July 28, 2005 – Velocity: MNM (Joey Mercury & Johnny Nitro w/Melina Perez) defeated Scotty Sabre & Steve Lee..
- August 8, 2005 – RAW: Chris Hamrick, Scotty Sabre and Glenn Spectre played extras as security guards..
- August 11, 2005 – Smackdown!: Road Warrior Animal & John Heidenreich squashed Scotty Sabre & Jason ????..
- December 5, 2005 – RAW: Trevor Murdoch defeated Scotty Sabre in a match taped for HEAT..