Title History
- PWS tag team titles w Alex Reynolds defeating Jay Silva and Pat Buck (June 7, 2014);
Career Highlights
- May 18, 2013 – PWS: Starman and The Drunken Swashbuckler defeated Reality Check (Devon Moore and Kyle Reynolds).
- June 8, 2013 – PWS: Fallah, Starman, The Blue Meanie and The Drunken Swashbuckler defeated Reality Check (Damian Gibbs, Dave Sturch, Devon Moore and Kyle Reynolds) in a tag team elimination match.
- September 20, 2013 – PWS: Devon Moore defeated Kyle Reynolds.
- October 26, 2013 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Devon Moore and Kevin Matthews in a street fight.
- November 16, 2013 – PWS: Arkim, Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Devon Moore, Kevin Matthews and Bonesaw.
- February 1, 2014 – WXW: The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) and Travis Dorian defeated Axel Lennox, Kyle Reynolds and Sgt. RJR.
- March 1, 2014 – WXW C4: BLK Jeez defeated ???, Donovan Dijak, Jay Busta, Kyle Reynolds and Mark Maverick in a 6-way match.
- March 8, 2014 – PWS: Kyle Reynolds defeated Big Lez and Little Mac in a 3-way match.
- March 22, 2014 – PWS: Kyle Reynolds won a battle royal.
- April 26, 2014 – PWS: Jay Silva and Pat Buck defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds to retain the tag team titles.
- June 7, 2014 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Jay Silva and Pat Buck to win the tag team titles.
- September 20, 2014 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Lance Storm and Justin Credible to retain the tag team titles.
- October 31, 2014 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards to retain the tag team titles.
- November 22, 2014 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated AC Gamble and Anthony Bowens to retain the titles.
- December 20, 2014 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Gregory Iron and Zach Gowen to retain the tag team titles.
- January 31, 2015 – PWS: Gregory Iron and Zach Gowen defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds to win the tag team titles.
- February 13, 2015 – CAP: Kyle Reynolds defeated Dickie Rodz.
- February 21, 2015 – PWS: PWS tag team champions Gregory Iron and Zach Gowen defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds, Beefcake Charlie and Damian Gibbs & Craven Varro and Devon Moore in a 4-way tag team match to retain the titles.
- March 28, 2015 – PWS: PWS tag team champions Gregory Iron and Zach Gowen defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds, The Heavenly Bodies (Desirable Dustin and Gigolo Justin) & Jos A and Jos B in a 4-way tag team gauntlet match to retain the titles.
- April 3, 2015 – CAP: Dickie Rodz and Nikki Addams defeated Debbie Kane and Kyle Reynolds.
- April 25, 2015 – PWS: PWS tag team champions Gregory Iron and Zach Gowen defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds & Brother Ray and Brother Devon in a 3-way tag team match to retain the titles.
- October 24, 2015 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds defeated Anthony Bowens and Bobby Wayward.
- November 20, 2015 – PWS: Alex and Kyle Reynolds won a 10 way tag team gauntlet.
- November 21, 2015 – PWS: Sonjay Dutt defeated Kyle Reynolds.
- December 19, 2015 – PWS: Craig Steele and Sandy Mann defeated Gregory Iron and Hush, Alex and Kyle Reynolds & Beefcake Charlie and Damian Gibbs in a 4-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- December 20, 2015 – CAP: CPA and Kevin Matthews defeated John Silver and Kyle Reynolds.
- January 22, 2016 – GFW: The Heavenly Bodies (Desirable Dustin and Gigolo Justin) defeated The Reynolds Brothers (Alex Reynolds and Kyle Reynolds).
- January 30, 2016 – GFW/PWS: PWS tag team champions Craig Steele and Sandy Mann defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds, Beefcake Charlie and Damian Gibbs in a 3-way tag team match to retain the titles.
- January 31, 2016 – CAP: Alex and Kyle Reynolds were in a tag team gauntlet match won by Dorian Graves and VSK.
- March 5, 2016 – WrestlePro: The Heavenly Bodies (Desirable Dustin & Gigolo Justin) and Buster Jackson defeated The Reynolds Brothers (Alex Reynolds & Kyle Reynolds) and John Silver.
- March 13, 2016 – CAP: Brian Myers and Pat Buck defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds.
- April 17, 2016 – CAP: Mario Bokara defeated Kevin Tibbs, Kyle Reynolds and Pat Buck in a 4-way match.
- April 30, 2016 – WrestlePro: WrestlePro tag team champions Craig Steele and Sandy Mann defeated Alex and Kyle Reynolds to retain the titles.
- June 5, 2016 – CAP: Dickie Rodz defeated Kyle Reynolds.
- June 11, 2016 – GFW/WrestlePro: Beefcake Charlie defeated Adam Brooks, Caleb Konley, Delroy Alexander, Kyle Reynolds and Ronald Kingsley in a gauntlet match.
- July 17, 2016 – CAP: The Breakfast Club (CPA & Francis Kipland Stevens) and Kyle Reynolds defeated Bryce Donovan, Joe Bronson and Maxwell Jacob Feinstein.
- September 11, 2016 – CAP: Massage NV (Dorian Graves and VSK) defeated Alex’s Boys (John Silver and Kyle Reynolds).
- October 27, 2016 – CAP: Delroy, Pat Buck & The Breakfast Club (CPA and Francis Kipland Stevens) defeated Kai Katana, Kyle Reynolds & The Warren Cousins (Mikey Warren and TJ Warren).