|A.J. Styles||02/14/04||Braintree, MA||Second Anniversary Show|
|* * * NOTES: A.J. Styles defeated C.M. Punk in a tournament final.
|* * * NOTES: The title was vacated when A.J. Styles was pulled from all ROH shows by Total Nonstop Action Wrestling following the Rob Feinstein controversy.
|Doug Williams||07/17/04||Elizabeth, NJ||Reborn: Completion|
|* * * NOTES: Doug Williams defeated Alex Shelley in a tournament final. ROH only recognizes reigns from here on.
|John Walters||08/28/04||Elizabeth, NJ||Scramble Cage Melee|
|Jay Lethal||03/05/05||Philadelphia, PA||Trios Tournament 2005|
|Samoa Joe||05/07/05||New York, NY||Manhattan Mayhem|
|Nigel McGuinness||08/27/05||Buffalo, NY||Dragon Gate Invasion|
|Bryan Danielson||08/12/06||Liverpool, England||Unified|
|* * * NOTES: Bryan Danielson then unified the title with the ROH World Championship.|