topcenter





WRESTLING COLUMNS

The Truth About Ring Of Honor
July 5, 2006 by F.J. Parlan


Editor's Notes: You may have noticed that there are multiple columns up on the website about the rumored return of Degeration-X. If you read a column (ANY column) and decide to send in feedback, PLEASE be sure to indicate which column you are responding to by typing the TITLE of the column in the subject line. Also, DO NOT FORGET to sign your name. Thanks!


This column is written in response to another column made by a fellow obsesee, Terry Russell. He wrote the article "Truth about Ring of Horror", emphasizing on the negative points that ROH bears along with its visibly positive ones. By that, it is not implied that this output will focus on the other side of the argument, so, maybe this title isn't suitable for that reason. My purpose with the title is just for this to be identified as a column viv-a-vis with Mr. Russell's article. Seeing that Mr. Russell's article brought out a lot of heat from OWW's obsesees, who safe-to-say are mostly ROH fans, it is inevitable to react to that. On that note, whilst making a reaction myself, I saw that mine's was a little bit too long so I decided to make a website entry myself, my first column for OnlineWorldofWrestling.com.

He was actually the first one I found out to be an anti-ROH wrestling fan. I am not surprised by how many people reacted to his article, whether taking it seriously or not. But I was of course somehow surprised by the way these "marks" reacted. It was an unfair take by most of them, with one even questioning the qualifications of that article for this respective site (no offense, sir). I am actually writing this article to support Terry Russell's ideals about it.

I believe not a lot of people do not like ROH. Just like OWW's "puppet master" said, that to one anti-ROH article there might be five more pro-ROH ones. Any - well, except some - hardcore wrestling fan would like ROH, and would most probably prefer it over the mainstream promotions. So, that's a very gutsy move Mr. Russell made; insulting ROH. But as aforementioned, it is unbearable how some people cannot accept many things. In this case, ROH fans, who in the process of reacting had stepped over the right to freedom of speech. Well, his approach was somewhat in part sarcastic and rude, but that's a part of criticism, and in the first place I think that's just how wrestling fans approach certain information, case in point; an opinion by another wrestling fan. Can't those people just accept that this Terry Russell did make some very valid points?

The Ring of Honor promotion, just like others, has downsides too. But let me tell you right now that I am not anti-ROH nor pro, just middle ground. There are only little means that I don't like it. I am from the Philippines and I don't actually have direct means to watch ROH. But I must say, after watching just a few tapes, clips, and matches inside, I cannot believe what I saw, as its wrestling has the potential to endanger the WWE that I grew up loving. What I saw was one of, if not the best pure wrestling available in today's pro wrestling world. But after watching it further, it is noticeable that it does it lack some things.

ROH just isn't the most perfect wrestling out there, in contrast to people who think they know everything in pro wrestling say. And by the plain term "wrestling" and "pro wrestling", in connection with this one, I mean all its aspects. "Pro wrestling" and "sports-entertainment" is basically the same, now while ROH states its emphasis on the "sport", it is very lacking in the departments of entertainment, which includes; Captivating storylines, which is very essential to keep a promotion fresh, appealing, and interesting to its audience. Mic promos, which is significant because it is the most direct thing for a performer to approach a hostile crowd, which fans are hungry about. "Superstars" who entertain rather than just wrestling. These superstars include talents who have charisma and will draw fans, valuable big men who can instil a certain comical notion to the fans, gimmick-centered entertainers who delight the general public, and a variety of wrestlers in a promotion's roster.

The way I see it, most of the performers in ROH are just mere small wrestlers who have the speed, the moves, and enough guts to put their body on the line to put on a show for the crowd, One can make a case about Samoa Joe, but that's just about it because Joe is still somewhat a wrestler who tends to be fast in order to fit in an ROH environment. That removes the right of good wrestlers, who are just big, to compete in the prestigious ring of "honor". While I am not trying to remove the consideration that these guys do have great talent, I want to state the fact that:

YOU NEED ENTERTAINMENT IN PRO WRESTLING.

That is very important, and the need of that is inevitable. I'm not saying that ROH has no entertainment whatsoever, for their wrestling may be just enough entertainment. What I'm saying is that they have distinct and considerable deficiencies in that feature. That tells you why ROH can't just sell and draw THAT MUCH. I really apprehend that ROH promoters do not like to grow their company out, earn, or at least expand. If you will say that ROH doesn't need that, and is perfect the way they are, I disagree, and then I may conclude that ROH is NOT the best wrestling out there. If ROH wants to gain fame, the only thing it has to do is to appeal to the GENERAL AUDIENCE. To the kids, to the women, to the public, to the casual wrestling fans and all. I'm not saying that they should change their main attraction, which is the wrestling, and get rid of their lively, oftentimes hardcore, and explosive action. Again, I am not saying that.

If you are looking for great wrestling, ROH will not be discounted, but the opinion that I have voiced out suggests why people just flock to the WWE (and even TNA). A typical ROH lover is a hater of the WWE, because almost everything that ROH is, is not the WWE. On that note, I just want to tell you something else. WWE, you and I may criticize it just like we do, but believe it or not, as long as the general fans in countries like mine doesn't generally recognize ROH, TNA, and the like, is still and will be, be it the best or not, the top company in the world of pro wrestling.

by F.J. Parlan ....


theXenigma wrote:
I must say this article was a very good idea but some of your points are a bit sketchy. You mentioned alot about sports entertainment. You must keep in mind that ROH was started over the principle of "wrestling" and not "gimmicks". In some the the earlier shows we saw Little Guido argue with Tony Mamaluke about wether or not they should have a gimmick in a promotion like ROH. In the modern day, ROH has developed quite a number of characters with gimmicks. Also they have begun to implementing storylines(which is part of the reason why I haven't bought many DVDs, now im into NOAH). The ROH vs CZW angle is currently going on. It is two promotions feuding over what wrestling should be like. We have Chris Hero whining about never being "good enough for ROH". Besides that we have Jimmy Jacobs and his emo gimmick and his love for Lacy. The Embassy have a gimmick in which they are a bunch of rich snobs trying to buy the ROH title. Theres quite a large amount of wrestlers wit h gimmicks in ROH now. To name a few more: Delirious, Cluadio Castagnoli, Chris Daniels(remeber the Prophecy?), Colt Cabana and Homicide(very emotional storyline).

Now you can not say that ROH's only big guy is Samoa Joe. ROH has Bj Whitmer, Adam Pearce, Claudio Castanoli isnt too small, Abyss was in ROH for a while so was Da Hit Squad and the Carnagge Crew.

ROH is about "pro wrestling" and the way it is meant to be. Wrestlers can have gimmicks or a specific look and showcase pure wrestling or hardcore wrestling ability. Wrestlers can show off athletcsim and toughness. In ROH wrestlers have a chance to put on impressive matches.
Count Grog (click here) wrote:
Ring of Honor is great for those smarks who have no life and all the care about is work rate and move sequences. I have many tapes and at times a few wrestlers entertained me (Prince Nana, The Christopher Street Connection, Colt Cabana) but for the most part it is boring. I watch wrestling to be entertained not bored. I don't care if its beleiveable or athletic, I like entertainment, storylines and action (not spot Fests) I am not a WWE fan as their crap has no storyline that makes sense. I don't care how many guys suplex eachother off the top rope, I don't want wrestlers to shake hands, I want funny promos, sneak attacks and interference. None of what I get in ROH, Loc & Devito are OK but they have no one to work with. I agree with the writers and their stance on ROH, its just not MY cup of tea.
Stephen Mitchell wrote:
I find ring of honour incredibly dull. It seems to me that ROH is only the smarks choice because out of the big 3 it is the least promoted and publicised. It makes them feel like they are in the know which is very important to a smark.

Smarks go on about how the ROH title is the most prestigious in America but is it really? How can it be? If you look at boxing at the moment Floyd Mayweather is the WBC world Champion at Welterweight. He is the best in the division and P4P the best in the world but he is not the real Welterweight champion. That honour goes to Baldomir who sparked out Zab Judah earlier this year. Does anyone think that Baldomir would beat Mayweather even though he is the liner world champ? Of course not. Everyone knows Baldomir is a champion because he hasn’t came across Hatton, Mayweather, Cotto or Collazo yet. Look at Jamie Noble, a great ROH champ WWE jobber, why? Smarks will say it is because the WWE holds him down. I say that it’s because he is no longer a big fish in a small pond. He is now a small fish in a big ocean. ROH builds itself up to be something it’s not and plays on the stupidity of ‘smarks’ by feeding them BS and turning them into marks. It is actually very cleaver when you think about it. Your common garden smark is an idiot, ROH knows this and they play on it. They tell smarks that ROH is about everything they love and against everything they hate yet on any ROH card I have seen (and I have seen lots because in the UK you get about 8 hours ROH a week on the wrestling channel) for every good match you get about 5 stinkers worse than almost everything on TNA & WWE programming. It is a limited company with limited resources, talent and shelf life. The reason it will never take of is because its rubbish.

Please everyone feel free to tell me I am an idiot and know nothing about wrestling that does not bother me at all for two reasons.

1. I know what I like
&
2. There is no point in arguing with an idiot. They will only drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
Kevin Hill wrote:
i agree with this guy. Ive been a wrestling fan my entire life, which is 18 years now. ive seen the territorial days, to the nwo/attitude days, to the sports entertainment days

although i dont always agree with what wwe puts out there, they are the best product out there regardless of how bad Cena wrestles or how lame some gimmicks are.

Those "great stars" you speak of including like Jake Evans and the Jimmy Rave, and countless other wrest.... no i cant call them wrestlers. Wheres the wrestling? Ive noticed most ROH fans at least semi enjoy CZW, which is bashing heads and bleeding... and ROH is abunch of spotfest matches and they pray that works because thats all they can do. So I call the guys in CZW "fatasses who dont care if their hurt" and ROH people "gymnists." Yes they are athletic (well ROH people anyways not CZW) and yes they have the heart but I cannot call that wrestling. Dean Malenko true wrestler. Yes HHH is a superb PRO WRESTLER. Thats where people lose focus. This is pro wrestling, which means know how to sell the moves, execute them good, and most importantly tell a story with the match. CZW matches dont tell stories, and neither do ROH matches.

To the guy that responded about WWE TLC matches.... those are very very different. Even with all the weaponary and stunts, they manage to do wrestling moves, and by wrestling moves I dont mean a backdrop through glass with burning barbed wire under it, or leaping through the air spinning 7 times just to barely land on your opponent (although athletic, its not wrestling). Consequently this is why I hate TNA. Even ECW with its violence could tell a good story for the majority of the time.

If ROH was better than WWE, then why hasn't it got the billions and billions of dollars? why dosent it have the millions of viewers, or have advertisment?

Theres a reason WWE is at the top of the pro wrestling industry, because thats exactly what it is.... pro wrestling. Not bashing heads or doing flips. Pro wrestling
Jon Rosaler wrote:
I do not mean to offend him, but Bryan Danielson to me looks like Mark Hamil. "May the belt be with him" lol. Anyway, ROH is true wrestling.
Philip Frazer wrote:
I completely disagree with your entire article. Ring of Honor is not about sports-entertainment, it is not about the 'entertaining' storylines and promos that make WWE a soap opera, sorry, professional wrestling. Ring of Honor is all about the sport of wrestling, and is the SPORT not the entertainment.

Now I for one love a lot of wrestling, I love TNA, ROH, 1PW, CZW and I like certain things in WWE. But the problem with WWE is that their gimmicks/characters and storylines are so over the top that a lot of wrestling fans will dislike it. WWE does not go off wrestling talent as most wrestling fans would like wrestling promotions to go off, it instead puts talentless idiots that supposedly have charisma and entertain the crowd (although I think people like Hogan and Cena are completely talentless and unentertaining) because they bring in merchandise money. For years fans have been asking for wrestlers such as Christian, Eddie, Benoit and Angle to get more air time and a proper push, but as per usual they decide to use people like Cena, The Boogeyman and Hulk Hogan on air time instead. ROH is a company that is for the fans, not the money, or the fame, or the entertainment through soap opera.

ROH is there to give WRESTLING fans what they want to see, pure wrestling, ROH gives us some of the greatest wrestling there is today with stars such as Samoa Joe, AJ Styles, Bryan Danielson, Christopher Daniels, Homicide, Low-Ki, Jimmy Jacobs, Delirious, CM Punk, Colt Cabana, Alex Shelley, Spanky and many others. They also give us segments with some entertainment that isn't along the lines of John Cena's continual yelling about nothing other than making himself look an idiot on global television, instead they have genuinly entertaining segments from people such as Colt Cabana, Spanky, CM Punk, The Embassy, Delirious, Jimmy Jacobs and Ebassan.

Now WWE may have some good talent, but the few ones they have they waste and then release. They misuse the tag, cruiserweight and womens divisions and the heavyweight divisions are full of overrated, giant, talentless idiots such as John Cena, Great Khali, Mark Henry etc. While there are plenty of good wrestlers, most of them charismatic as well, that are underused and ignored. Tag teams such as MNM, Worlds Greatest Tag Team, Basham Brothers, La Resistance, Cade and Murdoch and even back to the days of Demolition, tag teams have always been misused and wasted leading to their eventual splitting and/or firing. The womens division is a lot better than people give it credit, if it got used properly. Trish, Lita, Mickie and Victoria are all very good womens wrestlers, and Torrie can learn if she is sent to OVW as she is showing slightly more progression every week, some good women wrestlers have also been released over the last two years such as Gail Kim, Molly Holly, Jazz, Jackie Gayda all to make room for the talentless diva search contestants. And the cruiserweight division is possibly the best division in WWE, but is so underused, and has only just made it back onto the lackluster Smackdown from Velocity. It is full of fantastic wrestlers such as Jamie Noble, Paul London, Brian 'Spanky' Kendrick, Kid Kash, Super Crazy, Psicosis, Little Guido, and former ones such as Tajiri, Akio, Shannon Moore, Billy Kidman and others. The Cruiserweights are a very valuable part of the WWE, and wrestling itself, and are the only real reason to watch Smackdown nowadays other than some other very good and underused wrestlers such as Mr Kennedy, Chris Benoit, Finlay, William Regal, Paul Burchill and others, and when the Cruiserweights are used they steal the show.

Which is why we love alternate indy promotions such as TNA, ROH and other smaller ones, because they use the talented and don't have the untalented. They use their tag teams, and keep them together, they use their stars and talents and don't just have them job to big body builders who couldn't wrestle a match to earn the brain they are missing. So before you slate ROH learn what the purpose of ROH is, it's sole purpose is to supply us WRESTLING fans with the WRESTLING we want to see, not the 'entertainment' rubbish we are fed from WWE.
john byrnes wrote:
I must say you do bring up a few good points, but I will say ROH is the best promotion out of the Three for these reasons.

1. Without it TNA more then likly would be Dead, if it wasnt for ROH. Look at all the stars TNA has that got there break in ROH and other indy promotions. Chris Daniels, A.J. Styles, Abyss, Alex Shelley, Roderick Strong, Austin Aries ( TNA made a big mistake in letting them go) Homicide, Somoa Joe, Jay Lethal, to name a few.

2. Just about every on in the X divison came from ROH

3. They have produced a ton of prospects( CM Punk, Joe, Styles,Aries) who will be the future of Wrestling

4. They are not afraid to bring in big names. ( Kobashi, Foley, Steamboat,Raven, Eddie Guererro)

5. Combines many types of wrestling in matches( Lucha libre, European, Japanese,ect)

6. The sign of a good promotion is pleasing it's fans, and ROH does a stellar job of doing this.

7. The live atmosphere is much better then on the DVDs.The Crowd is ALWAYS into the action.

8. Every wrestler gives it 100% every night, something that most WWE stars don't do.

9. Shows live normally last 4-5 hours!
FJ Parlan (Original Author) wrote:
THIS IS A RESPONSE FROM KYLE DAVIS, PERTAINING TO MY ARTICLE "THE TRUTH ABOUT RING OF HONOR (He sent this to me via email, so I'll just post them here) :

I would like to respond to some of the comments made within this atricle and debate some of the remarks that have been written.

To begin, yes I am a diehard ROH fan but I don't solely enjoy Ring of Honor.

With that said, I just want to make some informative points and elaborate on some of the arguments that have been put forward.

Firstly, to rebut Mr.Stephen Mitchell's comments:

Buddy, smarks don't enjoy ROH because "out of the big 3 it is the least promoted and publicised". FANS enjoy Ring Of Honor because it offers something that the two other promotions do not: Hot in ring action that is void of ridiculous cartoon-esque storylines and is the epitome of the SPORT of professional wrestling.

"It is a limited company with limited resources, talent and shelf life. The reason it will never take of is because its rubbish." IT'S AN INDY PROMOTION. Indies don't have multi million dollar budgets like the MacMahons. Call it rubbish, but it is certainly based on actual wrestling and mat skills moreso than the 'E...There are no diva Bikini Bull Riding Contests, no 300 pound muscle heads jacked up steroids using a closeline or sideslam as their finisher, no supernatural dieties as tag team parters, and ROH wrestlers aren't held back by management out of fear. It's a ground where talented athletic individuals can showcase their skills and put on good matches the way PRO WRESTLING was meant to be.

You claim you have 8 hours of ROH wrestling at your weekly disposal and you go on to say that 'for every good match you have 5 bad ones.' Sure, you know what you like but not every match ROH puts on is going to be an instant 5 star classic, and can you honestly say without a shadow of a doubt that Ring of Honor matches are worse than WWE and TNA matches? If you do say that, I would like to know how you came to that conclusion. Sure, I recognize that tastes ARE SUBJECTIVE and it's fine if you like WWE or TNA or whatever the hell promotion you enjoy, but to call ROH 'incredibly dull' compared to other promotions just doesn't make sense to me at all. Moreover, Calling us 'smarks and idiots' is just stupid and proves how weak your argument is and how you need to rely on adhominem to boost it.

To Kevin Hill,

You say you've been a wrestling fan 'all your life' yet you refure to refer to guys like Jimmy Rave as wrestlers? What's wrong with you man? If you were even remotely familiar with the subject you were criticizing, you would know Jimmy Rave does very little high flying moves and is nothing close to a 'gymnist' as you like to say and Jack Evans, albeit a decent high flyer, is no superstar. You say 'Wheres the wrestling'? What a ridiculous comment that I can only shake my head at. It ultimately proves you haven't watched more than at smidget of ROH, because if you had, you would realize that it's about more than 'high spots' and gymnastics. Yes, you do have occasional spotty matches but you also have excellent technical wrestling based on submissions (i.e. Castagnoli versus Chris Daniels from the 'This Means War'show) that you would never ever see in the mainstream promotions such as MacMahon's bastardized ECW or WWE.

Another ludicrous remark is "their matches don't tell stories." You obviously haven't seen any of the Bryan Danielson vs Roderick Strong matches, any of the CM Punk versus Samoa Joe series, any of the Embassy versus Generation Next feud, Jame's Gibson's farewell match, or any of ROH's main event battles that tell great captivating stories and have gotten rave reviews from critics the world over. I would like to know under what grounds do you feel ROH don't tell stories. I suggest you at least sit down and watch an entire ROH show before erroneously judging a promotion you clearly have no experience with.

You also go on to say 'Dean Malenko is a true wrestler.' Is Ricky Steamboat a true wrestler? Is Kenta Kobashi a true wrestler? Is Lance Storm a true wrestler? (I hope you answered yes to all of these, otherwise you're futher gone that I originally thought) because they have all been involved with ROH in some capacity or another.

Moving right along, allow me to reflect on this naive question: "If ROH was better than WWE, then why hasn't it got the billions and billions of dollars? why dosent it have the millions of viewers, or have advertisment?"

a) ROH doesn't have a TV contract. It has no national televsion exposure. They rely on ticket sales, attendace - which are arguably the highest among North American indy promotions - and DVD sales.

b) ROH management has not inherited millions of dollars worth of money from their parents.

I honestly believe the only reason you all critize ROH is because you feel threatened by its success and you don't understand what real, honest and true wrestling is all about. Call it being 'brainwashed' or call it sheer ignorance, but there is superior wrestling to what is being offered by the mainstream promotions in North America, whether it be ROH, PWG, Dragon Gate, NOAH or the other Japanese promotions. I suggest you look into those promotions as well. Maybe purchase a ROH DVD before generating opinions.

I'll admit, Ring of Honor isn't for everyone and we are all entitled to our opinions and personal tastes, but some of the points made in this column hold absolutely no weight and are just plain incorrect.

Just thought I would share my two cents.
FJ Parlan (Original Author) wrote:
I'll settle this. First off, I am not anti-ROH. Second off, the purpose I wrote the article is just to expose some of the things that ROH lack thereof. I just made it an issue of ridicule, which is actually good to let ROH and the marks' approach to it improve.

For those who reacted, particularly to Kyle Davis, dude, you cant say one's points of opinion is INCORRECT, because last time I checked it's still just my opinion. Thanks to those who reacted, I also smile to the fact that an actual pro wrestling manager also responded to it (thank you, Count Groc). Your reactions of course enlighten on my ideas with regards to this one. That's appreciated.

ROH is great wrestling. That's pretty much about it but the reason why I wrote my column is just to try to show why ROH does not sell THAT MUCH. That's all. I did not show the negativity part of ROH just to put it under sarcastic realms. You don't have to bash the WWE really.

But for that matter, I have one question for y'all: Why is the WWE still at the top of this industry? I know, I know you will say that it inherited million dollars from it's forefathers, or, or... I really don't know what else. All I know is that it's at the top because it serves the general public. It can actually entertain EVERY kind of fan one way or the other. Believe it or not. You know what, I do believe that perhaps ninety plus percent(just to be safe) of pro wrestlers in the world, if asked to go the WWE, and be changed greatly(cut the wrestling fancy, forget the style, reduce risks in performing, add more talk, reduce wrestling, and have a gimmick which doesn't have to be good), would JUST ACCEPT with the smallest amount of reluctancy rather than go to TNA or ROH, etc if offered. It's not really about the money, for I think the WWE is still that much respected.
Jesse H wrote:
Hey, Great article just a couple of things. The reason ROH is so over with smarks is because of the format. WWE provides “sports entertainment” with outrageous promos and funny gimmicks. ROH is an alternative. Sure there are great gimmicks (prince nana and the embassy arguably the best faction in a long time) my point is like the ECW of yesteryear ROH is an alternative to the usual programming on Monday and Friday. Besides a little competition never hurt anybody look what happened when WWE last had competition. We got Attitude.
wrote:

wrote:

wrote:

wrote:

If you have any comments, reactions, rebuttles or thoughts on this column, feel free to send them to the email below,
PLEASE INCLUDE THE NAME OF THE COLUMN YOU'RE REPLYING TO AND SIGN YOUR NAME..
We at OnlineWorldofWrestling want to promote all points of view, and that includes YOURS.




© 2015, Black Pants, Inc. All other trademarks are property of their respective holders.

[ CHAT ROOM | FLASH | SEARCH | FORUMS | DOWNLOADS | TAPES | WRESTLINKS | GUESTBOOK | THANK YOU | CONTACT ]