Rico Cosantino’s first OVW opponent was Rasputin, and it was a slaughter – his first tag team partner was “Trailer Park Trash”..
October 12, 1999 – OVW: Rob Conway w/Kenny Bolin defeated Rico Constantino in a 2/3 falls match to retain the OVW title..
October 13, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino & Trailer Park Trash defeated The Andretti Express w/Treasure.
October 19, 1999–OVW: Rob Conway w/Kenny Bolin defeated Rico Costantino in a Best 2/3 Falls match to retain the OVW Title.
October 20, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Mr. Black w/Kenny Bolin.
October 27, 1999–OVW: Rob Conway & Bull Buchanan w/Kenny Bolin defeated Rico Costantino & Trailer Park Trash.
November 3, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Rob Conway w/Kenny Bolin.
November 7, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Mr. Black.
November 10, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Rob Conway to win the OVW Heavyweight Title.
November 14, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Rip Rogers to retain the OVW Heavyweight title.
November 16, 1999–OVW: Rico Costantino defeated Flash Flanagan by DQ to retain the OVW Heavyweight title.
November 17, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated B.J. Payne.
November 25, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino & Damaja defeated Bull Buchanan & Mr. Black w/Kenny Bolin by DQ.
November 26, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Nick Dinsmore w/Kenny Bolin defeated Rico Costantino (OVW Champion) by DQ.
November 28, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated Mr. Black to retain the OVW Heavyweight title.
November 30, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated Bull Buchanan w/Kenny Bolin to retain the OVW Title.
December 1, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Bull Buchanan & Mr. Black w/Kenny Bolin defeated Rico Costantino & Damaja by DQ.
December 5, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated Nick Dinsmore by DQ to retain the OVW Heavyweight title.
December 7, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino & The Damaja defeated Bull Buchanan & Mr. Black.
December 8, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated Nick Dinsmore w/Kenny Bolin to retain the OVW Title.
December 9, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino & Damaja beat Rip Rogers & Jason Lee (champions) by DQ.
December 15, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Costantino defeated Chris Alexander.
December 26, 1999–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Flash Flanagan defeated Rico Costantino to win the OVW Heavyweight Title.
January 31, 2001 – OVW-WWF: Flash Flannigan & Trailor Park Trash defeated Rico Constantino & Mr. Black..
April 4, 2001–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Flash defeated Nick Dinsmore & Rico Costantino w/Kenny Bolin in a Handicap match.
April 22, 2001–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Constantino defeated Randy Orton.
June 27, 2001 – OVW-WWF: Randy Orton defeated Rico Constantino..
June 28, 2001–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Randy Orton defeated Rico Constantino with help from Cowboy Bob Orton.
Rico Cosantino held three Heavyweight championships simultaneously: EWF, OVW, and PPW..
Ohio Valley Wrestling – Rico Cosantino & The Prototype:
2001: Rico Cosantino teamed with Prototype as one of the all time greatest heat generators in Ohio Valley Wrestling history..
July 28, 2001 – OVW-WWF: Rico Constantino & The Prototype defeated Randy Orton & Bobby Eaton..
August 15, 2001–OVW: Rico Costantino & The Prototype & Jerome Crony defeated B.J. Payne & Damien & Connie Swail.
August 22, 2001–Ohio Valley Wrestling: The Damaja & Rob Conway defeated Rico Costantino & The Prototype..
~~~~Rico Constantino & The Prototype (John Cena) were awared the vacant OVW Southern Tag Team Titles.
September 16, 2001–OVW: Rico Constantino & Prototype beat Sean Casey & Chris Michaels to retain the Tag Team titles.
October 3, 2001–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Rico Constantino defeated Brock Lesnar.
October 27, 2001–OVW: Mark Henry & Randy Orton defeated Rico Constantino & Prototype in a Non-title match..
~~~~Rico & Prototype initially won but Nidia informed the referee of their cheating and the match was restarted..
2001: Rico Cosantino was nominated for PWI (Pro Wrestling Illustrated) Rookie of the Year..
Heartland Wrestling Association:
2001-2002: Rico Cosantino wrestled dark matches on RAW & SmackDown!, plus performed at Non-Televised Live Events..
November 3, 2001 – Jakked: Brock Lesnar and Shelton Benjamin defeated Rico Constantino and Prototype to win the OVW southern tag team titles in a dark match.
November 10, 2001 – Jakked: Randy Orton and Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino and Shawn Stasiak in a dark match.
November 11, 2001 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
November 17, 2001 – Jakked: Brock Lesnar defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
November 18, 2001 – HEAT: Randy Orton and Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino and Stevie Richards in a dark match.
December 1, 2001 – Jakked: Billy and Chuck defeated Rico Constantino and Randy Orton in a dark match.
December 2, 2001 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
December 8, 2001 – Jakked: Brock Lesnar defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
December 9, 2001 – HEAT: Brock Lesnar defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
December 15, 2001 – Jakked: Tajiri defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
December 16, 2001 – HEAT: Spike Dudley defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 6, 2002 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 12, 2002 – Jakked: Brock Lesnar defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 13, 2002 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 19, 2002 – Jakked: Charlie Haas defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 20, 2002 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 26, 2002 – Jakked: Brock Lesnar defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
January 27, 2002 – HEAT: Rico Constantino defeated AJ Styles in a dark match.
January 27, 2002 – Live Event: Perry Saturn defeated Rico Constantino.
February 2, 2002 – HEAT: Rico Constantino defeated Orlando Jordan in a dark match.
February 3, 2002 – HEAT: Rico Constantino and Randy Orton defeated Brock Lesnar and Ron Waterman in a dark match.
February 9, 2002 – Jakked: Rico Constantino and Randy Orton defeated Brock Lesnar and Ron Waterman in a dark match.
February 10, 2002 – HEAT: Ron Waterman defeated Rico Constantino in a dark match.
March 2002: Rico Cosantino was sent to Les Thatcher’s HWA (Heartland Wrestling Association) to sharpen his skills..
~~~While competing in HWA, Rico formed a tag team with Tough Enough winner Maven Huffman..
March 5, 2002–Heartland Wrestling Association: Rico Costantino defeated Steve Bradley.
World Wrestling Entertainment – Smackdown! (Rico with Billy & Chuck):
March 21, 2002 – Smackdown!: Rico finally debuted on WWF Television as the “Stylist” to Tag Team Champions, Billy & Chuck..
March 28, 2002–SmackDown!: Billy & Chuck w/Rico defeated Dudley Boyz to retain the WWE Tag Team titles with help from Rico.
April 4, 2002–SmackDown!: Billy & Chuck w/Rico beat Scotty 2 Hotty & Albert to retain the Tag Team titles with help from Rico.
April 11, 2002–SmackDown!: Maven & Al Snow defeated WWE Tag Team Champions Billy & Chuck w/Rico in a non title match.
April 18, 2002–SmackDown!: Rikishi & Maven & Al Snow defeated Albert & Billy & Chuck w/Rico.
April 25, 2002–SmackDown!: Billy Kidman & Maven & Al Snow defeated Billy & Chuck (w/Rico) & Tajiri (w/Torrie Wilson)..
~~~~Rico stopped Torrie from interfering – Billy & Chuck left Tajiri to fight on his own after being stripped down to their thongs.
May 9, 2002 – SmackDown!: Rico made his first in-ring TV appearance.. Billy & Chuck & Rico beat Al Snow & Mavan & Rikishi!
October 16, 2004 – Velocity: Buh Buh Ray Dudley defeated Rico Cosantino..
October 21, 2004–SmackDown!: WWE United States Champion Carlito Cool defeated Rico in a Non title match..
~~~Before the match; Carlito spit a apple in Torrie Wilson’s face in which she was guest ring announcer..
October 24, 2004 – Live Event: Heidenreich defeated Rico.
October 31, 2004 – Live Event: Rico defeated Rene Dupree.
November 1, 2004 – Live Event: WWE tag team champions Rene Dupree and Kenzo Suzuki defeated Rico and Charlie Haas & The Basham Brothers in a 3-way tag team match to retain the titles.
November 4, 2004 – Velocity: Billy Kidman defeated Rico (Kidman went for SSP after, but Chavo made the save)..
November 4, 2004: Rico is officially released from his World Wrestling Entertainment contract, which comes as a huge surprise..
Life After WWE:
February 2, 2005: Bull Buchanan & Rico defeated Mitsuya Nagai & Masayuki Naruse to win the All-Asian Tag Team titles..
July 2005: Rico Cosantino announced that he was retiring from professional Wrestling..
~~~~Rico added that he going back to working as a law enforcement officer in Las Vegas..
~~~~(this meant that the All-Asian Tag Team Titles had to be vacated).
February 5, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan and Rico defeated Masayuki Naruse and Mitsuya Nagai to win the All-Asian tag team titles.
February 6, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan and Rico defeated Masanobu Fuchi and Nobukazu Hirai.
February 8, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan, Jamal and Rico defeated Keiji Muto, Kohei Suwama and Tomoaki Honma.
February 9, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan, Jamal, Rico, Taiyo Kea and TAKA Michinoku defeated Keiji Muto, Kohei Suwama, Masanobu Fuchi, Nobutaka Araya and Toshiaki Kawada.
February 10, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan, Rico and TAKA Michinoku defeated Masanobu Fuchi, Nobutaka Araya and Toshiaki Kawada.
February 11, 2005 – AJPW: Buchanan, Rico and TAKA Michinoku defeated Kaz Hayashi, Keiji Muto and Kohei Suwama.
February 13, 2005 – AJPW: Kaz Hayashi, Keiji Muto and Kensuke Sasaki defeated Buchanan, Rico and TAKA Michinoku.
February 16, 2005 – AJPW: Chuck Palumbo, Johnny Stamboli and TARU defeated Buchanan, Rico and TAKA Michinoku.