February 2, 2016–Girl Fight VIII: Ashley America defeated Dominique Fabiano.
January 30, 2016–Clash: Leah Vaughan defeated Ashley America, Ray Lyn and Jewells Malone in a 4-way match.
February 13, 2016–VOW: Ashley America defeated Randi West.
December 2, 2017–CLASH: Ashley America defeated Maria James.
December 30, 2017–ACW/Rogue: Trixie Tash defeated Ashley America.
March 9, 2018–Showtime Championship Wrestling Alliance: Kaci Dillon defeated Ashley America.
March 15, 2018–ACW: Kacee Carlisle defeated Ashley America to retain the ACW women’s title.
April 13, 2019–VPW: Ariela Nyx defeated Ashley America to retain the women’s title.
May 26, 2019–PTPW: Lady Frost defeated Ashley America in the 1st round.
July 12, 2019–SCWA: Sicend defeated Ashley America.
August 24, 2019–ACW: Missy Sampson defeated Ashley America.
September 28, 2019–PTPW: Savanna Stone defeated Ashley America, Davienne and Lady Frost in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the PWM women’s title.
October 18, 2019–WSU: Vita VonStarr defeated Ashley America.
October 25, 2019–ACW: Kaci Dillon defeated Ashley America.
August 28, 2021–NCW: Ashley America and Michael Walker defeated The Von Engelands (Eden Von Engeland and Sidney Von Engeland).
October 9, 2021–VPW: Karen BamBam defeated All Natural Ashley, Marie Valdomina and Megan Mason in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the women’s title.
April 2, 2022–MEW/GIW: Nakoma Tala defeated All Natural Ashley and Jessie Nolan in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the MEW women’s title.
May 28, 2022–SWA: Dani Deville defeated All Natural Ashley.
July 9, 2022–Route 33: Olivia Devine defeated All Natural Ashley.
August 20, 2022–SWA: All Natural Ashley defeated Dani Deville.
September 3, 2022–Route 33: All Natural Ashley defeated Olivia Devine.
September 24, 2022–EWA: All Natural Ashley defeated Lady Eva.
December 10, 2022–SWA: Dani Deville and Kamen MK defeated All Natural Ashley and Christopher Andino.
March 25, 2023–SWA: All Natural Ashley defeated Taylor Brooks.