January 12, 2008–NWA Upstate: Jimmy Olsen beat John McChesney and Danny Doring in a 3-WAY to retain the NWA Upstate Title..
January 19, 2008–PWU: Adam Flash defeated “Fabulous” John McChesney by Countout to retain the PWU World Title..
January 19, 2008–ICW: Larry Sweeney defeated John McChesney in a wild & bloody Texas Death Match to win the Super Indy title..
January 27, 2008–Firestorm Pro: Raymond Rowe vs. John McChesney ended in a double disqualification..
April 5, 2008–Firestorm Pro Wrestling: Fabulous John McChesney defeated Starless..
April 5, 2008–New Era Pro Wrestling: Fabulous John McChesney defeated Jimmy Demarco..
March 19, 2010–Firestorm Pro Wrestling: John McChesney defeated Ray Rowe in a Loser Leaves Town match..
June 26, 2010–NWA New York: John McChesney defeated Pepper Parks in a #1 Contender’s Match..
March 8, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Kevin Bennett to retain the heavyweight title.
March 15, 2014–BCW: John McChesney defeated War Child by disqualification.
April 5, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Andre Kanan Alexander to retain the heavyweight title.
April 12, 2014–IWC: Jimmy Nutts & The Steiner Brothers (Rick Steiner & Scott Steiner) defeated Team Big League (John McChesney, Joseph Brooks & Rex Lawless).
April 18, 2014–BCW: John McChesney defeated Rhino.
April 19, 2014–BCW: John McChesney defeated Krimson in a no disqualification match to win the heavyweight title.
May 4, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Rhino to retain the heavyweight title.
May 17, 2014–IWC: John McChesney defeated Justin Idol.
June 7, 2014–BCW: John McChesney defeated Tyson Dux by disqualification to retain the heavyweight title.
June 7, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Pepper Parks by disqualification to retain the heavyweight title.
June 12, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Tyler Nitro to retain the heavyweight title.
June 13, 2014–PWR: Rhino defeated John McChesney by disqualification. McChesney retains the heavyweight title.
June 14, 2014–IWC: Jimmy Nutts vs. John McChesney ended in a no contest.
June 21, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Tyler Nitro to retain the heavyweight title.
July 11, 2014–Champions of the Galaxy: Brutus Beefcake & John McChesney defeated Bennett Cole & Rocky Reynolds by disqualification.
July 26, 2014–BCW: John McChesney defeated Brian Jennings to retain the heavyweight title.
August 9, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Pepper Parks to retain the heavyweight title.
August 23, 2014–IWC: Team Big League (John McChesney, Joseph Brooks & Matthew Justice) defeated Team DeMarco (Aiden Veil, Jimmy DeMarco & Marshall Gambino).
August 29, 2014–BDW: John McChesney defeated Michael Facade.
September 13, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Aaron Draven and Matt Cross in a 3-way match to retain the heavyweight title.
September 20, 2014–IWC: John McChesney defeated Asylum.
October 11, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Pepper Parks in a street fight to retain the heavyweight title.
October 17, 2014–BDW: Michael Facade defeats John McChesney in a street fight.
October 18, 2014–IWC: John McChesney defeated Chuck Roberts.
November 8, 2014–IWC: Asylum defeated John McChesney.
November 15, 2014–PWR: Aaron Draven & John McChesney defeated Colin Delaney & J-Rocc.
December 13, 2014–IWC: Matt Hardy defeated John McChesney.
December 14, 2014–PWR: John McChesney defeated Matt Hardy to retain the heavyweight title.
January 3, 2015–PWR: Aaron Draven, John McChesney & Rhino defeated Asylum, J-Rocc & Pepper Parks.
January 24, 2015–IWC: John McChesney defeated Jimmy Nutts.
February 7, 2015–PWR: John McChesney defeated Asylum to retain the heavyweight title.
March 7, 2015–IWC: John McChesney defeated Joseph Brooks in a steel cage match.
March 14, 2015–PWR: John McChesney defeated J-Rocc to retain the heavyweight title.
April 11, 2015–IWC: Asylum, John McChesney & Kevin Nash defeated Gangrel, Krimson & War Child.
April 18, 2015–PWR: John McChesney vs. Ethan Carter III ended in a no contest. McChesney retains the heavyweight title.
May 9, 2015–PWR: John McChesney defeated J-Rocc to retain the heavyweight title.
May 30, 2015–PWR: Erie Elite (Aaron Draven & John McChesney) defeated JJ Rumham & Joe Rosa. John McChesney defeated JJ Rumham to retain the heavyweight title. John McChesney defeated Joe Rosa to retain the heavyweight title. John McChesney defeated Stain to retain the heavyweight title.
June 6, 2015–PWR: John McChesney & Waylon Reavis defeated J-Rocc & Phil Kinney.
June 20, 2015–PWR: Erie Elite (Aaron Draven & John McChesney) defeated Andrew Palace & Darin Dinero. John McChesney defeated Andrew Palace to retain the heavyweight title. John McChesney defeated Darin Dinero to retain the heavyweight title.
July 10, 2015–GFW: Eric Young defeated John McChesney.
July 11, 2015–PWR: Aaron Draven vs. John McChesney ended in a no contest. McChesney retains the heavyweight title.
July 26, 2015–PWR: Dead Wrestling Society (Krimson & War Child) vs. Erie Elite (Aaron Draven & John McChesney) ended in a no contest.
August 8, 2015–PWR: John McChesney defeated War Child by disqualification to retain the heavyweight title.
September 12, 2015–PWR: Krimson & War Child defeated Aaron Draven & John McChesney.
September 26, 2015–IWC: Jimmy Nutts & John McChesney defeated Team LaBar (Bill Collier & Wardlow).
October 10, 2015–PWR: Erie Elite (Aaron Draven & John McChesney) defeated The Dead Wrestling Society (Krimson & Stain) in a steel cage, monster’s balls casket match.
October 17, 2015–IWC: John McChesney defeated Jimmy Nutts and Rhyno in a 3-way match to win the world heavyweight title.
November 14, 2015–PWR: Aaron Draven defeated John McChesney to win the heavyweight title.
December 12, 2015–IWC: Jimmy Nutts defeated John McChesney in a ladder match to win the world heavyweight title.
January 2, 2016–PWR: Aaron Draven defeated Bill Collier, John McChesney and Yusuke Kodama in a 4-way match to retain the heavyweight title.
February 6, 2016–PWR: The Cleveland Mafia (J-Rocc & Phil Kinney) defeated John McChesney & Yusuke Kodama by disqualification to retain the tag titles.
March 12, 2016–PWR: The Cleveland Mafia (J-Rocc & Phil Kinney) defeated Andre Kanan Alexander & John McChesney to retain the tag titles.
March 26, 2016–ESW: John McChesney defeated Jay Freddie.
April 9, 2016–IWC: John McChesney defeated Jeff Jarrett.
April 16, 2016–PWR: John McChesney defeated Matt Cross.
May 7, 2016–IWC: The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) defeated Britt Baker & John McChesney to retain the tag titles.
May 14, 2016–PWR: John McChesney defeated Kevin Bennett to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title.
May 21, 2016–ESW: John McChesney defeated Asylum by disqualification.
June 11, 2016–IWC: Asylum & John McChesney defeated The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) by count-out. Decker & Gibson retains the tag titles.
June 18, 2016–ESW: Asylum defeated John McChesney by disqualification.
July 9, 2016–PWR: Bill Collier vs. John McChesney ended in a no contest.
January 21, 2017–IWC: The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) vs. Daniel Hooven & John McChesney ended in a no contest to retain the tag titles.