- January 3, 2011 – ROH TV (Taped): Michael Elgin defeated Alex Silva in a dark match.
- January 15, 2011 – C4: C4 champion Stupefied defeated Michael Elgin and Sonjay Dutt in a 3-way elimination match to retain the title.
- January 16, 2011 – SCW: Boris Brezhnev defeated Michael Elgin to become #1 contender for the MPW triple crown title.
- January 29, 2011 – PWE: Michael Elgin defeated Kenneth Crises in the semi-finals. Michael Elgin defeated Derek Wylde, Josh Alexander and Mike Rollins in a 4-way match to win the tournament.
- January 31, 2011 – ROH TV (Taped): Michael Elgin and Roderick Strong defeated Alex Silvas and Chrisjen Hayme.
- February 6, 2011 – CCW: CCW heavyweight champion Cody Deaner defeated Michael Elgin to retain the title.
- February 19, 2011 – NSPW: Andrew Davis defeated Michael Elgin.
- February 20, 2011 – A1: Michael Elgin defeated Colin Delaney. Rhino defeated Michael Elgin.
-
February 25, 2011 – ROH World’s Greatest: Christopher Daniels defeated Michael Elgin.
- February 25, 2011 – ROH 9th Anniversary Show: El Generico defeated Michael Elgin.
- February 27, 2011 – Fight!: Michael Elgin defeated Josh Alexander.
- February 28, 2011 – ROH TV (Taped): Michael Elgin defeated Bobby Dempsey in the 1st round of the top prospect tournament.
- March 5, 2011 – PWE: PWE Open weight champion Michael Elgin defeated Anthony Fiasco to retain the title.
- March 7, 2011 – ROH TV (Taped): Kyle O’Reilly defeated Michael Elgin in the semi-finals of the top prospect tournament.
- March 12, 2011 – AAW: AAW Heritage champion Shane Hollister defeated Michael Elgin to retain the title.
- March 17, 2011 – TWE: Tomer Shalom defeated Marcus Marquez and Michael Elgin in a 3-way match.
- March 18, 2011 – ROH Defy and Deny: Eddie Edwards defeated Michael Elgin.
- March 19, 2011 – ROH Mayhem in Manhatten: Adam Cole and Kyle O’Reilly defeated Michael Elgin and Mike Mondo.
- Michael Elgin signed a contract with ROH on March 19, 2011, tying him to the company through December 2012.
- March 26, 2011 – C4: Tyson Dux defeated Michael Elgin.
- March 27, 2011 – MPW: Michael Elgin defeated Scotty O’Shea and Ashley Sixx in a 3-way match.
- April 1, 2011 – ROH Honor Takes Center Stage night 1: Michael Elgin defeated El Generico.
- April 2, 2011 – ROH Honor Takes Center Stage night 2: Christopher Daniels defeated Michael Elgin w/ Truth Martini.
- April 9, 2011 – wXw: Michael Elgin and Johnny Moss defeated Big Van Walter and Brodie Lee.
- April 10, 2011 – A1: The Convoy (Brodie Lee, Dan Magnum, Logan Savage and Steve Brown) defeated Team Alpha-1 (Justin Sane, Luis Aveiro, Michael Elgin and Mike Rollins).
- April 16, 2011 – AAW: Jimmy Jacobs defeated Michael Elgin.
- April 23, 2011 – NSPW: Michael Elgin vs. Ashley Sixx ended in a double count-out. Scotty Turner defeated Michael Elgin.
- April 29, 2011 – PWE: PWE Open Weight champion Michael Elgin defeated Brent B to retain the title.
- April 30, 2011 – C4: Michael Elgin defeated Brodie Lee.
- May 6, 2011 – ROH Revolution: Michael Elgin defeated Andy Ridge.
- May 7, 2011 – ROH Revolution: Michael Elgin defeated Adam Cole, Andy Ridge, Grizzly Redwood, Rhett Titus and Tommaso Ciampa in a scramble match.
- May 12, 2011 – MPW: Michael Elgin and Jake O’Reilly defeated Derek Wylde and Phil Atlas.
- May 13, 2011 – AAW: Michael Elgin defeated Alex Shelley.
- May 14, 2011 – CWI: X-Pac defeated Michael Elgin.
- May 15, 2011 – MPW: Michael Elgin defeated Josh Alexander in a #1 contenders match for the Triple Crown title.
- May 15, 2011 – CWI Event in Canada: Sean Waltman defeated Michael Elgin.
- May 20, 2011 – ROH Super Card of Honor: Homicide defeated Michael Elgin with Truth Martini.
- May 27, 2011 – MPW: MPW Triple Crown champion Tyson Dux defeated Michael Elgin to retain the title.
- May 28, 2011 – MPW: Jimmy Jacobs defeated Michael Elgin.
- June 5, 2011 – MPW: Jayson Cyprus defeated Michael Elgin and Sonjay Dutt in a 3-way match.
- June 11, 2011 – MPW: Michael Elgin and Jake O’Reilly defeated Brent B and Phil Atlas.
- June 12, 2011 – A1: Josh Alexander defeated Michael Elgin, Justin Sane and Mike Rollins in a 4-way match to win the A1 Alpha Male title.
- June 17, 2011 – C4: Michael Elgin defeated Chris Hero.
- June 18, 2011 – CCW: Michael Elgin defeated Davey Richards.
- June 19, 2011 – CCW Live Event in Canada: Michael Elgin defeated Davey Richards.
- June 26, 2011 – ROH Best in the World: Michael Elgin defeated Steve Corino.
- July 2, 2011 – MPW Event in Canada: Michael Elgin defeated Kiyoshi, Brent B, and Ashley Sixx in a 4-way match.
- July 3, 2011 – MPW Event in Canada: Kiyoshi defeated Michael Elgin.
-
July 8, 2011 – ROH Tag Team Turmoil: Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards defeated Michael Elgin and Roderick Strong.
- July 9, 2011 – ROH No Escape: Caprice Coleman and Cedric Alexander defeated Michael Elgin and Chase Owens.
- July 23, 2011 – AAW: Michael Elgin defeated Brent B.
- July 24, 2011 – FIGHT! 2: Michael Elgin defeated Mike Rollins.
- July 30, 2011 – MPW: MPW Triple Crown champion Tyson Dux defeated Michael Elgin and Jayson Cyprus in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- July 31, 2011 – A1: Michael Elgin defeated Jimmy Jacobs and Mike Rollins in a 3-way match.
- August 12, 2011 – Fighting Back: Low Ki defeated Michael Elgin.
- August 18, 2011 – NSPW: Andrew Davis defeated Michael Elgin in a chairs match.
- August 20, 2011 – CCW: Sabu defeated Michael Elgin.
- August 21, 2011 – C4: Mike Rollins defeated Michael Elgin by disqualification.
- September 9, 2011 – CCW: Cezar defeated Michael Elgin.
- September 10, 2011 – MPW: Michael Elgin defeated Matt Cross.
- September 11, 2011 – CCW: CCW heavyweight champion Deamon Reznor defeated Michael Elgin to retain the title.
-
September 17, 2011 – ROH Death Before Dishonor IX: Charlie Haas defeated Michael Elgin.
- September 23, 2011 – MPW: Crazzy Steve defeated Michael Elgin.
- September 24, 2011 – CCW: Michael Elgin defeated Shawn Spears.
- September 25, 2011 – SCW: Michael Elgin defeated Kevin Steen in the 1st round of the SCW premier title tournament.
- September 30, 2011 – AAW: Michael Elgin defeated Arik Cannon.
- October 15, 2011 – ROH TV: Eddie Edwards defeated Michael Elgin in a rematch from Defy or Deny PPV.
- October 22, 2011 – NSPW: Franky the Mobster defeated Michael Elgin.
- October 23, 2011 – A1: Michael Elgin defeated Brodie Lee to win the A1 Zero gravity title. Mike Rollins defeated Michael Elgin in a no disqualification match.
- October 23, 2011 – A1: A1 Alpha Male champion Josh Alexander defeated A1 Zero Gravity champion Michael Elgin to win the title in a match where both titles were on the line.
- October 28, 2011 – AAW: Michael Elgin defeated Mason Beck to win the AAW heritage title.
- October 31, 2011 – Fight ! 3: Michael Elgin defeated Josh Alexander.
- November 5, 2011 – ROH TV: Michael Elgin defeated Shiloh Jonze.
- November 6, 2011 – ROH Gateway to Honor: Michael Elgin defeated Grizzly Redwood.
- November 11, 2011 – SCW: Michael Elgin defeated Brent Banks in the semi-finals of the SCW premier title tournament.
- November 12, 2011 – SCW: Pepper Parks defeated Michael Elgin to win the vacant SCW premier title.
- November 12, 2011 ROH TV (Taped): Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards defeated Roderick Strong and Michael Elgin.
-
November 18, 2011 – ROH Survival of the Fittest: Michael Elgin defeated Adam Cole, Kenny King and Tommaso Ciampa in a 4-way qualifying match for the survival of the fittest finals. Michael Elgin defeated Roderick Strong, Jay Briscoe, Eddie Edwards, Kyle O’Reilly and Mark Briscoe in the survival of the fittest finals.
- November 19, 2011 – ROH Glory by Honor X: Michael Elgin defeated Adam Cole, Mike Bennett and Grizzly Redwood.
- November 20, 2011 – TCW: Michael Elgin defeated Brent Banks.
- November 26, 2011 – AAW: AAW heritage champion Michael Elgin defeated BJ Whitmer to retain the title.
- November 26, 2011 – ROH TV (Taped): Michael Elgin w/Truth Martini defeated Sean Casey & Raphael Constantine in a handicap match.
- December 3, 2011 – ROH Southern Defiance: Charlie Haas and Shelton Benjamin defeated Roderick Strong and Michael Elgin.
- December 4, 2011 – ROH Northern Aggression: Eddie Edwards, El Generico and Wrestling’s Greatest Tag Team defeated Roderick Strong, Michael Elgin and The Briscoes.
- December 17, 2011 – ROH TV: ROH World Champion “The American Wolf” Davey Richards defeated “Unbreakable” Michael Elgin w/Truth Martini.
- December 23, 2011 – ROH Final Battle: Michael Elgin w/ Truth Martini defeated TJ Perkins.