| Champion | Date | Location | Event |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tyler Bate | 01/15/17 | Blackpool, England | Championship Tournament |
| Pete Dunn | 05/20/17 | Chicago, IL | NXT TakeOver: Chicago |
| WALTER | 04/05/19 | New York City, NY | WWE NXT TakeOver: New York |
| Ilja Dragunov | 08/22/21 | Orlando, FL | NXT TakeOver - 36 |