September 10, 2011–OOW/NWA Coastal: Alex Payne defeated Joey Spades.
September 10, 2011–CZW: The Latin Dragon defeated Alex Payne in a dark match.
September 16, 2011–F1: Pelle Primeau defeated Alex Payne.
September 24, 2011–RCW: Alex Payne defeated T-Jay Sykes.
October 7, 2011–NWA Revival: Alex Payne defeated Kevin Douglas in the 1st round.
October 9, 2011–CZW Wired TV Taping: Alex Payne defeated The Latin Dragon.
November 5, 2011–RCW: Milo Shizo defeated Alex Payne.
November 12, 2011–CZW: BLK OUT (Alex Colon, Rich Swann & Ruckus) defeated The Runaways (Joe Gacy & Ryan Slater) & Alex Payne.
November 19, 2011–NWA Coastal: Alex Payne defeated Josh Adams.
December 3, 2011–CZW: Drew Gulak defeated Alex Payne, Derek Frazier, Dustin Rayz, Ryan McBride and tHURTeen in a 6-way match to become #1 contender for the world heavyweight title.
December 9, 2011–FSW/2KW: Peter Ash Rubinski defeated Alex Payne.
January 28, 2012–NWA Coastal: Ricky Reyes defeated Alex Payne to retain the Iron Man title.
February 25, 2012–FSW: Alex Payne defeated Angel Ortiz, Joe Ettell, Latin Dragon and Mike Draztik in a 5-way match.
March 3, 2012–ECWA: Shane Strickland defeated Alex Payne.
March 24, 2012–GBW: Simon Ryme defeated Alex Payne.
March 25, 2012–RCW: Joe Gacy and Ryan Slater defeated Alex Payne and Niles Young to win the vacant tag team titles.
March 31, 2012–Sideshow Pro: Johnny Calzone defeated Alex Payne.
April 20, 2012–FSW: Angel Ortiz defeated Alex Payne.
May 12, 2012–NWA Coastal: Alex Payne vs. Kevin Tibbs in the 1st round ended in a time limit draw. Sebastian Cruz defeated Alex Payne, Damien Alexander and Josh Adams in a 4-way semi-finals, no disqualification match.
May 26, 2012–FSW: Alex Payne defeated Green Ant, Jack Gallow, Joey Ace and Soldier Ant in a 5-way match.
June 22, 2012–Sideshow Pro: Alex Payne defeated Fredo Majors.
June 23, 2012–FSW: Alex Payne defeated Mike Draztik.
August 4, 2012–NWA Coastal: Sebastian Cruz defeated Alex Payne to become #1 contender for the NWA Coastal Iron Man title.
August 25, 2012–GBW: Jimmy Starz defeated Alex Payne to retain the world title.
October 6, 2012–RCW: Alex Payne defeated Skull.
October 20, 2012–Sideshow Pro Wrestling: Alex Payne defeated Ty Hagen.
November 3, 2012–RCW: The Hell Cats (Jimmy Starz and Sexy Steve) defeated Alex Payne and Niles Young.
November 17, 2012–NWA Coastal: Absolute James defeated Alex Payne.
February 16, 2013–GBW: Alexander James defeated Alex Payne.
March 9, 2013–Coastal: Ricky Reyes defeated Alex Payne to retain the Coastal Iron Man title.
April 26, 2013–Xcite: Marc Krieger defeated Alex Payne, Devon Moore and Kimber Lee in a 4-way, 1st round match.
April 27, 2013–Coastal: The 4ce (Alex Payne and Johnny Calzone) defeated Biggie Biggs and Ricky Reyes.
July 20, 2013–Coastal: Josh Adams defeated Alex Payne and Braydon Knight in a 3-way match.
July 27, 2013–Side Show Pro Return Of The Sideshow: Alex Payne defeated Mighty Mo.
August 9, 2013–Xcite: Kage & Nick Napoleon defeats Alex Payne & Kimber Lee.
April 19, 2014–GBW: Big Buddha defeated Alex Payne.
June 20, 2014–Xcite: Alex Payne and Greg Excellent defeated Joe Gacy and Niles Sozio.
August 2, 2014–GBW: Alex Payne and Sozio defeated The Hellfire Club (Fred Flash and Hayne).
November 15, 2014–Xcite: Joe Gacy defeated Alex Payne.
April 25, 2015–Xcite: Joe Gacy defeated Alex Payne in the 1st round.
May 8, 2015–Side Show Pro Back To Basics: Alex Payne defeated Will Mason.
June 26, 2015–Side Show Pro The Fake Sound Of Progress: Alex Payne defeated The Latin Dragon.
August 19, 2015–CZW Dojo Wars: Nate Carter defeated Alex Payne.
August 29, 2015–HOB: Ted Goods defeated Alex Payne.
August 30, 2015–OPW: Conor Claxton defeated Alex Payne.
September 11, 2015–Side Show Pro The Young And The Wrestlers: The Latin Dragon defeated Alex Payne.
September 16, 2015–CZW Dojo Wars: Alex Payne defeated TJ Sykes.
October 9, 2015–Side Show Pro Oh The Horror Of An October Night: Alex Payne defeated The Latin Dragon in a best 2 out of 3 falls match.
December 4, 2015–Xcite: Joe Gacy defeated Alex Payne in a last man standing match.
January 2, 2016–OPW: Sam Shields defeated Alex Payne and Joe Gacy and Neiko Sozio in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title.
February 10, 2016–CZW Dojo Wars: Alex Payne defeated Swift Kick.
February 19, 2016–Xcite: Alex Payne defeated Alexander James, Jay Freddie, Mike Skyros, Pinkie Sanchez and Sozio in a 6-way match.
March 5, 2016–OPW: Alex Payne defeated Joe Gacy.
March 19, 2016–PPW: Dan Maff defeated Alex Payne.
April 30, 2016–Xcite: Marc Hauss defeated Alex Payne.
May 7, 2016–OPW: Gran Akuma defeated Alex Payne.
June 5, 2016–PWE: Alex Payne defeated Joe Gacy and Worker Ant in a 3-way match.
July 30, 2016–Xcite: Alex Payne defeated Marc Hauss.
September 9, 2016–PWE: Alex Payne defeated Habib From The Car Wash.
September 24, 2016–OPW: Alex Payne defeated Conor Claxton, Devon Moore and Pelle Primeau in a 4-way match.
November 6, 2016–Xcite: Marc Hauss defeated Alex Payne.
December 3, 2016–OPW: Unbreakable Andy defeated Alex Payne and Drake Chambers in a 3-way, 1st round match.
December 9, 2016–PWE: Alex Payne defeated Argus.
January 28, 2017–OPW: Drake Chambers and Unbreakable Andy defeated Alex Payne and Pelle Primeau.
March 4, 2017–OPW: Billy Avery and Qefka The Quiet defeated Alex Payne and Pelle Primeau.
July 16, 2017–PWE/ASP: Alex Payne vs. Tracy Williams ended in a double count-out.
July 22, 2017–OPW: Kyle The Beast defeated Alex Payne, Dan O’Hare and Xavier Cross in a 4-way, semi-finals match.
September 8, 2017–PWE: Alex Payne defeated Joe Gacy, Delirious, Juan Francisco de Coronado, The Ouroboros and Tracy Williams in a 6-way match to win the vacant PWE title.
September 15, 2017–Xcite: Team Xcite (Axel Lennox, Greg Excellent, Joe Gacy, Rob Cook and Sean Carr) defeated Crusade For Change (Alex Payne, Anthony Gangone, Pat Sawyer, Stockade and TJ Marconi) in a War Games rules match.
September 23, 2017–OPW: Alex Payne defeated Pelle Primeau.
January 13, 2018–OPW: Xavier Cross defeated Alex Payne, Jason Furious and Unbreakable Andy in a 4-way match.