February 28, 2004–NWA Florida: Stash and David Mercury defeated Mikey Batts & Erick Stevens, Antonio Banks & Scoot Andrews and Mikey Tenderfoot & Rod Steel in a 4-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
March 13, 20, 2004–NWA Florida: NWA Florida tag team champions Stash & David Mercury defeated Mikey Batts & Erick Stevens to retain the titles.
May 15, 2004–NWA Florida: Naphtali defeated Mikey Batts.
May 23, 2004–WrestleJam 1: Mikey Batts defeated J-Busta.
June 5, 2004–NWA Florida: Naphtali defeated Andre Lyonz, Chasyn Rance, David Babylon, Krazy K, Lit and Mikey Batts in a 6-way elimination match.
June 12, 2004–NWA Florida: Jerrelle Clark defeated Mikey Batts to retain the NWA Junior Heavyweight title..
NWA Florida + NWA Total Nonstop Action:
June 2004: Mikey Bates works as on-air “security” for the first few episodes of TNA Impact in Orlando, FL..
October 29, 2005 – TNT: Sonjay Dutt defeated Mikey Batts and Ultra Dragon in a 3-way match.
Deep South Wrestling:
October 30, 2005: Mikey Batts signed a developmental contract with WWE and will report to Deep South Wrestling..
November 5, 2005–Pro Wrestling Warfare: Mikey Batts defeated Pretty Fly..
Ohio Valley Wrestling:
January 18, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Da Beast w/Titus defeated Mickey Batts..
January 21, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mickey Batts defeated Dean Visk..
January 22, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: C.M. Punk defeated Mickey Batts..
January 25, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Titus defeated Mickey Batts with help from Da Beast..
January 26, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mickey Batts defeated Titus w/Da Beast..
January 28, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mickey Batts defeated Da Beast w/Titus..
February 8, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: The Spirit Squad (Johnny Jeter, Ken Doane, Mike Mondo, Nick Mitchell & Nick Nemeth) defeated Danny Inferno, Mikey Batts, Russell Simpson & The Riggs Brothers (Jason Riggs & Johnny Riggs).
March 8, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Mikey Batts defeated Tony Mann in a dark match..
March 11, 2006–OVW: Jack Bull beat Pat Buck and Discord and Bad News and Luis Almodovar and Mikey Batts in a 6-WAY
March 15, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Gene Snitsky defeated Mikey Batts..
March 19, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mikey Batts defeated “Platnum” Pat Buck..
March 25, 2006–North East Wrestling: Mikey Batts defeated Romeo Roselli..
April 5, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Ryan Reeves & Mikey Batts defeated Billy Kryptonite & Russell Simpson..
April 8, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Ryan Reeves & Mikey Batts defeated Jack Bull & Vic Devine..
April 12, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Mikey Batts defeated Just Chad (Tank Toland ran in but security held him back)..
April 19, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Duece defeated Mikey Batts..
April 21, 2006–NEW: Josh Daniels defeated Mikey Batts.
May 5, 2006 – SmackDown!: Gregory Helms defeated Mike Altieri (aka Mikey Batts) in a match taped for Velocity to retain the cruiserweight title..
May 13, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: K.C. James & Roadkill beat Ryan Reeves & Mikey Batts to retain the Tag Team titles..
May 17, 2006–OVW TV Tapings: Aaron ‘the Idol’ Stevens defeated Mikey Batts..
June 2, 2006–OVW Six Flags: Boris Alexiev defeated Mikey Batts..
June 3, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mikey Batts & Shawn Spears defeated Los Locos (Aaron Lamata & Lowrider)..
June 8, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Deuce & Domino & Jack Bull defeated Cody Runnels & Elijah Burke & Mikey Batts..
June 9, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Deuce & Domino & Aaron Stevens defeated Chet the Jet & Mikey Batts & C.M. Punk..
June 10, 2006–Ohio Valley Wrestling: Mikey Batts defeated Shawn Spears..
July 29, 2006–SCW: Kahagas defeated Mikey Batts..
October 14, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Dynamic Sensation defeated Mikey Batts in Milford, Pennsylvania..
November 3, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Mikey Batts defeated Ricky Landell..
December 9, 2006–Northeast Wrestling: Hale Collins & Vic Delicious w/Tina Marina beat Mikey Batts & Jeff Starr..
April 21, 2007–Northeast Wrestling: Josh Daniels defeated Mikey Batts in Bristol, Connecticut..
April 27, 2007–Northeast Wrestling: Josh Daniels defeated Mikey Batts and Jason Blade in a 3-WAY..
Michael Altieri retired from pro-wrestling to pursue a career in MMA – which did not go so well..
Michael Altieri (Mikey Batts) was hired by World Wrestling Entertainment to perform as a referee.
January 25, 2014–NWA FUW: Wes Brisco defeated Mikey Batts.
February 21, 2014–NWA FUW: Jeff Boom & Mitch Mitchell defeated Mikey Batts & Wayne Van Dyke.
March 7, 2014–NWA FUW: Aaron Solo, Lince Dorado & Milo Beasley defeated James Alexander, Mikey Batts & Wayne Van Dyke.
April 12, 2014–NWA FUW: James Alexander & Mikey Batts defeated The Worst Case Scenario (Elijah Evans IV & Ethan Case).