August 24, 2003 – Ballpark Brawl I in Buffalo, New York after the Buffalo Bisons (AAA baseball team) game: Little Louie b King Sleazy, A.J. Styles b Kid Kash, Trinity b Tracy Brooks, Jimmy Snuka b Nikolai Volkoff (subbing for King Kong Bundy), Disco Inferno b Norman Smiley, Jeff Jarrett and Sabu b Raven and Disco Inferno.
July 17, 2004 – Ballpark Brawl II – Field of Screams in Buffalo, New York after the Bisons Game: Jonny Puma and Jimmy Hart vs Charisma and Puff (local sports talk host feuding with Jimmy Hart to build up the show) ended in a NO CONTEST, Next four matches were first round of the Natural tournament: Julio Dinero b Petey Williams, Abyss b Cody Steele, Ron Killings b Johnny Swinger, Teddy Hart b Derek Wylde, Jim Duggan b Buff Bagwell, Piper’s Pit with Abyss, Sean O’Haire b Abyss by DQ , Al Snow b Chris Candido. No-shows included Konnan, Greg Valentine, Shane Douglas and Zach Gowen.
August 14, 2004 – Ballpark Brawl III in Buffalo, New York: Jim Neidhart b Johnny Puma, Derek Wylde b Cody Steel, Jimmy Hart b [INSERT], Ron Killings vs Abyss ended in a NO CONTEST (both eliminated from tournament), Harry Smith b Petey Williams, Bret Hart cut a promo on the show, and was reunited with Jim Neidhart and Jimmy Hart, Teddy Hart (who held up a “Ric Flair Sucks” sign) b Harry Smith to win Natural title in tournament final (Bret Hart presented the trophy), Nattie Neidhart b Tracy Brooks, Christopher Daniels b Amazing Red, A.J. Styles b Teddy Hart and Sabu (managed by Bill Alfonso) in a 3-WAY to win the Natural title.
July 15, 2005 – Ballpark Brawl IV in Buffalo, New York: The Backseat Boyz (Trent Acid and Johnny Kashmere) b The Outkast Killaz (Oman Tortuga and Diablo Santiago), John McChesney b Johnny Devine by surviving a 5:00 challenge, Matt Striker b Johnny Devine, Chris Sabin b Roderick Strong and Jay Lethal and Petey Williams and Shawn Spears and Mastiff in a 6-WAY, Abyss vs Slyck Wagner Brown ended in a NO CONTEST, C.M. Punk b Homicide, Dusty Rhodes b Kid Kash, Ariel b April Hunter, Christopher Daniels b A.J. Styles in a 2/3 Falls match to win the Natural Heavyweight title | Teddy Hart no-showed and C.M. Punk ran him down saying it was due to previous problems. So Homicide wrestled Punk.
August 13, 2005 – Ballpark Brawl in Buffalo, New York before an estimated 900 fans: Sonjay Dutt b Trent Acid, Harry Smith b Damien Alexander and Glenn Spectre and John McChesney and Matt Stryker and Bobby Rude in a 6-WAY Elimination #1 Contenders match, Charlie Haas cut a promo saying he was “Charlie Haas, singles superstar”, Jimmy T (Local DJ) and Kamala b Jimmy Hart and Lanny Poffo, Abyss b Slyck Wagner Brown in a Bullrope match, Petey Williams and Eric Young b Shawn Spears and Derek Wylde, Mick Foley segment (Foley made fun of Matt Striker, who came out and did an impersonation of the Rock. Foley gave him the Mr. Socko down the throat), Bill Alfonso and Todd Gordon made appearances, Jackie Gayda (as “Just Jackie”) won Battle Royal (Including: Tracy Brooks, Nattie Neidhart, Jamie D and April Hunter), Christopher Daniels vs Chris Sabin vs Charlie Haas ended in a 20:00 time limit draw (Daniels retains the Natural title) – – They were granted five more minutes, where Charlie Haas pinned Chris Daniels to win the Natural title!, Sandman b Sabu in a Cane, Tables and Chairs match with Mick Foley counting the 1-2-3 – – Sandman forced Mick Foley to drink a beer after the match. He then climbed the ladder, lost his balance, and fell off.
August 14, 2005 – Ballpark Brawl in Rochester, New York before 250 fans (the baseball game was canceled and they moved the ring indoors): Roderick Strong b Kudo, The Ring Crew Express (Dunn and Marcos) b The Backseat Men (Trent Acid and Johnny Kashmere), Nattie Neidhart b April Hunter and Jackie Gayda in a 3-WAY, Kamala b Matt Striker (who was imitating Randy Savage), Charlie Haas b Harry Smith with Mick Foley as referee (the ring broke so they had to work their match around a hole in the ring), Homicide won Battle Royal throwing out T.J. Wilson in the end.
August 27, 2006 – Ballpark Brawl VII in Buffalo, New York before 700 fans: The Italianos (Primo Scordino and Tony Carbonie) b Rhythm and Booze (Frank The Tank and Buddy Delmar w/Krystal Banks) to retain the NVPW Tag Team titles, Jonny Puma b T.J. Harley and Crazzy Steve and Derek Duncam and Eric Everlast and Mastiff in a 6-WAY Scramble, “Fabulous” John McChesney b Phil Atlas to retain the NWA Upstate No Limits Title and win the NVPW Pride Title and earn a spot in the 6-MAN Scramble | Main Show: Ruckus b Chris Hero and J.D. Michaels and Delirious and John McChesney and Big Cat Lemmer in a 6-WAY Scramble, Samoa Joe b Steve Corino for a spot in the main event, Teddy Hart b Ruckus, Trent Acid and Teddy Fine (sub for Johnny Kashmere) b Up in Smoke (Cheech and Cloudy) and Ring Crew Express (Dunn and Marcos) and Sterling James Keenen and Brodie Lee in a 4-WAY Tables match, Colt Cabana b Claudio Castagnoli with Chip Stetson as referee, Sgt. Slaughter celebrated his birthday and put the cobra clutch on Cody Deaner w/Krystal Banks, T and A (Talia Madison and April Hunter) b Daizee Haze and Cherry-bomb by DQ with Jaime D and Jennifer Blake as guest referees, Monty Brown b Matt Morgan w/Hellcat, Samoa Joe b Christopher Daniels and Low Ki and Homicide in a 4-WAY “Belt on a Pole” match to win the Natural title.
August 23, 2007 – Ballpark Brawl VIII in Buffalo, New York at Dunn Tire Park: Jake O’Reilly won a Buffalo Royal Rumble, Cody Deaner and Krystal Banks w/Dewey b Cody 45 and Sara Del Rey, Xtremo b Kevin Dunnt to win the Young Lyons Trophy, “M-Dogg20” Matt Cross b Ruckus, Brutus Beefcake b Jonny Puma and Cody Deaner in a Hair vs. Hair vs. Mullet match (Puma lost his hair), Sterling James Keenan b El Generico and Trent Acid and PAC and John McChesney and Xtremo in a 6-WAY Futures match, Claudio Castagnoli b Delirious in a European Rules match via judge’s decision (Judges were “Dr. Of Style” Slick, Big Mosh from Monday Night Mayhem, and Jaime D.), Steve Corino and Ricky Reyes b Detox and Devon Moore and Brodie Lee and Big Cat Lemmer in a Tag Team Tables Turmoil match (Corino was the only man that didn’t go through a table to earn the win for his team), Gail Kim and Kelly Couture b Tracy Brooks and Sara Del Rey with guest referee Jennifer Blake, 2 Cold Scorpio b Joey Matthews to retain the PWU Heavyweight title, Sterling James Keenan w/Hellcat b Samoa Joe and Rikishi by Countout (20 Count) to win the Natural Heavyweight title – Notes: All 3 then danced together in the ring after Joe beat up Keenan’s manager Hellcat in the corner to allow Rikishi to give him the Stink Face.